SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2022 MarsdenLR 1332

COURT OF APPEAL PUTRAJAYA
RATHNAVEL PACKIRISAMY & ORS – Appellant
Versus
KOPERASI NLFCS BERHAD – Respondent
[Civil Appeal No: W-02(NCvC)(W)-281-02-2020]



Important Points

The court determined that while a breach of trust was established, ordering damages assessment post-trial was appropriate due to complexities surrounding proof of profits.

Subject

Civil Law - Trust Law

Headnote

(A) High Court – Appeals – Assessment of damages – Liability established but separate assessment ordered – Proper procedure not bifurcated per the Appellant's claim – Reliefs included indemnity for losses, equitable compensation, restitution of profits. (Paras 1-2, 22-26, 28-29)

(B) Trust Law – Breach of trust and fiduciary duties established – Respondent acted as trustee without paying for the Land – Profit-sharing arrangement and unauthorized sales constitute breach. (Paras 20, 24-25)

Facts of the case: Appellants claimed against the Respondent regarding a 17.59-hectare land's development under a trust arrangement, intending each participant to acquire quarter-acre lots as part of the Temiang Land Scheme. (Paras 5-6)

Findings of Court: The court recognized an express trust and found it inappropriate to bifurcate the assessment of damages, directing an assessment of compensation per principles established. (Paras 28, 44)

Issues: Whether the learned trial Judge erred in ordering a separate damages assessment post-trial rather than deciding quantum at trial's end. (Paras 3, 29)

Ratio Decidendi: The court upheld that while breach of trust was established, adequate proof of the Respondent's profits and losses was essential for determining compensation; assessment remains the correct approach under these circumstances. (Paras 34-36)

Result: Appeal dismissed.

Petitioner Advocates:M Rajenthirakumar Malaiapan,Hiu Yeat Fong ,Respondent Advocate: DP Vijandran,Khairun Niza Husnin

Darryl Goon Siew Chye JCA:

[1] This was an appeal against the decision of the learned High Court Judge in ordering an assessment of damages after a full trial and after having made a finding on liability.

[2] The Appellants in this case were the plaintiffs, who had successfully obtained a decision on liability in their favour against the Respondent, the only defendant in the High Court.

[3] This appeal raises only one main issue and that is, whether the learned trial Judge ought to have determined the quantum of damages the Respondent was liable for, at the end of the trial and upon the evidence adduced at the trial, instead of ordering a separate assessment thereafter.

Background

[4] In order to assess the learned Judge's decision in making the order for the assessment of damages subsequent to the trial, the background, the Appellants' case and, particularly, the findings of the learned Judge need to be examined.

[5] The Appellants consisted of some 160 individuals. Their claim was in respect of a piece of land measuring 17.59 hectares, previously held under Grant No: 17937 Lot No: 3032 and, prior to that, under Grant No: 4010 Lot No: 715. This said land will hereinafter be referred to as the 'Land'. The Land has since been sub-divided into separate pieces and held under various new titles issued.

[6] Before its acquisition, an idea was mooted that the Land be acquired jointly by several individuals. These individuals included workers and residents, including the family members of residents, in and around the Temiang Estate in Seremban. It was then agreed that the Land, when acquired, would be divided into 160 lots of approximately a quarter of an acre (approximately 10,890 sq ft) each and the remaining portion of the Land be used as common property.

[7] The vendor of the Land, Sumle Enterprise, however, preferred to deal with one single entity and as such the Respondent was approached to purchase the property on behalf of the intending purchasers.

[8] The Respondent was and is a co-operative society registered under the Co-operative Societies Act 1993 and has, among its objectives, to uplift the socio-economic and land holding status of the Indian Community in Malaysia and to provide an opportunity for land and house ownership among Indian estate workers in the country.

[9] The Respondent agreed and it thus came to be that the Land was acquired by the Respondent in what became known as the 'Temiang Land Scheme'.

[10] The participants of this Temiang Land Scheme each paid a sum of RM550.00 to the Respondent towards the acquisition of the Land with a view to each participant acquiring approximately a quarter acre of it (approximately 10,890 sq ft).

[11] The Appellants consisted of both the original participants themselves and individuals claiming through or on behalf of the estate of the original participants in the Temiang Land Scheme.

[12] The Respondent's purchase of the Land was completed and the Land transferred to the Respondent in or around 1973.

[13] Additional sums of monies were subsequently paid by the original participants of the Temiang Land Scheme to the Respondent, towards expenses incurred in respect of the Land.

[14] Sometime in 1980 there was a meeting among the parties and there was said to be an agreement for the Land to be developed and then, thereafter, sub-divided and transferred to the participants.

[15] Sometime in 1981, it was agreed, inter alia, that the Land be developed as a housing project and the Respondent to implement this development.

[16] Several agreements were subsequently entered into between the parties and further payments made to the Respondent.

[17] In the meantime, several companies appointed by the Respondent to undertake the development of the Land failed. Ultimately, however, the development and the housing units for the Appellants were completed in 2004.

[18] Apart from the housing units for the Appellants, what was constructed on the Land were many more units of houses of varying sizes. The Appella

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top