F.A.No. :82 TO 86/14

Date of filing:05.02.2014

Date of order:10.09.2015

MAHARASHTRA STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL

COMMISSION, MUMBAI, CIRCUIT BENCH AT AURANGABAD.

FIRST APPEAL NO.: 82 TO 86 OF 2014

IN COMPLAINT CASE NO. : 158,159,160,161,162 OF 2012.

DISTRICT FORUM :

1. Solapur Nagari Audyogik Sahakari

Bank Ltd.,

340 A,Skharpeth, Solapur 413001.

2. Chief Executive Officer,

Chitrashekhar Somshekhar Babanagare,

Solapur Nagari Audyogik Sahakari

Bank Ltd.,

Solapur 413001.

3. Sidram Pundlik Ganji,

Solapur Nagari Audyogik Sahakari

Bank Ltd.,

R/o 238, M.I.D.C. Solapur 413 001.

4. Prakash Vyankatpati Konda,

Solapur Nagari Audyogik Sahakari

Bank Ltd.,

Branch Ahmednagar Shantiban Complex,

Dal Mandai, Ahmednagar 414001.

5. Sanjay Raut,

Administrator Solapur Nagri A.Sah.Bank,

Solapur 413001

6. Mr.Narayandas Jaskaran Rathi,

R/o 911, Ghati Galli, Solapur 413001.

7. Mrs.Shashikala Shankar Singam,

R/o 1813/14, Dattanagar, Solapur 413001.

8. Pandurang Sindramappa Diddi,

R/o 370/71, Sakharpeth, Solapur 413001.

9. Mr.Prabhakar Ambadas Dikonda,

R/o Madhavnagar, Solapur 413001.

F.A.No. :82 TO 86/14

10. Sidram Krishnahari Munagapatil,

R/o 1608, Kunchan Nagar, Solapur 413001.

11. Ashok Ramchandra Katake,

R/0 10/18, Bhavani Peth, Solapur 413001.

12. Ramchandra Bhagwandas Somani,

R/o 1574, Azad Bol, Barshi 413 001.

13. Prakash Sudarshan Jannu,

R/o 5B Rangrajnagar, Solapur 413001.

14. Dharmraj Narayan Konkatti,

R/o 92, Kuchannagar, Solapur 413001.

15. Raymallu Bakayya Kamtam,

R/o 1229, New Pacha Peth, Solapur 413001.

16. Raju Ramchandra Bhimanpalli,

R/o 724, New Pacha Peth, Solapur 413001.

17. Mr.Shashikant Shivram Kenchi,

R/o 1528, Daji Peth, Solapur 413001.

18. Madhukar Lingraj Katta,

R/o 155, Daji peth, Solapur 413001.

19. Prabhakar Ambaji Goranti,

R/o 43 A, Kuchannagar, Solapur 413001.

20. Ganesh Purushottam Gundewar,

R/o 2896/1, Paschim Dwar,

Pandharpur 413304.

21. Mr.Vijaya Krishahari Vaddepalli,

R/o 1043, Pacha Peth, Solapur 413001.

…APPELLANTS

VERSUS

1. Vijaykumar Champalal Mutha,

R/o 57, Punam Motinagar,

Ahmednagar 414001.

…RESPONDENT

(In F.A.No. 82/2014

& 83/2014)

F.A.No. :82 TO 86/14

2. Mohinibai Champalal Mutha,

R/o 57, Punam Motinagar,

Ahmednagar 414001.

…RESPONDENT

(In F.A.No. 84/2014)

3. Jyoti Vijaykumar Mutha,

R/o 57, Punam Motinagar,

Ahmednagar 414001.

…RESPONDENT

(In F.A.No. 85/2014)

4. Champalal Lalchand Mutha,

R/o 57, Punam Motinagar,

Ahmednagar 414001.

…RESPONDENT

(In F.A.No. 86/2014)

Coram : Mr.S.M.Shembole, Hon`ble Presiding Judicial

Member.

Mrs.Uma S.Bora, Hon`ble Member.

Present :

Adv.D.B.Jetla for appellants,

Adv.P.M.Bhandari for respondents.

O R A L J U D G M E N T

( Delivered on 10^th September 2015 )

Per Mr.S.M.Shembole, Hon`ble Presiding Judicial Member.

1. Challenge in all these appeals are the separate judgments and

orders

dated

23.12.2013

passed

by

District

Consumer

Forum

Ahmednagar

allowing

complainant’s

claim

directing

appellants/org.opponents to pay to the complainants maturity amount of

fixed deposit with interest as per the chart given below and further

compensation Rs.2000/- each complainant towards mental torture and

Rs.1000/- towards cost of each complaint.

F.A.No. :82 TO 86/14

Amount of deposits are as under:-

Sr.No.

Appeal No.

Consumer

complaint No.

Amount of fixed

deposit

1. 82/14

158/12

09,60,748/-

2. 83/14

159/12

11,04,308/-

3. 84/14

160/12

11,04,308/-

4. 85/14

161/12

05,56,500/-

+

07,68,581/-

5. 86/12

162/12

08,28,098/-

(For the sake of brevity appellants are hereinafter referred as opponents

and respondents as complainants)

As the appellants/opponents as well as points which are to be

determined in all the appeals are common, we have decided to dispose of

all these appeals by this common judgment.

2. Brief facts

Click Here to Read the rest of this document