SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2005 MarsdenLR 637

COURT OF APPEAL, PUTRAJAYA

DENIS ONG JCA ; RICHARD MALANJUM JCA ; TENGKU BAHARUDIN SHAH JCA


SAYANG PLANTATION BHD
versus
KOH SIAK POO

CIVIL APPEAL NO: K-02-359-2003

Decided On : 07-29-05

Advocates:
For the plaintiff/appellant - Bastian Vendargon (Eng Ooi Huang with him); M/s Lim Kean Siew & Co.
For the defendant/respondent - Mahinder Singh Dulku; M/s Mahinder Singh Dulku & Co.

JUDGMENT

Denis Ong JCA:

Introduction

[1] This is an appeal by Sayang Plantation Bhd, the abovenamed defendant (the appellant) to this court from the decision of the judge of the High Court at Alor Setar, Kedah who on 8 April 2003 ordered the appellant to pay to Koh Siak Poo, the abovenamed plaintiff (the respondent), compensation for damage and/or loss consequential upon the failure of the appellant to withdraw forthwith Lien Holder's Caveat No. Perserahan 60/1988 Jilid 23 Folio 7 (the caveat) registered at the Land Office Kedah on 16 February 1988 against the land comprised in GM3423, Lot 208, Mukim Sungai Pasir, Padang Temusu, Kuala Muda District (Lot 208); such compensation to be enquired into and assessed by the deputy registrar or the senior assistant registrar of the High Court; and costs. We heard this appeal in Alor Setar and reserved judgment to a date to be fixed.

[2] The decision is not unanimous as has been pronounced in open court. There has been a division of opinion in this quorum. The majority opinion of Denis Ong Jiew Fook and Richard Malanjum (CAJJ) concur that this appeal be dismissed with costs here and below; the deposit to be paid to the respondent towards the account of taxed costs and directed afresh the deputy registrar or the senior assistant registrar to enquire into the matter of compensation for damage or loss (if any) caused to the respondent from 21 October 2002 to 18 March 2003 by the failure of the appellant to withdraw the caveat. Tengku Baharuddin Shah bin Tengku Mahmud (CAJ) dissents. His opinion is that this appeal be allowed, the order of the High Court set aside and that the parties are to bear their own costs. The majority opinion prevails and we order accordingly. The following are the grounds of majority decision.

Facts And Background

[3] The respondent is the registered proprietor of Lot 208 under Original Title Deed No: 20386 (the Original Title Deed) and a director and shareholder of the appellant under share certificate Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20. The Title Deed and all share certificates were in the possession of the appellant, having been deposited with the latter as security documents purportedly for various sums totalling RM663,000 received by the respondent on diverse dates from the appellant to defray expenses necessary or incidental to procure three joint venture agreements for the appellant with landowners for oil palm cultivation under the appellant's schemes named "Rancangan Tanah Senggang B", "Rancangan Tanah Senggang E" and Rancangan Tanah Hong." The respondent failed to procure such joint venture agreements and the appellant sued the respondent in Ipoh High Court Civil Suit No: 23-167-1988 for the recovery of the RM663,000 and obtained judgment in the said sum against the respondent after a trial. On appeal, the Court of Appeal by a majority decision (Gopal Sri Ram and Abdul Kadir Sulaiman (CAJJ) concurring; Mokhtar Sidin (CAJ) dissenting); upheld the judgment of the Ipoh High Court on the original action and the appeal was dismissed (See the oral judgment of the majority delivered on 29 November 2000 and the written judgment of Mokhtar Sidin dated 10 July 2001 in MRRS No. A-02-190-1998). Leave to appeal was refused by the Federal Court. On 16 February 1988 the appellant entered the caveat against Lot 208 which caveat remained on the land register as at 23 January 2003 upon a search by the respondent.

[4] By a letter dated 30 September 2002 from the respondent's solicitors, M/s Mahinder Singh Dulku & Co, to M/s Lim Kean Siew & Co, solicitors for the appellant, the former enclosed a Public Bank cheque No: 046012 for RM802,125.92 (the cheque) in "full and final settlement of the judgment obtained by your client and as varied by the order of the Court of Appeal dated 29 November 2000." The text of that letter is reproduced below:

Surat Kami: K12-23

Surat Tuan: BK/AL/685/87

30th September, 2002

M/s. Lim Kean Siew & Co

Advo

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top