2019 MarsdenLR 1028
HIGH COURT SABAH & SARAWAK TAWAU
OLIVIA CHONG OI YUN – Appellant
Versus
PP – Respondent
[Criminal Case No: TWU-42AC-1/3-2019]
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Traffic Offences
Act Referred
Headnote
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. overview of the conviction and sentences received. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6) |
| 2. court's findings on recklessness and causation of accident. (Para 14) |
| 3. findings of the learned sessions court judge. (Para 15 , 16) |
[1] This is an appeal by the appellant ("Olivia Chong Oi Yun") against the order of conviction and sentence given by the learned Sessions Court Judge ("SCJ") on 7 March 2019 for two charges both under s 44(1)(b) of the Road Transport Act 1987 (" RTA ").
[2] The two charges proffered against the appellant are as follows:
First charge
"Bahawa, kamu pada 8 July 2018 jam lebih kurang 01.20 pagi di Jalan Chong Thien Vun hadapan Pusat Komersil BDC (1 Arena) di dalam daerah Tawau, di Negeri Sabah sebagai pemandu kenderaan Nombor Pendaftaran ST851X, mempunyai sebegitu banyak alkohol dalam badan kamu sehingga alcohol di dalam darah kamu melebihi had yang ditetapkan dan menyebabkan kematian kepada:
1) Hiew Nyuk Wei, L, 30 Tahun, Cina, Nombor Kad Pengenalan: 881218-49- 5425
2) Clawence Wong Vun Kit, L, 21 Tahun, Cina, Nombor Kad Pengenalan: 971120-12-6903
3) Dicson Lim Kien Shing, L, 16 Tahun, Cina. Nombor Kad Pengenalan: 020425- 12-0381
4) Chung Vui Chan, L, 21 Tahun, Cina, Nombor Kad Pengenalan: 970415-12- 5495
dan oleh yang demikian kamu telah melakukan satu kesalahan yang boleh dihukum di bawah s 44(1)(b) Akta Pengangkutan Jalan 1987 (Akta 333)."
Second charge
"Bahawa, kamu pada 8 July 2018 jam lebih kurang 01.20 pagi di Jalan Chong Thien Vun hadapan Pusat Komersil BDC (1 Arena) di dalam daerah Tawau, di Negeri Sabah sebagai pemandu kenderaan Nombor Pendaftaran ST851X, mempunyai sebegitu banyak alkohol dalam badan kamu sehingga alcohol di dalam darah kamu melebihi had yang ditetapkan dan menyebabkan kecederaan kepada 1) Chin Guan Xiong, L, 21 Tahun, Cina, Nombor Kad Pengenalan: 971112-12-6233 dan oleh yang demikian kamu telah melakukan satu kesalahan yang boleh dihukum di bawah s 44(1)(b) Akta Pengangkutan Jalan 1987 (Akta 333)".
[3] For the first charge, the appellant was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment and a fine of RM20,000.00 in default 6 months jail.
[4] For the second charge, the appellant was sentenced to 7 years imprisonment and a fine of RM19,000.00 in default 6 months jail.
[5] The learned SCJ also ordered the terms of imprisonment for both charges to run consecutively.
[6] The learned SCJ further ordered for the disqualification of the appellants driving licence for the period of 10 years ie 5 years for each charge.
[7] On the 25 October 2019, I dismissed the appellants appeal against conviction. However, I allowed the appellants appeal in part against sentence.
[8] Accordingly, I set aside the sentence imposed by the learned SCJ and substituted it as follows:
(i) For the first charge, a sentence of 8 years imprisonment.
(ii) For the second charge, a sentence of 6 years imprisonment.
(iii) The imprisonment terms for both charges are to run concurrently.
(iv) The particulars of conviction be endorsed on the appellants driving licence after the expiry of the disqualification order.
[9] The order by the learned SCJ to disqualify the appellant from holding or obtaining a driving licence for such period as ordered is hereby affirmed.
[10] Likewise, the sentence of fine imposed by the learned SCJ for the two charges is also affirmed.
[11] Dissatisfied against my decision, the appellant filed an appeal.
[12] I shall now give my grounds of decision.
The Background Facts Of Case
[13] The facts of the case as summarised by the learned SCJ are as follows:
"[5] In this case the accident happened within the vicinity of an area of shop houses known as 1 Arena in the early hours of the morning. The said accident was said to have happened at around 1.20 am. There are basically three witnesses who are PW1 - Raja Ibrahim Fikri bin Raja Abdullah Husni PW 2 - Mohamad Syahidan bin Mamat and PW 3 Encik kamaludin bin Airf. First of all, I must emphasize that PW 1 and PW 2 were the nearest witnesses to the scene of the accident. Both of