2017 MarsdenLR 2604
COURT OF APPEAL PUTRAJAYA
LABUAN FERRY CORPORATION SDN BHD – Appellant
Versus
CHIN MUI KIEN (TRADING UNDER THE NAME AND STYLE OF ECON FOCUS EN.... – Respondent
[Civil Appeal Nos: S-02(W)-35-01-2016 S-02(W)-34-01-2016 & S-02(W)-11501-2016]
Important Points
Subject
Civil - Contract and Competition Law
Act Referred
Headnote
Result: 'The appeal by Labuan Ferry is dismissed with costs of RM50,000.00 to the respondents in the first appeal.'
| Date | Event | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Date of decision | The court held that the common law doctrine of prime necessity applies in Malaysia, especially in cases involving monopolies over essential services. | (!) |
| Date of decision | The court determined that where a service is essential and provided under a monopoly, the provider has an implied obligation to supply the service at reasonable prices. | (!) |
| Date of decision | The court emphasized that this obligation arises from the principles of English common law as incorporated into Malaysian law, unless overridden by specific statutes. | (!) |
| Date of decision | The court clarified that statutes such as the Competition Act, Contracts Act, or Merchant Shipping Ordinance do not automatically exclude the application of the doctrine of prime necessity unless they explicitly regulate or override it. | (!) |
| Date of decision | The court found that the ferry service was an essential service and that the monopoly provider had a duty to charge reasonable prices, which had been exceeded. | (!) |
(Note: The exact dates of these events are not specified, but the table reflects the sequence of legal findings and principles established in the decision.)
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. origin and procedural history of the appeals. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 8 , 9 , 12 , 13) |
| 2. argument regarding necessity of service and pricing. (Para 4 , 5 , 14 , 15) |
| 3. judicial findings on duty of care in services. (Para 23 , 24 , 66) |
| 4. application of common law doctrine to malaysian context. (Para 27 , 28 , 32 , 33) |
| 5. application of the doctrine of prime necessity in context. (Para 49) |
[1] These three appeals originated from two separate suits which were tried jointly in the High Court at the Federal Territory of Labuan, an island off mainland Sabah. Having heard arguments by the parties, we reserved judgment to a date to be fixed. We have now reached a unanimous decision and this is our judgment.
[2] The appeal by the appellant in the first appeal, namely Labuan Ferry Corporation Sdn Bhd (the defendant at the trial - after this referred to as "Labuan Ferry") was against paras 1 and 2 of the following orders made by the High Court:
1. Judgment be entered against the defendant for the sum of;
(a) 1st plaintiff (Chin Mui Kien) - RM14,760.00
(b) 2nd plaintiff (S L Transport Sdn Bhd) - RM204,610.00
(c) 3rd plaintiff (Lim Kian Sen and Lim Kian Wah) - RM95,140.00
(d) 4th plaintiff (Lim Kian Sen) - RM807,000.00
(e) 5th plaintiff (Kasmin Kurdi and Zainal Kasmin) - RM60,680.00
(f) 6th plaintiff (S.P. Hing Seng Sdn Bhd and Ting Sieng Hing) - RM18,640.00
2. Interest at the rate of five per centum (5%) per annum for the judgment sum as paragraph 1 above calculated from 06 January 2011 to the date of full settlement to be paid by the defendant to the plaintiffs.
3. The 1st plaintiff's claim as follows be dismissed:
(a) Damages to be assessed for the loss of use of the vehicles bearing registration number LD811 and LD6116.
(b) Damages to be assessed for the loss of profit of the vehicles bearing registration number LD811 and LD6116.
(c) Costs of RM30,000.00 to be paid by the defendant to the plaintiffs for this suit at the High Court.
4. Costs of RM8,000.00 to be paid by the defendant to the plaintiffs for the Court of Appeal case no S-02(IM)-856-05- 2014.
[3] The first order was in fact an order for Labuan Ferry to refund to the respondents the excess ferry charges that it had charged the respondents over and above the charges fixed by the State Government of Sabah
[4] The appeal by Chin Mui Kien (the 1st plaintiff at the trial) on the other hand was against the order at para 3(a) and (b) above whilst the appeal by Wong Thiam Phin (the plaintiff in the other suit) was against the dismissal of his claim for damages against Labuan Ferry for causing breach of his contract with a company known as Gold Coin.
[5] Wong Thiam Phin's grievance was that on 26 May 2011 Gold Coin terminated their contract and he suffered loss and damages as a result. His claim was for annual loss of RM1,106,213.40 calculated over a 21-month period for loss of business which amounted to RM1,935,873.45 and RM100,000.00 for loss of reputation and inconvenience
The Cross Appeal
[6] Labuan Ferry on its part cross appealed against that part of the decision of the High Court ordering it to refund the sum of RM112,670.00 to Wong Thiam Phin. We dismissed the cross appeal at the commencement of the hearing and upon objection raised by Wong Thiam Phin on the ground that the cross appeal did not relate to the subject matter of the appeal by Wong Thiam Phin: Kabushiki Kaisha Ngu v. Leisure Farm Corporation Sdn Bhd & Ors, [2016] 5 MLJ 557. Costs shall be borne by Labuan Ferry in the sum of RM5,000.00.
The Principal Relief Sought
[7] At the High Court, the principal relief sought by the respondents in the first appeal was for a declaration that the excessive charges imposed by Labuan Ferry for its ferry service between the two points, namely Labuan-Menumbok and Menumbok Labuan were unlawful and null and void.
Facts Of Case
[8] For the facts of the case, we can do no better than to reproduce, with the necessary modifications, the head note of the case as reported in Wong Thiam Phin v. Labuan Fe