SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 MarsdenLR 114303


WA-24NCvC-6205-12/2025 Kand. 13
5 IN THE HIGH COURT OF MALAYA AT KUALA LUMPUR ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO: WA-24NCVC-6205-12/2025 IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF THOR AH KAM (NRIC NO.: 370628-06-5159)
10 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE GRANT OF LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION WITH WILL ANNEXED ISSUED BY THE HIGH COURT OF MALAYA AT KUALA LUMPUR
15 ON 25 AUGUST 2011 VIA PETITION NO. 31NCVC-634-2011 AND IN THE MATTER OF THE PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION ACT
1959 AND
20 IN THE MATTER OF ORDER 80 OF THE RULES OF COURT 2012 BETWEEN
1.THOR SIEW FUN (NRIC NO: 640115-06-5708)
25225 2.THOR MENG TATT (NRIC NO: 670828-06-5377)
… APPLICANTS AND THOR SIEW KEN (NRIC NO: 730209-06-5468)
30 … RESPONDENT
5

Date: 4.8.2026
15 NIXON ANAK KENNEDY KUMBONG Judicial Commissioner High Court of Malaya Kuala Lumpur
5 PARTIES For the Plaintiff:
Solicitor: Muhamad Fayyadh Bin Muhd Alwi
10 Messrs Yunus Ali & Kam No. 5A, Jalan Anggerik Aranda D31/D, Kota Kemuning, Section 31, 40460 Shah Alam, Selangor
15 For the Defendant:
Solicitor: Rudeen Chua Messrs Rudeen Chua & Co. 15-3, Jalan USJ 1/1A, USJ 1
20 47620 Subang Jaya, Selangor

Advocates:
For the Plaintiff: Solicitor: Muhamad Fayyadh Bin Muhd Alwi
For the Defendant: Solicitor: Rudeen Chua

JUDGMENT

Introduction

This Originating Summons is brought under Order 80 of the Rules of Court 2012 (“ROC 2012”) and the Probate and Administration Act 1959 (“PAA 1959”) in relation to the administration of the estate of the late Thor  Ah Kam (“the Deceased”).

The Deceased died on 18.01.2009, leaving a will dated 26.09.1997. A Grant of Letters of Administration with Will Annexed was issued on 25.08.2011 and extracted on 06.01.2012, appointing the Second Applicant and the Respondent as joint administrators of the estate.

 The Applicants’ core complaint is that, despite the passage of more than a decade, the estate remains incompletely administered, particularly in respect of immovable properties, and that the Respondent has failed to furnish proper accounts or status updates.

They seek, first, an order compelling the Respondent to produce and/or verify the estate accounts within 14 days, and, in the alternative, her removal as co-administrator and the issuance of a fresh grant naming the Applicants as joint administrators.

The Respondent resists the application, characterising it as procedurally defective, factually unsubstantiated and driven by family  friction rather than genuine estate risk. She contends that she has actively engaged in administration, that delays are attributable to complex title issues and beneficiary disagreements, and that no “sufficient cause” has been shown to justify her removal under s 34 PAA 1959.

Beneath the legal architecture, this is a sibling dispute in a land-heavy  estate, where ageing beneficiaries, long-running efforts, mistrust and  fatigue intersect. The court’s task is not to adjudicate family loyalties, but to ensure due and proper administration of the estate and to calibrate remedies in a way that is legally principled and humanly realistic.

Factual background  

The Deceased and the grant. The Deceased, Thor Ah Kam, died on 18.01.2009. A Grant of Letters of Administration with Will Annexed dated 25.08.2011 was issued by this court on 06.01.2012, appointing the Second Applicant, Thor Meng Tatt, and the Respondent, Thor Siew Ken, as joint administrators. The beneficiaries include the Deceased’s widow, Madam Chan Moi, and thirteen children, among them all three parties to this application.

The estate composition. The estate comprises both movable and immovable assets. The List of Assets and Liabilities exhibited in the probate petition identifies, inter alia, a Raub shop lot, a Raub house, other  lands, and interests in the estate of the Deceased’s mother, New Thoy.

The administration of these immovable properties has been the principal source of difficulty and contention.

Applicants’ narrative. The Applicants say that, despite their repeated attempts to obtain updates, the Respondent has failed to provide periodic accounts, bank statements or a clear status of administration. They aver that the Respondent blocked the First Applicant on WhatsApp and did not respond to a solicitors’ letter dated 24.01.2025 sent by AR registered post, which was returned “Tidak Dituntut”.

They emphasise that the Respondent holds the original title documents to the immovable properties, thereby effectively disabling the Second Applicant from acting as co-administrator.

Respondent’s narrative. The Respondent accepts her appointment and joint responsibility but attributes delay to complex legal issues and beneficiary indecision. She exhibits extensive WhatsApp and email communications showing discussions on valuation, sale strategy, caveats and title problems, particularly in relation to the Raub shop lot and Raub house.

She says she refused to sign sale documents where title was not yet properly vested in the estate, and that she exercised “fiduciary prudence” in resisting unsafe transactions. She further contends that the Second Applicant has been inactive, refused to be a signatory to the estate bank account, and has himself failed to honour commitments regarding properties held on trust.

Procedural history. The Originatin

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top