STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION,
MAHARASHTRA, MUMBAI
Consumer Complaint No.CC/15/218
Mr.Sarwanand Mahanand Mandhan
& Mrs.Sandhya Sarwanand Mandhan
R/o.Flat No.701, Miracle Heights
C.H.Society, Sector 2-A
Koperkhairne, Navi Mumbai 400 709 ….. Complainants
Versus
Rehea Developer
Through its partner
Mr.Kumar Thakurdas Budhrani
Garage no.8, Ground floor
Dinath Wadi, off. L.J.Road
Mahim, Mumbai 400 016
Alternative address
5 Baba Textile
Near Prashutam Bhatia Hall
Gown Bazar, Ulhasnagar 421 005 …….Opponent
BEFORE: Usha S. Thakare, Presiding Judicial Member
A.K.Zade, Member
PRESENT: Mr.T.Dharma-Advocate for complainants
Mr.R.S.Motwani-Advocate for opponent
ORDER
Per Hon’ble Usha S. Thakare, Presiding Judicial Member
1. Complainants-Mr.Sarwanand Mahanand Mandhan and Mrs.Sandhya
Sarwanand Mandhan have filed consumer complaint u/sec.12 r/w.17 of
Consumer Protection Act, 1986 against opponent –Rehea Developers through
its partner by alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.
2. By filing consumer complaint, complainants have claimed possession of
booked flat. They have also claimed order for monthly expenditure from the
agreed date of possession with interest @ 18% p.a. till handing over peaceful
possession of flat. They have requested for amount of Rs.6 lakhs @ Rs.50,000/-
per month from October 2013. In addition, they have claimed compensation of
Rs.25 lakhs for mental pain and agony and an amount of Rs.30,000/- towards
costs of litigation.
3. According to complainants, complainant no.1 is a small businessman
doing the business at Navi Mumbai and complainant no.2 is housewife. They
are living in rented house. They were looking for flat to be purchased. They
wanted to have a flat which is close to their business place and school for
children. Complainants received an offer letter dated 28/08/2012 from the
opponent/builder. Opponent was willing to sell flat no.1001 in the Ventures
Residency, Kharghar. Complainants entered into an agreement with opponent
through partner Mr.Kumar Thakurdas Budhrani. Complainants agreed to
purchase flat no.1001 on 10th floor in Ventures Residency on Plot no.38 & 38A,
Sector 35D, Owe-Kharghar for total consideration of Rs.49,50,000/-. The
opponents agreed to give possession of the flat on or before October 2013.
Complainants agreed to pay total amount of consideration by cheques and by
bank loan. Complainants made total payment during 06/08/2012 to 21/09/2012.
Amount of Rs.20 lakhs was paid on 10/04/2013 by the Corporation Bank. For
obtaining loan property was mortgaged.
4. Complainants had made many attempts since October 2013 to get
possession of booked flat. Complainants visited office of the opponent and
made phone calls about possession of flat. They did not get proper and sound
reply. Complainants had been to office of the opponent at Ulhasnagar with
family friends. Opponent denied to identify the complainants. Opponents
started shouting and abusing for no reason. It was unwarranted attitude and
rude behaviour. Later on opponent conveyed message through Mr.Moorajmal
Santwani that complainants should pay him Rs.25 lakhs more over and above
the full and final amount. Agreement for sale was for Rs.49,50,000/-. Total
agreed consideration was Rs.49,50,000/- for a flat as purchase price. It was
mentioned in the agreement. Complainants paid all agreed amount by cheques
and bank loan. Complainants wrote letter to the opponent about extra demand
of Rs.25 lakhs on 11/08/2014. Letter was duly served under acknowledgement
but it was not replied. Opponent was to hand over possession of flat no.1001 in
Venture Residency to the complainants on or before October 2013.
Complainants are residing in a rented house and travelling long to go to their
work place. Therefore, by filing present complaint, complainants alleged that
opponents are guilty