2010 MarsdenLR 1313
HIGH COURT, MUAR
RAMATEX TEXTILES INDUSTRIAL SDN BHD & ANOR – Appellant
Versus
HONG LEONG ASSURANCE BERHAD – Respondent
[Civil Suit No: 23-57-2003]
Important Points
Subject
Insurance Law - Marine Insurance
Act Referred
Sales of Goods Act 1957: S.26
Marine Insurance Act 1906: S.48
Civil Law Act 1957: S.5
Headnote
(B) Insurable Interest - Requirement for property ownership and the relationship between sale terms (FOB) and risk transfer - Clarified the implications of the term FOB and how it affects title and risk in shipping context. (Paras 5.2 and 5.4)
(C) Marine Insurance - Insurance contract termination based on Clause 8.1 addressing conditions of transit interruptions and the implications for liability. (Paras 7 and 10)
1. This is a joint application by the Plaintiffs and the Defendant in enclosure 49 to refer questions to the Court for determination under Order 14A of the Rules of the High 1980 ("RHC") as follows:
1.1. whether or not the storage of the containers at the consignee's forwarder's yard [Foo Eng Cambodia Import - Export and Transportation Co. Ltd. ("Foo Eng")] was for "storage other than in the ordinary course of transit" within the meaning of Clause 8.1.2 of the Institute Cargo Clauses ("ICC") (A) 1/1/82?
1.2. whether the contract of insurance had terminated when the containers were left at the consignee's forwarder's yard (Foo Eng) pursuant to Clause 8 of ICC (A)?
1.3. whether the Plaintiffs have title to bring this action?
B. THE FACTS:
2. The first Plaintiff sent a consignment of clothing and fabric to June Textiles Co. Ltd. at Phnom Penh, Cambodia ("June Textiles") by sea vide containers. The consignment was insured by 7 marine policies of the Defendant. The 2nd Plaintiff also sent a consignment of clothing and fabric to June Textiles in a similar manner and the same was insured by the Defendant vide 3 marine policies. The insurance cover was for "warehouse to warehouse", that is, from the Plaintiffs' premises in Batu Pahat to the consignee's premises in Phnom Penh. The consignments arrived safely at the port of discharge in Sihanoukville Port, Phnom Penh, Cambodia and was sent by land to be delivered to the consignee. It was then kept at the consignee's forwarder's yard en route to the consignee's premises. However, on 5th and 6th July 1997 during civil riots in Phnom Penh, the entire consignment was looted by unknown thieves. The Plaintiffs suffered loss by reason of the lost consignments and made claims against the Defendant under the marine policies. The consignee never paid the Plaintiffs since it never received any of the consignments. The Plaintiffs filed this suit against the Defendant as insurer for the insured loss.
3. Before this application was made, the Defendant had filed an application under Order 18 rule 19 RHC ("Order 18 application") to strike out the Plaintiffs' claim by reason of the Plaintiffs being alleged to have no title to bring this action. The Order 18 application was agreed to be kept on hold whilst this application was agreed to be made without a trial being conducted. Both parties relied on all the Affidavits filed in the Order 18 application , the Common Bundle of Documents as well as the Agreed Facts for the purposes of this Order 14A proceedings.
4. It was agreed by the parties that the coverage of insurance for all the said marine cargo policies was subject to the Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 1.1.82, Institute War Clauses (Cargo) 1.1.82 and Institute Strikes Clauses (Cargo) 1.1.82 and such coverage was subject to an excess of 0.25 % on the total insured value.
C. Question 3 - Whether the Plaintiffs have title to bring action:
5. This question needs to be dealt with first as it would determine the other 2 questions posed. I answer the question in the negative, for the following reasons.
5.1. The Plaintiffs failed to exhibit the sales contract between the Plaintiffs and June Textiles to lend credence to what they had averred in their affidavits. What is left is documentary evidence which the Plaintiffs themselves had forwarded to the Defendant when first making their claims. Based on the:-
5.1.1. SGS Report of Findings, being the Plaintiffs' own documents and found on pages 6, 10, 14-15, 21-25, 29-30, 38, 42-43, 47-48, 52-53 ("SGS Report") of the Common Bundle of Documents;
5.1.2. the Combined Transport Bills of Lading found on pages 2, 8, 12, 17, 27, 32, 36, 40, 45 and 50 ("Bills of Lading") of the Common Bundle of Documents, I agree with the submission of learned counsel for the Defendant that the sales contract between the Plaintiffs and June Textile was on a FOB terms. The SGS Report shows the FOB prices of all the imported goods by June Textile, where the import duty and consumption tax were paid b