2002 MarsdenLR 2
HIGH COURT MALAYA, PENANG
RK NATHAN J
INFRA ELITE DEVELOPMENT SDN BHD
versus
PACIFIC TREASURE LAND SDN BHD
ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO: 24-1863-2001
Decided On : 09-27-02
For the plaintiff - Raj Shanker; M/s R Rajasingam & Co
For the defendant - YC Wong; M/s Lim Kean Siew & Co
RK Nathan J:
Facts
The plaintiff was the purchaser of Lot 1418 Mukim 14, Daerah Seberang Perai Tengah, Pulau Pinang, held under Geran Mukim No. 816 (the said land) having fully paid the purchase price to the vendor. The plaintiff was therefore the beneficial owner of the said land. The plaintiff was unable to register itself as the owner because the defendant had entered a caveat on 9 April 2001 over the said land. The Form 19B which is the 'Application For Entry of a Private Caveat' which the defendant was required to submit pursuant to s. 323 of the National Land Code (the NLC) and which was exhibited showed that the caveat was sought to bind the entire land itself and not any particular interest described in the said Schedule. The ground pursuant to which the defendant sought to enter the caveat and as stated in the Form 19B was that the plaintiff had allowed the defendant to construct a 6-foot wide 'RC Monsoon Drain' (the said drain) on the plaintiff's land.
The plaintiff then took out an originating summons on 1 November 2001 for the following orders:
1) to vacate and cancel the caveat forthwith;
2) that the Registrar Land Office, Seberang Prai or any other authorised officer do cancel the said caveat forthwith.
3) that the senior assistant registrar do assess the damages suffered by the plaintiff as a result of the wrongful entry of the caveat and that the defendant do pay the assessed damages to the plaintiff;
4) that the defendant be prevented from entering a private caveat over the said land;
5) costs.
Findings Of The Court
The plaintiff denied giving the defendant permission to construct the said drain on the plaintiff's land. The plaintiff further averred that it had not entered into any agreement with the defendant to enable the defendant to enter into the plaintiff's land and to construct the said drain. The plaintiff contended that the defendant had shown no valid or reasonable cause to entitle the defendant to enter the said caveat nor had it shown any valid power or authority to entitle it to enter the said caveat. The plaintiff further averred that in any case the defendant was not entitled to caveat the entire land of the plaintiff since the defendant had not claimed any interest over the entire land. The plaintiff also pointed out that in the event the defendant had a right as claimed to construct the said drain, the defendant was clearly not at liberty to caveat the entire land of the plaintiff.
Subsequently, an affidavit (encl. 5) was filed by one Khor Siak Koon who stated in para. 1 of the said affidavit that he is the director of the plaintiff and has been authorised by the plaintiff to affirm this affidavit. However upon a perusal of the contents of the affidavit and the jurat I was surprised to note that the affidavit is in actual fact filed by the defendant's director and in response to the plaintiff s affidavit in support of the originating summons. How could the defendant's director contend that he can affirm an affidavit on behalf of the plaintiff and further to contend that he was authorised by the plaintiff to affirm that affidavit? Either this is a false affidavit or at best it was careless drafting. Since it is solicitors who prepare the affidavit I shall give the deponent the benefit of the doubt and hold that it was carelessness on the part of solicitors that caused this confusion and that it is not to be construed as a false affidavit. This case illustrates how important it is for solicitors to be precise and accurate in their drafting. In the circumstances it is only proper to reject the contents of encl. 5.
In the meantime the defendant affirmed an affidavit through its director on 7 May 2002 (encl. 10) in which the defendant admitted having withdrawn the said caveat on 6 May 2002 "kerana mengikat keseluruhan tanah tersebut" and having entered a fresh caveat over that portion of the plaintiff's land that would carry the said drain as contained in the plan annexed to the fresh Bora