The regulations prohibit reverting to a former name after a change, emphasizing the finality of name changes and the absence of a general duty to provide reasons for decisions unless warranted by the case's nature.

Collin Lawrence Sequerah:JCA

(A) Introduction

[1] This is an appeal against the decision of the High Court at Kuala Lumpur which had on 20 October 2023 dismissed the Appellant's application for Judicial Review with costs for the following reliefs:

a) An order for Certiorari to quash the decision of the 1st Respondent dated 21 January 2021 in rejecting the Appellant's application to amend the name of Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah No: identification card: 750423-71-5087 (A33757824) to original name of the Appellant which is K. Praghadheeswara a/l Raja Kaladasamy 750423-71-5087(433757824); No: identity card:

b) An order for Mandamus to compel the 1st Respondent to amend and register the name of Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah ID card No: 750423-71-5087 (A33757824) to the original name of the Appellant which is K. Praghadheeswara a/l Raja Kaladasamy (ID card No::750423-71- 5087 (A33757824);

c) A Declaratory order that the decision of the 1st Respondent dated 21 January 2021 in dismissing the Appellant's application was invalid and void;

d) Damages; and

e) Any other reliefs that the Court deems fit and proper.

(B) Pertinent Background Facts

[2] The Appellant is a citizen of Malaysia who was born on 23 April 1975 in Coimbatore, Tamil Naidu, India.

[3] The Appellant's birth certificate was issued by the Office of Assistant High Commissioner Malaysia in Madras under the name of K. Praghadheeswara Raja. His father's name was Kalandasamy.

[4] The Appellant was a Hindu from birth and professed the said religion at all material times.

[5] The 1st Respondent issued a Malaysian Registration Identity Card under the name of K. Praghadheeswara Raja all Kalandasamy (My Kad No: 750423-71-5087(A33757824)).

[6] In 2005, the Appellant converted to Islam at Jabatan Agama Islam Negeri Sembilan and he changed his name to Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah.

[7] On 4 October 2005, an application by the Appellant to change his name was allowed by the 1st Respondent under reg 14 of the National Registration Regulations 1990 . Consequent to that, a new identity card was issued under the name of Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah replacing the name of K. Praghadheeswara Raja a/l Kalandasamy.

[8] The Appellant successfully applied for and was given a new passport on 29 April 2015 under his new name of Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah and he flew to India using this new passport on 23 December 2016.

[9] However, the Indian Immigration refused to allow the Appellant entry into India due to the fact that he had previously entered India using a Malaysian passport under the name of K. Praghadheeswara Raja a/l Kalandasamy. As a result, the Appellant was deported to Malaysia.

[10] Upon his return to Malaysia, the Appellant claimed that on 22 March 2016, upon his application for a passport under his original name, the Director General of Malaysian Immigration revoked the passport under the name of Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah and replaced it with a new passport issued under the name of K. Praghadheeswara Raja a/l Kalandasamy (No. A35711811) for a duration of 5 years.

[11] The Appellant encountered difficulties with passport No. A35711811 wherein the Director General of Malaysian Immigration denied issuing the said passport and stated that all Malaysian passports were issued according to the name that appears on the identity card.

[12] The Appellant then claimed that he was granted a Tourist Visa from the Government of India for 5 years from 22 September 2019 to 20 September 2024 based on passport No A35711811. Passport No A35711811 will expire in 22 March2021.

[13] The Appellant claimed that he applied for a new passport in December 2020 under the name of K. Praghadheeswara Raja a/l Kalandasamy and this was refused by the Malaysian Immigration Department since his name in the identity card is Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah.

[14] The Appellant averred that several applications were made to 1st Respondent to change his name ie Sayyid Shah bin Abdullah to his original name ie K. Praghadheeswara Raja a/l Kalandasamy.

[15] However,