BEFORE THE KARNATAKA STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, BANGALORE. (ADDL. BENCH)

DATED THIS THE 11^th DAY OF FEBRUARY 2022

PRESENT

SRI RAVI SHANKAR – JUDICIAL MEMBER

SMT. SUNITA C.BAGEWADI - MEMBER

APPEAL NOS. 1743/2013 & 1823/2013

APPEAL NO. 1743/2013

1.    M/S Deepashree Hospital,

       No.86, 2^nd Main Road, 16^th

       D Cross, Nagarbhavi, 2^nd Stage,

       Bangalore-72,

       Rep. by its Managing Partner.

2.    Dr. C.N.Shreedhar (Physician),

       S/o Chowdaiah, A/a 43 years,

       M/s Deepashree Hospital,

       No.86, 2^nd Main Road,

       16^th D Cross, Nagarbhavi,

       2^nd Stage, Bangalore-72.

(By Shri. B.R.Deepak, Adv.,)

……….Appellant/s.

                                          -Versus-

1.       Smt. Varalakshmi S W/o Shivanna .N

A/a 35 years, R/at 3^rd Cross,

Hosahalli Extension, Mandya City,

Mandya District.

2.       M/s United India Insurance Co., Ltd.,

          No.89/1, 2^nd Floor, 11^th Cross,

          Sampige Road, Malleshwaram,

          Bangalore-03, Rep. by its Manager.

(R1- By Sri. T.P.Vivekananda, Adv.,)

……….Respondent/s

APPEAL NO. 1823/2013

The Manager, United India Insurance Co., Ltd.,

No.89/1, 2^nd Floor, 11^th Cross,

Sampige Road, Malleshwaram,

Bangalore-03,

Now Reptd. by its Regional Manager,

United India Insurance Co., Ltd.,

Regional Office, 5^th & 6^th Floor,

Krishi Bhavan, Nrupathunga Road,

Bangalore-560 001.

 (By Shri. A.N.Krishnaswamy, Adv.,)

……….Appellant/s.

                                          -Versus-

1.       Smt. Varalakshmi S W/o Shivanna .N

A/a 36 years, R/at 3^rd Cross,

Hosahalli Extension,

Mandya City,

Mandya District.

2.    M/S Deepashree Hospital,

No.86, 2^nd Main Road, 16^th

D Cross, Nagarbhavi, 2^nd Stage,

Bangalore-72,

Rep. by its Managing Partner.

3.    Dr. C.N.Shreedhar (Physician),

S/o Chowdaiah, A/a 33 years,

M/s Deepashree Hospital,

No.86, 2^nd Main Road,

16^th D Cross, Nagarbhavi,

2^nd Stage, Bangalore-72.

………Respondent/s

 (R1 – Sri. T.P.Vivekananda, Adv.,)

: O R D E R :

BY SMT. SUNITA C.BAGEWADI - MEMBER

The appeal No.1743/2013 has been filed by the appellant/Opposite Party Nos.1&2 and the Appeal No.1823/2013 has been filed by the appellant/Opposite Party No.3 being aggrieved by the order dated:24/10/2013 passed by Bangalore Urban District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission and prays to set-aside the order and to dismiss the complaint filed by the complainant.

2.       The Opposite Parties Nos. 1 & 2 and the Opposite Party No.3 have filed these 02 appeals against the same order and the subject matter involved in these appeals are one and the same.  Hence, for the sake of convenience, both these appeals are taken up together to pass a common order.  

3.     The parties to the appeal shall be referred to as complainant and OPs respectively as per their rankings before the District Forum.

4.       The brief facts of the complaint are as under:-

The complainant slipped and fell down from the moving train, while she was trying to catch a train a