JUDGMENT

(Enclosure 145 - Application To Produce Document For Inspection)

John Lee Kien How @ Mohd Johan Lee J:

A) Introduction

i) Facts Of The Case

[1] This is a case where Tan Sri Dato' Kam Woon Wah ("Plaintiff") filed an action ("this Case") suing his grand daughter, Hannah Kam Zhen Yi ("D1") and Messrs Thomas Philip ("D2").

[2] While this Case was still in its interlocutory stage, D1 and D1's father, Dato' Sri Andrew Kam Tai Yeow ("DSAK") sent a letter to the then Chief Judge of Malaya ("the Letter to CJM" and "the Honourable CJM respectively"), expressing serious concerns and grievances concerning the conduct of the High Court Judge ("HCJ")("the Serious Concerns & Grievances") in Kuala Lumpur High Court Civil Suit No. WA-22NCvC822-12/2021 ("Suit 822"). In Suit 822 both D1 and DSAK were sued by Plaintiff as well.

[3] Suit 822 is a suit by Plaintiff against DSAK and D1, in which Plaintiff had similarly commenced separate committal proceedings against D1. Believing that such conduct rendered the HCJ unsuitable to continue presiding over both actions, D1 sought for a new judge be appointed in the HCJ's stead.

[4] Later, the Plaintiff in this Case received an email from the Special Off