2021 MarsdenLR 3608
HIGH COURT MALAYA SHAH ALAM
SUNTRACK DEVELOPMENT SDN BHD – Appellant
Versus
DEEPAK JAIKISHAN JAIKISHAN REWACHAND – Respondent
[Originating Summons No: BA-24NCvC-1155-10/2020]
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Land Registration
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Legal Principle – A director or shareholder of a company does not have a registrable or caveatable interest in land registered in the name of that company or another. (Paras 5, 27)
Facts of the case: Plaintiff contends Defendant, a former director/shareholder of a company, lacks registrable interest in the lands registered in a different company's name.
Findings of Court: Court allowed the Plaintiff’s application to remove caveats and assess damages suffered due to Defendant’s actions. (Paras 4, 38)
Issues: Whether Defendant had a caveatable interest in Plaintiff's lands.
Ratio Decidendi: Defendant failed to show any caveatable or registrable interest, and the law clearly bars such claims by former shareholders or directors over properties not registered to them. (Paras 15, 35)
Result: Application to remove caveats allowed.
JUDGMENT
A. Introduction
[1] Does a caveator, who is a former director and shareholder of company A, have a registrable or caveatable interest, in lands registered in the name of company B? This is essentially the issue before this Court in the Plaintiff's application for the removal of the private caveats lodged by the Defendant on the Plaintiff's lands.
[2] The Defendant, as a former director and majority shareholder of a company known as Astrocanggih Sdn Bhd ("Astrocanggih") and a minority shareholder of a company known as Awan Megah (M) Sdn Bhd ("Awan Megah"), had lodged private caveats on the lands owned by the Plaintiff.
[3] The Plaintiff contends that the Defendant does not have any registrable interest or caveatable interest on the said lands. It had applied to this Court, by way of the originating summons in Enc. 1, for the removal of private caveats under s 327 of the National Land Code (" NLC ") and for compensation under s 329 of the .
[4] At the conclusion of the hearing of Enc. 1, this Court agrees with the Plaintiff that based on the facts of this case and established principles of law, the Defendant as the former director and shareholder of Astrocanggih and minority shareholder of Awan Megah, does not have any registrable or caveatable interests in the lands belonging to the Plaintiff.
[5] It is clear from the Supreme Court's landmark decision in Hew Sook Ying v. Hiew Tin Hee , [1992] 2 MLJ 189, that a director or shareholder of a company does not have any registrable or caveatable interest under s 323(1) of the NLC in land registered in that company's name, let alone land registered in the name of another company of which he is neither a director nor a shareholder.
[6] For the reasons set out in this Judgment, this Court allowed the Plaintiff's application to remove the caveats lodged by the Defendant on its lands and ordered that damages suffered by the Plaintiff as a result of the Defendant's caveats on its lands to be assessed by this Court.
B. Background Facts
[7] The Defendant had entered private caveats on four of the Plaintiff's lands. The said lands (collectively referred to as "the Lands") and the private caveats entered by the Defendant on the said Land's (collectively referred to as "the Caveats") are detailed in Table 1 and Table 2 below.
TABLE 1
NO PLAINTIFF'S LANDS 1. Geran 338263, Lot 98858, Mukim Bukit Raja, Daerah Petaling, Negeri Selangor ("1st Land") 2. Geran 338264, Lot 98857, Mukim Bukit Raja, Daerah Petaling, Negeri Selangor ("2nd Land") 3. Geran 338266, Lot 98856, Mukim Bukit Raja, Daerah Petaling, Negeri Selangor ("3rd Land") 4. Geran 338267, Lot 98855, Mukim Bukit Raja, Daerah Petaling, Negeri Selangor ("4th Land") TABLE 2
NO DEFENDANT'S CAVEATS 1. Caveat presentation No. 22106/2020 registered on 13 July 2020 lodged on the 1st Land 2. Caveat presentation No. 22097/2020 registered on 13 July 2020 lodged on the 2nd Land 3. Caveat presentation No. 22004/2020 registered on 13 July 2020 lodged on the 3rd Land 4. Caveat presentation No. 22093/2020 registered on 13 July 2020 lodged on the 4th Land
[8] The Plaintiff is the registered owner of the Lands at all material times.
[9] The Defendant had entered the Caveats on the Lands on 13 July 2020 in his capacity as a former director and majority shareholder of Astrocanggih and a minority shareholder of Awan Megah.
[10] The reasons for filing the Caveats on the Plaintiff's Lands, as stated by the Defendant in his Forms 19B, was to preserve the status quo pending the disposal of his civil suit at the Kuala Lumpur High Court against Dato' Seri Mohd Najib bin Tun Abdul Razak, Datin Paduka Seri Rosmah Mansur, Boustead Holdings Berhad ("Boustead Holdings") and Bakti Wira Development Sdn Bhd ("Bakti Wira") in WA-22NCVC-679-10/2018 ("Suit 679") for the sale by Boustead Holdings and Bakti Wira of lands (including the Plaintiff's Lands") to Cebur Megah Development Sdn Bhd, UMW Toyota Motor Sdn Bhd and the Plaintiff ("the Purchasers"); and his civil suit against the Pur