KERALA STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION SISUVIHARLANE VAZHUTHACADU THIRUVANANTHAPURM
OP.NO.09/03
JUDGMENT DATED :30.04.2015
PRESENT
SRI.K.CHANDRADAS NADAR : JUDICIAL MEMBER
SMT.A.RADHA : MEMBER
SMT.SANTHAMMA THOMAS : MEMBER
COMPLAINANTS
1. Mary George,
Kayyalackakom,
Kuravankonam Junction,
Thiruvananthapuram – 695 003 (Died)
2. K.G.Kuruvila,
Kayyalackakom,
Kuravankonam Junction,
Thiruvananthapuram – 695 003
3. K.Joseph Cherian,
Kayyalackakom,
A-22 Jawahar Nagar,
Thiruvananthapuram
(By Adv.Sri.Shyampadman)
ADDITIONAL COMPLAINANTS IMPLEADED
4. K.G.Mathew,
S/o.Late Mary George,
VH – 182, East Pattom,
Thiruvananthapuram
OPPOSITE PARTY
1. P.S.Biju,
Advocate,
“Ramjyothy”, Kaloor Cross Road,
Ernakulam
ADDITIONAL 2nd OPPOSITE PARTY
5. K.G.Augustine,
S/o.Late Mary George,
VH-56, Kuravankonam,
Thiruvananthapuram -3
(By order dated 05.09.2013 the additional 5th complainant was
transposed as supplemental 2nd opposite party)
(OP5 by Adv.Sri.N.R.Suresh Kumar)
JUDGMENT
SRI.K.CHANDRADAS NADAR : JUDICIAL MEMBER
This is a petition filed under section 17 of the Consumer Protection Act. The first petitioner, the mother of the second petitioner died during the pendency of the proceedings and her legal heirs were impleaded as additional petitioners 4 & 5 along with petitioner no.2. The first petitioner was the 'E' Claimant in LAR case Numbers 44/86 & 45/86 before the Additional Sub Court, Thrissur. The second petitioner, the son of the first petitioner and Late.K.M.George, Kayyalackakom was the 'J' Claimant in the said LAR cases. The third petitioner, the son of Late.K.M.Joseph, Kayyalackakom and Late. Thressiamma Joseph, were 'G' & 'B' Claimants in the said LAR cases. The opposite party is an Advocate practising before Ernakulam courts. It is alleged in the complaint that the opposite party was entrusted with the conduct of the LAR cases. The first petitioner and her husband were instrumental in engaging the opposite party Advocate for conducting the LAR cases on behalf of all the claimants and they did so believing that the opposite party would be trustworthy. All the correspondences and communications were carried out between the second petitioner and the opposite party. The second petitioner was authorized to adduce evidence far and on behalf of all the claimants. The fees due to the opposite party was also paid by the second petitioner and receipts of payments were acknowledged by the opposite party.
2. Awards were passed in the LAR cases on 05.03.1991. Undisbursed portion of the land value deposited in court d were ordered to be released to the claimants prior to the award on 05.03.1991. Out of an amount of Rs.24,95,725.29/- that was deposited in court an amount of Rs.18,60,000/- was released to the advocate on 25.08.1987, out of which only an amount of Rs.15 lakhs was handed over to the second claimant for payment to A,F.G,I & J Claimants and Rs.3,00,000/- was given to the son of 'H' Claimant. However, the opposite party insisted for receipt for the entire amount of Rs.18,60,000/- and demanded Rs.60,000/- towards fees and expense though he had demanded only Rs.10,000/- towards fees as per letter dated 07.07.86. Rs.5000/- was accepted by the opp.party Advocate on 27.05.86. He had demanded Rs.10,000/- in October and another 15,000/- to be paid later.
3. On 31.10.2001 it came to the notice of the petitioners that though the balance amount of Rs.5,83,765/- was received by the opp.party as early as on 16.03.91, the same was not paid to the claimants till date. It is further understood that the opp.party had received Rs.2,88,30,979.49/- through court and another sum of Rs.1,49,14,248.22/- by demand draft from KSEB subsequent to the judgment and decree in the LAR cases and during execution of the decrees. Now after the recent verdict of the Hon'ble Supreme court when verification of the payments made