Mohd Radzi Abdul Hamid J:

GROUNDS OF JUDGMENTMATTER BEFORE THIS COURT

[1]This is a decision at the end of a full trial on a claim instituted by the Plaintiffs against all Defendants arising from issues related to the transfer of monies from the 2^nd Plaintiff (‘LMC’) to the 1^st Defendant and the functions and duties of the First Defendant as the Joint Management Body of a property known as Kondominium Lagenda (‘Lagenda’). This decision also relates to the Counter Claim instituted by all the Defendants against the Plaintiffs and one, Eng Song Huat who was at the material time a Director of the 1^st Plaintiff (‘Jeuro’).

[2]Based on the Statement of Claim, the Plaintiffs claim essentially rests on a claim that the 2^nd to 5^th Defendants who were Directors of LMC at the material time and also members of the Joint Management Committee of the Joint Management Body, Badan Pengurusan Bersama Kodominium Lagenda (‘JMB’) had wrongfully caused LMC to transfer to the JMB the amount of RM438,945.00 being maintenance charges collected by LMC as the management corporation appointed by the Jeuro. It is both the Plaintiffs’ claim that those monies belonged to Jeuro and therefore those monies should be ret