2005 MarsdenLR 2350 ; 2005 MarsdenLR 1
GOPAL SRI RAM, ABDUL KADIR SULAIMAN, NIK HASHIM
CHIN CHOON – Appellant
Versus
CHUA JUI MENG – Respondent
Advocates:
For the appellant - Mohamed Zaini Mazlan; M/s CL Chin & Assoc
For the respondent - Darryl SC Goon (Yvonne Ong with him); M/s Raja, Darryl & Loh
CHIN CHOON V. CHUA JUI MENG COURT OF APPEAL, PUTRAJAYA[CIVIL APPEAL NO: W-02-372-2000]GOPAL SRI RAM JCA , ABDUL KADIR SULAIMAN JCA , NIK HASHIM JCA14 OCTOBER 2004[Appeal from High Court, Kuala Lumpur; Civil Suit No: S2-22-503-1994] Reported by WA SharifJUDGMENT Gopal Sri Ram JCA:The appellant is an advocate and solicitor. He was the second defendant in the court below. This is his appeal against the award of damages made against him in respect of the libel admittedly committed by him upon the respondent. The trial judge awarded a total sum of RM1,500,000 made up of RM500,000 as compensatory damages, RM500,000 as aggravated damages and a further RM500,000 as exemplary damages. The appellant complains that these awards are excessive.At the date of publication of the admitted libel, the respondent was the Deputy Minister for International Trade and Industry. The appellant made a charge against the respondent that was of the gravest nature. He alleged that the respondent had acted corruptly in the discharge of his duties. This charge was made at a press conference called at the appellant's behest. The story was carried by two newspapers of the Chinese vernacular. Later, the appellant r
Click Here to Read the rest of this document