SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2022 Supreme(Online)(NCDRC) 675

S[; NFB, TFZLBo Z*vZvZ_!(

S[; O[;, TFZLBo #_v(vZ_ZZ

S[; lGSF,GF lNJ;M o $ JQF" & DF; # lNJ;

U|FCS TSZFZ lGJFZ6 SlDXG4 U]HZFT ZFHI4 VDNFJFNP

SM8" G\P $

s!f .P V[P G\P *qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#Z$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

SFG5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P SFG5Z4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

;ZWFZ H]Y lJSF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;ZWFZ4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf .P V[P G\P (qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#Z&qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

SD/F5]Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P SD/F5]Z4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

VF8SM8 ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P VF8SM84 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

5|UlTXL, ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P 5|UlTXL,4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f .P V[P G\P )qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#Z(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

;ZTFG5Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P ;ZTFG5Z4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

VHD[Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P VHD[Z4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$f .P V[P G\P !_qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P##ZqZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

Z]5FJ8L ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P Z]5FJ8L4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DM-]SF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM-]SF4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5f .P V[P G\P !!qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P##5qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

N[JWZL H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P N[JWZL4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DFWJL5]Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DFWJL5]Z4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s&f .P V[P G\P !ZqZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P##(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

VF\AZ0L ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

VF\AZ0L4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

U\]NF/F sHxFPf ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

U\]NF/F sHXPf4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s*f .P V[P G\P !#qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#$#qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

SLXFG ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

XF\lTGUZ4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

lSXFG ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

SD/F5]Z4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s(f .P V[P G\P !$qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#$$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

;JM"NI ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;JM"NI4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DM8F S\W[JF/LIF H]Y lJSF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8F S\W[JF/LIF4 TFP H;N64 HLP ZFHSM8P

s)f .P V[P G\P !5qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#$(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

N,0L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

N,0L4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

R\N=5]Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

R\N=5]Z4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!_f .P V[P G\P !&qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5_qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

J3F;LIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

J3F;LIF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

D[;ZLIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D[;ZLIF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!!f .P V[P G\P !*qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5!qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

JF\SLIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

JF\SLIF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

Z;LSU- H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

Z;LSU-4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!Zf .P V[P G\P !(qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5ZqZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

UFLIFJNZ H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

UFLIFJNZ4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DCLSF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DCLSF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!#f .P V[P G\P !)qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

JF,F;6 ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

JF,F;64 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

B[ZJF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

B[ZJF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!$f .P V[P G\P Z_qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5&qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

S6SM8 V[U|LP ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S6SM84 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

;ZWFZSF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;ZWFZSF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

BLH0LIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BLH0LIF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!5f .P V[P G\P Z!qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5*qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

DF8[, H]Y ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DF8[,4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

5,F; H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

5,F;4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

VZ6L8LdAF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

VZ6L8LdAF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!&f .P V[P G\P ZZqZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#5(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

;L\WFJNZ H]Y ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;L\WFJNZ4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

HF,;LSF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

HF,;LSF4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

5L5/LIF sVUFELf H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

5L5/LIF sVUFELf4 TFP JF\SFG[Z4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s!*f .P V[P G\P Z#qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&!qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

U-SF H]Y ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

U-FSF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

ZFHSM8 TF,]SF V[V[GI]P HTL ;FD] V[;V[DP ,LP4

TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

ZFDGUZ H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

ZFDGUZ4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s!(f .P V[P G\P Z$qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&ZqZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

;ZWFZ H]Y lJSF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;ZWFZ4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DJ0L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DJ0L4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s!)f .P V[P G\P Z5qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&#qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

E]5U- H]Y lJSF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

E]5U-4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DM8F DJF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8F DJF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

RF\R0LIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

RF\R0LIF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ_f .P V[P G\P Z&qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

B[Z0L ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

B[Z0L4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

C0DTLIF sUM,L0Ff ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

C0DTLIF sUM,L0Ff4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

5FZ0L ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

5FZ0L4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ!f .P V[P G\P Z*qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&5qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

D3ZJF0F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D3ZJF0F4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

5F0F;6 H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

5F0F;64 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZZf .P V[P G\P Z(qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&&qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

S:T]ZAFWFD lSXFG ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S:T]ZAFWFD4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

J0F/L ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

J0F/L4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

OF0N ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

OF0N TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ#f .P V[P G\P Z)qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&*qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

A[0L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

A[0L4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

BMB0N0 ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BMB0N04 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

A[0,F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

A[0,F4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ$f .P V[P G\P #_qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

pDZFZL H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

pDZFZL4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

ZOF,F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

ZOF,F4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

ZFH5ZF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

ZFH5ZF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ5f .P V[P G\P #!qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#&)qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

UJZLN0 ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

UJZLN04 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

;6M;ZF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;6M;ZF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ&f .P V[P G\P #ZqZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*_qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

BLH0LIF H]Y B[0]T lJSF; ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BLH0LIF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

HLIF6F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

HLIF6F4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ*f .P V[P G\P ##qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*!qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

BMZF6F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BMZF6F4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

SM9FZLIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

SM9FZLIF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ(f .P V[P G\P #$qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*ZqZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

S]JF0JF H]Y B[0}T lJSF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S]JF0JF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

HF/LIF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

HF/LIF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

S:T]ZAFWFD H]Y lJSF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S:T]ZAFWFD4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZ)f .P V[P G\P #5qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*#qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

TZ30LIF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

TZ30LIF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

C,[gNF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

C,[gNF4 TFP HLP ZFHSM8P

s#_f .P V[P G\P #&qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

J[H,5Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

J[H,5Z4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

RF\RFJNZ0F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

RF\RFJNZ0F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#!f .P V[P G\P #*qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*&qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

S\]TF;L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S\]TF;L4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#Zf .P V[P G\P #(qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#*(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

N[ZF/F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

N[ZF/F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

BLZ. ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BLZ.4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s##f .P V[P G\P #)qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#(ZqZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

EFJ5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

EFJ5Z4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DM8LAZFZ H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8LAZFZ4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#$f .P V[P G\P $_qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#(5qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

GJFUFD ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

GJFUFD4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

BLZ. ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BLZ.4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

DM8LAZFZ ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8LAZFZ4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$f

H]GF 3F\8L,F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

H]GF 3F\8L,F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#5f .P V[P G\P $!qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#()qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

J[H,5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

J[H,5Z4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

BFBZ[RL H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BFBZ[RL4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#&f .P V[P G\P $ZqZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#)_qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

H]GF 3F\8L,F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

H]GF 3F\8L,F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

EFJ5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

EFJ5Z4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#*f .P V[P G\P $#qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#)#qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

BLZF. ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BLZF.4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

GJFUFD ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

GJFUFD4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

DM8L AZFZ ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8L AZFZ4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$f

DM8F NCL\;ZF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8F NCL\;ZF4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5f

S\]TF;L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S\]TF;L4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s&f

,1DLJF; ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

,1DLJF;4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s*f

AU;ZF sJJF6LIFf H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

AU;ZF sJJF6LIFf4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s(f

BLZ;ZF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BLZ;ZF4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#(f .P V[P G\P $$qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#)$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

DM8F E[,F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DM8F E[,F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

EFJ5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

EFJ5Z4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

RF\RFJNZ0F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

RF\RFJNZ0F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$f

;ZJ0 ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;ZJ04 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#)f .P V[P G\P $5qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#)5qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

N[ZF/F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

N[ZF/F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

TZ3ZL ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

TZ3ZL4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$_f .P V[P G\P $&qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#)*qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

J[H,5Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

J[H,5Z4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

BFBZ[RL H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BFBZ[RL4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$!f .P V[P G\P $*qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P#)(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

H]GF 3F\8L,F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

H]GF 3F\8L,F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

H]GF 3F\8L,F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

H]GF 3F\8L,F4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$Zf .P V[P G\P $(qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$#$qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

JF\S0F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

JF\S0F4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

VF\NZ6F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

VF\NZ6F4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

H[T5Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

H[T5Z4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$#f .P V[P G\P $)qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$#(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

A[,F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

A[,F4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

UF/F S<IF6 ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

UF/F S<IF64 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$$f .P V[P G\P 5_qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$$!qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

YMZF/F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

YMZF/F4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

GFZ6SF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

GFZ6SF4 TFP DF/LIF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$5f .P V[P G\P 5!qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$$ZqZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

3]8] ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

3]8]4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

CZL5Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

CZL5Z4 TFP DMZAL4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$&f .P V[P G\P 5ZqZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$*5qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

C0F/F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

C0F/F4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

W|]JGUZ sZFHFJ0f ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

W|]JGUZ4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$*f .P V[P G\P 5#qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$*&qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

BM0F5L5Z H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BM0F5L5Z4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

YMZLIF/L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

YMZLIF/L4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$(f .P V[P G\P 5$qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$**qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

VDZF5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

VDZF5Z4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

JLZ5Z sDrK]f ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

JLZ5ZsDrK]f4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$)f .P V[P G\P 55qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$(_qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

SM9FZLIF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

SM9FZLIF4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

AJ0L ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

AJ0L4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5_f .P V[P G\P 5&qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$(#qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

G[;0F sBFf ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

G[;0F4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

GFGF ZFD5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

GFGF ZFD5Z4 TFP 8\SFZF4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5!f .P V[P G\P 5*qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$)5qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

XLJZFHU- H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

XLJZFHU-4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

UM\0, H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

SM,LY0 H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

SM,LY04 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$f

3M3FJNZ ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

3M3FJNZ4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5Zf .P V[P G\P 5(qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$)&qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

VGL0F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

VGL0F4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

UMD8F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

UMD8F4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

;F\-JFIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

;F\-JFIF4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s$f

5|UlTXL, ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

5|UlTXL,4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5#f .P V[P G\P 5)qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$)*qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

S\8M,LIF H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

S\8M,LIF4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

E]D\0/ ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P E]D\0/4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5$f .P V[P G\P &_qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$)(qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

RZB0L H]Y ;[JFNIL ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

RZB0L4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

;],TFG5]Z H]Y ;[JFNIL ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P ;],TFG5]Z4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

BZ[0F H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

BZ[0F4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s55f .P V[P G\P &!qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P$))qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

5F8LN0 H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

5F8LN04 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

DM8L BL,MZL H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P DM8L BL,MZL4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s#f

;CIMU ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

DMJLIF4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5&f .P V[P G\P &ZqZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P5__qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

N[Z0L H]Y ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

N[Z0L4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

U\]NF;ZF ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P U\]NF;ZF4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

s5*f .P V[P G\P &#qZ_!(

sU|FCS OZLIFN G\P5_!qZ__Z DF\f

VZHNFZ o

s!f

T|FS]0F ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

T|FS]0F4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

sZf

ZF6;LSL ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L ,LP4

D]P ZF6;LSL4 TFP UM\0,4 HLP ZFHSM8P

lJZ]wW

;FDFJF/F o

s!f

V[U|LS<RZ .g:I]Zg; SM5M"Z[XG VMO .lg0IF ,LP4

ZLHLP VMlO; o ;CHFG\N VFS"[04 !#Z O}8 ZL ZM04

D[DGUZ RFZ Z:TF4 VDNFJFNv#(__5ZP

A|FgR VMlO; :8[8 ,[J, o .g:I]Zg; SM5M"Z[XG ;[,4

GFGF,F, R[dA;"4 VFzDZM04 VDNFJFNP

sZf

;[S|[8ZL4

S'lQF VG[ ;CSFZ lJEFU4 ;lRJF,I4 UF\WLGUZP

s#f

WL ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A[gS ,LP4

cc;CIMUcc4 -[AZEF. ZM04 ZFHSM8P

SMZD

o

zLP VF.P 0LP 58[,4 gIFILS ;eIzL

0MP H[P HLP D[[SJFG4 ;eIzL

V[0JMS[8;

o

VZHNFZ TZO[ o lJwJFG JSL, ;]zL VJGLA[G DC[TF

;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ o lJP JSL, zLP JLP 5LP GF6F\J8L

;FDFJF/F G\P Z TZO[ o U[ZCFHZP

;FDFJF/F G\P # TZO[ o ;[<O

C]SD ov 0MP H[P HLP D[SJFG4 ;eIzL DFZOT[

!P

VZHNFZ[ VF NZBF:T ZFHI SDLXGGF TFP Z(vZvZ_!$ GF ZMH

VF5[, R]SFNFGM ;\5}6" VD, G YTF\ VG[ OST VF\lXS VD, YIM CMJFYL VF

SDLXGDF\ NFB, SZ[, K[ VG[ DFL SZ[, K[ S[4 ;FDFJF/F G\P ! GFV[ AFSL

JLDFGL ZSDGL U6TZL :SLDGL HMUJF. VG];FZ SZLG[ R]SJJF5FT| YTL

ZSDDF\YL H[ ZSD 5C[,F\ R]SJF. UI[, K[4 T[ AFN SZLG[ AFSLGL ZSD ;FDFJF/F

G\P # GM0, V[Hg;L4 ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VMP A\[S ,LP G[ R]SJL VF5[P

ZP

VF NZBF:TGF SFD[ VZHNFZGF H6FjIF D]HA VF OZLIFNDF\ Z&)

OZLIFNLVMG\] U'5 CT\]P

H[DF\YL ;FDFJF/F G\P ! GFV[ !!$ OZLIFNLVMG[ VF\lXS

ZSD Z]FP !Z4!*4)_4&!_qv R]SJL VF5L K[ TYF AFSLGL Z]FP !4Z(4!(4$#*qv

GL ZSD TFP Z(vZvZ_!$ GF ZMH R]SJJF lGN"[X SZ[, CMJF KTF\ R]SJ[, GYLP

T[YL VZHNFZ wJFZF VT|[GF SDLXG ;D1F VF NZBF:T VZHL NFB, SZJFDF\

VFJ[, K[ VG[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! AFSLGL ZSD Z]FP !4Z(4!(4$#*qv jIFH ;FY[

R]SJ[ T[JM C]SD SZJF lJG\TL SZ[, K[P

#P

VZHNFZ[ .P V[P G\P *qZ_!( YL !Z_qZ_!( ;]WLGL S], !!$ NZBF:T

VZHL NFB, SZ[, K[P VF AWL NZBF:T VZHL VF ZFHI SDLXGG[ OZLIFN G\P

#!_qZ__Z sD[.Gf TYF T[GL ;FY[ SMg;M,L0[8 SZ[, ALHL OZLIFNMGF SFD[ TFP

Z(vZvZ_!$ GF ZMH SZ[, C]SDGF VD, DF8[ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P

$P

TFP )v&vZ_ZZ GF ZMH VF SDLXG[ .P[ V[P G\P *qZ_!( GL D]bI

NZBF:T VZHL U6L AFSLGL .P V[P G\P (qZ_!( YL .P V[P G\P !Z_qZ_!( G[

T[GL ;FY[ SMg;M,L0[8 SZJFGM C]SD SZ[, K[ VG[ T[YL HIFZ[ VF AWL NZBF:TM

V[S H OZLIFNGF C]SDGF VD, DF8[ SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ VG[ VF AWL NZBF:TGL

CSLST TYF T[DF\ ;\S/FI[, SFINFGF 5|xG V[S H CMI4 VF AWL NZBF:TMGF SFD[

V[S H C]SD SZJFG\] VF SDLXG[ 9ZFJ[, K[P H[DF\YL .P V[P G\P (qZ_!( YL .P

V[P G\P &#qZ_!( GL NZBF:TMDF\ VF C]SD SZJFDF\ VFJ[ K[P

5P

VFHZMH 5MSFZ SZTF\ NZBF:T NFB, SZGFZ VZHNFZ TZO[ lJwJFG

JSL, ;]zL VJGLA[G DC[TF TYF ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, JLP 5LP

GF6F\J8L JTL zLP NlX", 5ZLB CFHZ K[ TYF ;FDFJF/F G\P # A\[S TZO[ A\[SGF

HJFANFZ VlWSFZL CFHZ K[P ;FDFJF/F G\P Z G[ GM8L; AHL UI[, CMJF KTF\

T[DGF TZO[ SM. CFHZ ZC[, GYLP

&P

VZHNFZ TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, ;]zL VJGLA[G DC[TF4 ;FDFJF/F G\P !

TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB TYF ;FDFJF/F G\P # A\[S TZO[ A\[SGF

VlWSFZLVMGL N,L,M ;F\E/LP ZH] YI[, N:TFJ[HL 5]ZFJF4 ZFHI SDLXG[

OZLIFNGF SFD[ SZ[, C]SD4 ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ ZH] YI[, R]SFNFVM lJU[Z[

J\RF6[ ,LWFP

*P

VF NZBF:TGF SFD[ GLR[GF N:TFJ[HM ZH] YIF K[4 T[G[ 56 SDLXG[ wIFG[

,LWFP

sV[f NZBF:TGF SFD[ ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VMP A\[S[ s;FDFJF/F G\P #f TFP

Z5v!_vZ_Z! GF ZMH D\0/LVMGL S[XJF.h lJUTM H[JL S[4 JLDF5FT|

ZSD4 D/JF5FT| ZSD4 D/[,L ZSD4 AFSL ZC[TL ZSD lJU[Z[ ;\S,LT SZ[,

DFlCTLP

sALf ZLHIMG, D[G[HZ4 V[U|LS<RZ .g:IMZg; S\5GL VMO .lg0IF ,LP G\]

V[0LxFG, V[OL0[JL8 TFP !_vZvZ_ZZ GF ZMHG\]P

s;Lf TFP !_vZvZ_ZZ GF ZMH ZH] YI[, ZLHLIMG, D[G[HZ4 JLDF S\5GLGL

V[0LXG, V[OL0[JL8GF VG];\WFG[ TFP Zv&vZ_ZZ GF ZMH ZH] YI[,

SFG5Z ;[JF ;CSFZL D\0/L TYF ;ZNFZ H]Y lJlJW SFI"SFZL ;[JF ;CSFZL

D\0/LGM HJFAP

(P

VZHNFZ[ T[GL NZBF:TDF\ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 SDLXGGF TFP

Z(vZvZ_!$ GF R]SFNFGF VFWFZ[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! GFV[ S,[.DGL VF\lXS ZSD

.,[S8=MlGS DM0YL ;FDFJF/F G\P # GM0, V[Hg;LG[ TFP Z(vZvZ_!* GF ZMH

DMS,[,P 56 S,[.DGL VF\lXS ZSD ;FDFJF/F G\P ! JLDF S\5GLV[ R]SJ[, CMJFYL

GM0, V[Hg;L ;FDFJF/F G\P # T[ ZSD B[0}TG[ VF5L XS[, GYLP NZBF:TGF SFD[

VZHNFZ[ JW]DF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ;FDFJF/F G\P ! GFV[ TFP !v#vZ_!* GF ZMH

,B[, 5T| NZBF:TGF SFD[ V[G[1FZvAL YL ZH] SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P H[ VF

NZBF:TGF SFD[ D]bI 5T| K[P

)P

VZHNFZ[ JW]DF\ V[JL ZH]VFT SZ[, K[ S[4 B[0}TMG[ JLDFGL ZSD G D/TF\

T[D6[ GM0, V[Hg;L v ;FDFJF/F G\P # G[ ZH]VFT SZTF\ T[VMV[ TFP

Z*v#vZ_!* GF ZMH ;FDFJF/F G\P ! JLDF S\5GLG[ 5T| ,B[,P H[GF VG];\WFG[

JLDF S\5GLV[ TFP !!v$vZ_!* GF ZMH GM0, V[Hg;LG[ 5T| ,B[, VG[

H6FJ[, S[4 ZFHI SDLXGGF R]SFNFDF\ YI[, C]SD 5|DF6[GL JLDF S,[.DGL ZSD

R]SJJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ VG[ CJ[ SM. ZSD R]SJJFGL AFSL ZC[TL GYLP VF 5T|

ccV[G[1FZv;Lcc YL NZBF:TGF SFD[ ZH] K[P

!_P NZBF:TGF SFD[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! JLDF S\5GL TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL",

5ZLB[ N,L,DF\ H6FjI\] S[4 ZFHI SDLXG[ OZLIFN G\P #!_qZ__Z sD[.Gf DF\

TFP Z(vZvZ_!$ GF ZMH SZ[, C]SDDF\ :5Q8 ZLT[ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 NZ[S

OZLIFNGF ;CSFZL D\0/LVMGF JLD[NFZ B[0}TM AFSL JLDFGL ZSD D[/JJF DF8[

CSSNFZ AG[ K[P JW]DF\ C]SDGF 5[ZFv# DF\ V[J\] ,B[, K[ S[4 NZ[S OZLIFNGL

;CSFZL D\0/LVM q OZLIFNL G\P ! GFV[ 5MTFGF ;eIM q JLD[NFZ B[0}TMGL DFlCTL

VF5JL V[8,[ S[ NZ[S OZLIFNGF OZLIFNL G\P ! G[ R]SFNF VG];FZ ZSD D/JF5FT|

YFI K[P

!!P ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB[ JW] N,L,M SZTF\

H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VF R]SFNF VG];FZ ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A\[S ;FDFJF/F G\P #

G[ T[DGF JLD[NFZ B[0}TM S[ H[D6[ OZLIFNM NFB, SZ[,4 T[DGF GFD TYF JLDFGL

ZSDMGL DFlCTL VF5JF H6FJ[, VG[ T[YL TFP !&v*vZ_!5 GF ZMH A\[S[

SMd5[S8 0L:SDF\ B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/L4 GM8LOF.0 V[ZLIF ;\NE"[ !)))vZ___ GF

5FSGL lJUT TYF ;\A\WLT B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVMGF JLD[NFZ B[0}TMGF GFD VF%IF4

H[DF\ !# GM8LOF.0 V[ZLIF TYF TF,]SF 5|DF6[ DUO/L TYF AFHZFGF 5FSGL

lJUTM 5]ZL 5F0JFD\F VFJ[,P

!ZP ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB[ JW] N,L,M SZTF\

H6FJ[, K[ S[4 VF 5|FYlDS DFlCTL ;FDFJF/F G\P # A\[S 5F;[YL D/TF\ HF6JF

D/[, S[4 ;FDFJF/F G\P # A\[S[ V[JL B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVMGL JWFZFGL DFlCTL

DMS,[,4 S[ H[VMV[ U|FCS OZLIFN ZFHI U|FCS SDLXGDF\ NFB, SZ[, H G CTL

TYF OZLIFNDF\ T[VM 51FSFZ H G CTFP

!#P NZBF:TGF SFD[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB[ JW]

N,L,M SZTF\ H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ZFHI SDLXG[ ZZ( OZLIFNDF\ TFP Z(vZvZ_!$

GF ZMH R]SFNM VF5[,P tIFZAFN GM0, V[Hg;L4 ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A\[S

TZOYL TF,]SF 5|DF6[G\] SMg;M,L0[8 :8[8D[g8 ;MO8 SM5LDF\ T[DG[ D/[,P H[G[ U|FCS

OZLIFN TYF OZLIFNLVM B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVMGF VFWFZ[ TFZJLG[ TF,]SF 5|DF6[

R]SJJF5FT| ZSD TYF TF,]SF 5|DF6[ H[ OZLIFNLVMV[ OZLIFN NFB, SZ[, TYF

H[GF DF8[ ZFHI U|FCS SDLXG[ C]SD SZ[,4 T[GL U6T|L SZJFDF\ VFJ[,P

!$P ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB[ JW] N,L,M SZTF\

H6FJ[, K[ S[4 NZBF:TGF SFD[ ZFHI SDLXG 0LS|LYL ACFZ H. G XS[ VG[ T[YL

U|FCS OZLIFNGF VZHNFZ G\P Z G[ OZLIFNL U6JM S[ G U6JMm T[ NZBF:TGF

SFD[ SDLXG[ GSSL SZJFG\] YFIP 5Z\T]4 VZHNFZ G\P Z G[ HHD[g8 S|[0L8Z G U6L

XSFIP

!5P ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB[ JW] N,L,M SZTF\

H6FJ[, K[ S[4 "OTHERS" XaN S[ H[ R]SFNFDF\ SDLXG[ ,B[, K[4 T[ ;\A\WLT jIlST

DF8[ ;\AMWFI[, K[4 S[ H[ OZLIFNL G\P Z K[ TYF OZLIFNL G\P ! GF D[dAZ K[ VG[

T[YL OZLIFNL wJFZF NZBF:T OF., SZL U[Z,FE ,[JFGM 5|ItG SZJFDF\ VFJ[,

K[P

!&P ;FDFJF/F G\P ! TZO[ lJwJFG JSL, zLP NXL", 5ZLB[ N,L,MG\] ;DF5G

SZTF\ H6FJ[, S[4 ;FDFJF/F G\P ! JLDF S\5GLV[ ZFHI SDLXGGF R]SFNF D]HA Z]FP

Z#4(*4!(4_55qv GL ZSD .;LV[; q VFZ8LHLV[; DFZOT[ TFP Z(vZvZ_!*

GF ZMH ZFHSM8 0L:8=LP SMP VM5P A[gSGF V[SFpg8DF\ 8=Fg;OZ SZ[, K[ VG[ ZFHI

SDLXGGF R]SFNFG\] ;\5}6"56[ 5F,G SZ[, K[4 T[YL VF NZBF:T VZHL 8SJF5FT|

GYLP 5MTFGL N,L,MGF ;DY"GDF\ lJwJFG JSL, zLP 5ZLB[ GLR[ 5|DF6[ HHD[g8

ZH] SZ[, K[P

s!f

GFDNFZ ;]l5|D SM8"4 III (2018) CPJ 4 (SC), lDGF1FL ;S;[GF TYF ALHF lJP

.P;LPHLP;LP ,LDL8[0 VG[ ALHFVMP

!*P VF NZBF:TGF SFD[ ;FDFJF/F G\P # ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A\[S TZO[

5MTFGL ,[BLT N,L,M ZH] SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[P H[DF\ H6FJJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ S[4 5FS

JLDFGL :SLDDF\ A\[SGL E}lDSF DFT| V[Hg;LGL K[4 S[ H[ 5|LDLIDGL ZSD B[0}TM

5F;[YL V[S9L SZ[ K[ VG[ JLDF S\5GLG[ DMS,L VF5[ K[P JW]DF\ ,[BLT N,L,DF\

H6FJJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ S[4 ZFHI U|FCS SDLXG[ TFP Z(vZvZ_!$ GF C]SDDF\

lGN"[X SIF" 5|DF6[ B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVMV[ T[DGF JLD[NFZ q ;eIGF GFD TYF

JLDFGL ZSDGL DFlCTL A\[SG[ VF5[,LP A\[SG[ ALHL ;CSFZL D\0/LVMGL DFlCTL 56

D/L sH[DGF GFD :5Q8 ZLT[ OZLIFNDF\ ,B[, GYLf TYF JLD[NFZ B[0]TMGF GFD S[

H[DGL JLDFGL ZSD D]/ OZLIFNDF\ ;FD[, CTL T[DGF GFD 56 VF5JFD\F VFjIFP

tIFZAFN A[\S[ T[ AWL lJUT V[ST| SZL JLDF S\5GLG[ DMS,L VF5LP 5Z\T]4 JLDF

S\5GLV[ VFxRI"HGS ZLT[ ALHL D\0/LVM S[ H[DGL JLDFGL ZSD D]/ OZLIFNGM

EFU CTL4 T[ JLDF S\5GL wJFZF R]SJJFDF\ G VFJL VG[ T[YL A\[[SG[ JLDF S,[.DGL

5]ZL ZSD D/L G CMJFYL T[ ZSD lJD[NFZ B[0}TMG[ R]SJL XSL GYLP

!(P VF NZBF:TGF SFD[ D]bI D]N'M OST V[ RSF;JFGM ZC[ K[ S[4 ZFHI SDLXG[

U|FCS OZLIFN G\P #!_qZ__Z sD[.Gf GF SFD[ TFP Z(vZvZ_!$ GF ZMH H[

R]SFNM VF5[, K[4 T[G\] 5F,G ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z V[ ;\5}6"56[ SZ[, K[ S[ S[Dm

!)P GFDNFZ ;]l5|DSM8"[ III (2018) CPJ 4 (SC) DF\ GLR[ D]HA ,B[, K[P

"Executive Court cannot go beyond decree"

VFD4 GFDNFZ ;]l5|DSM8"GF p5ZMST TFZ6M wIFG[ ,[TF\ VF NZBF:TGF SFD[

ZFHI SDLXG U|FCS OZLIFN G\P #!_qZ__ZsD[.Gf GF R]SFNFGL 0LS|LGL ACFZ

H. XS[ GCL4 T[J\] VF SDLXGG\] DFGJ\] K[P

Z_P ZFHI SDLXG[ TFP Z(vZvZ_!$ GF ZMH U|FCS OZLIFN G\P #!_qZ__Z

sD[.Gf GF SFD[ GLR[ 5|DF6[ C]SD SZ[, K[P

Advocates:
For the Petitioner: AVANI MEHTA
For the Respondent:

ORDER

I) All the complaints are partly allowed.

2) Insured farmers/ members of the cooperative societies of each complaint are entitled to get crop insurance claim as per short fall in their respective area for groundnut and Bajra level of indemnity is 60%. Other reduction in sum assured and consequently insurance claim by opponent no.l and 2 is not permissible as per scheme. Maximum limit is Rs. I0,000/= per insured farmer.

3) It is hereby ordered that cooperative society / complainant no.I of each complaint should furnish details regarding name of members / insured farmers and sum assured to Nodal agency, Rajkot District Cooperative Bank, the opponent no. 3 within one month from the date of order.

4) On receiving the details from the complainant no.I the Nodal agency the Rajkot District Cooperative Bank the opponent no.3 should furnish details about the insured farmers and sum assured collectively to the opponent no.I within two months from the date of receipt.

5) On receiving the details from the opponent no.3 the Nodal agency the opponent no. I and 2 should calculate the crop insurance claim as per scheme as mentioned in para 1 of the order and make payment to the Nodal agency The Rajkot Cooperative Bank accordingly. The amount already paid should be deducted from the total insurance claim.

6) On receiving the amount from the opponents nos. 1 and 2 the Nodal agency Rajkot District Cooperative Bank should credit the insurance claim amount in loan account of respective insured farmers. Each party to bear their own costs.

Z!P ZFHI SDLXG[ U|FCS OZLIFN G\P #!_qZ__Z sD[.Gf DF\ OZLIFNL G\P ! DF\ ;CSFZL D\0/LG\] GFD TYF OZLIFNL G\P Z DF\ B[0}T JLD[NFZG\] GFD ,B[, K[ TYF VF OZLIFN ;FY[ SMg;M,L0[8 SZ[, OZLIFNMDF\ B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVMG\] GFD TYF "OTHERS" ,B[, K[P NZBF:TGF SFD[ VZHNFZG\] V[J\] SC[J\] K[ S[4 "OTHERS" V[8,[ S[ ALHL B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVM TYF T[DGF JLD[NFZP HIFZ[ JLDF S\5GLG\] V[J\] SC[J\] K[ S[4 VW;" V[8,[ S[ OZLIFNL G\P Z B[0}T q JLD[NFZP ZZP ZFHI SDLXGGF p5ZMST R]SFNM T5F;TF\ T[DF\ R]SFNFGF 5[ZFvZ DF\ ccInsured farmers / members of the cooperative societies of each complaint" XaN JF5Z[, K[ VG[ T[YL HIFZ[ cc cooperative societies" XaN AC]JRGDF\ JF5Z[, K[ VG[ T[YL T[ ;CSFZL D\0/LVM U6JFGL YFI VG[ VFD4 5[ZFvZ 5|DF6[ V[SYL JW]

;CSFZL D\0/LVMGF B[0}TM q ;eIMG[ AFSL JLDFGL ZSD D/JF5FT| YFIP tIFZAFN R]SFNFGF 5[ZFv# YL 5 DF\ H6FjIF 5|DF6[ OZLIFNL G\P ! q ;CSFZL D\0/L T[DGF JLD[NFZ q ;eIMGF GFD TYF JLDFGL ZSD GM0, V[Hg;L q ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A\[S q ;FDFJF/F G\P # G[ VF5[ VG[ VF DFlCTL D/[YL ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A\[S T[ DFlCTL ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z G[ A[ DlCGFDF\ DMS,L VF5[ VG[ VF DFlCTL D/[YL ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z AFSL JLDFGL ZSDGL U6T|L :SLD VG];FZ C]SDGF 5[ZFv! DF\ H6FjIF D]HA SZLG[ ;FDFJF/F G\P # G[ DMS,L VF5X[P VFD4 R]SFNFGF 5[ZFv5 DF\ :5Q8 ZLT[ lGN"[X SZJFDF\ VFJ[, K[ S[4 GM0, V[Hg;L ;FDFJF/F G\P # 5F;[YL JLD[NFZGF GFD TYF JLDFGL ZSDGL DFlCTL D/[YL T[ ZSD :SLD 5|DF6[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z V[ R]SJJFGL YFIP Z#P VF NZBF:TGF SFD[ lJUTM HMTF\ GM0, V[Hg;L q ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VMP A[\S[ GFD TYF JLDFGL ZSD ;FDFJF/F G\P ! JLDF S\5GLG[ DMS,L4 56 T[ 5|DF6[GL JLDF ZSDGL R]SJ6L JLDF S\5GLV[ SZ[, GYLP JLDF S\5GLG\] V[J\] SC[J\\\] K[ S[4 ZFHSM8 0L:8=LS8 SMP VM5P A\[S q GM0, V[Hg;L q ;FDFJF/F G\P # GFV[ H[ B[0}T ;CSFZL D\0/LVMV[ U|FCS OZLIFN NFB, SZ[, GYL TYF H[VM ZFHI SDLXGDF\ OZLIFNGF SFD[ 51FSFZ GYL4 T[VMGF GFDGL DFlCTL 56 DMS,[,P 5Z\T]4 ZFHI SDLXGGF R]SFNFGF 5[ZFv5 DF\ :5Q8 H6FJ[, K[ S[4 ;FDFJF/F G\P # GM0, V[Hg;L 5F;[YL H[ DFlCTL D/[ T[DG[ AFSL JLDFGL ZSDGL R]SJ6L ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z V[ SZJFGL ZC[X[P VFD4 VF SDLXG :5Q856[ DFG[ K[ S[4 GM0, V[Hg;L 5F;[YL D/[, DFlCTL 5|DF6[ T[DF\ ATFJ[, TDFD JLD[NFZMG[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z JLDF S,[.DGL ZSD R]SJJF HJFANFZ K[ VG[ ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z V[ C]SDGF 5[ZFv! DF\ H6FjIF 5|DF6[ :SLD VG];FZ OST S,[.DGL U6TZL H SZJFGL ZC[ K[P Z$P p5ZMST RRF"GF VFWFZ[ VF SDLXGGF D\TjI D]HA ;FDFJF/F G\P ! VG[ Z V[ ZFHI SDLXG[ OZLIFN

Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top