JUDGMENT

Raus Sharif JCA:

Introduction

[1] There are four inter-related appeals involving the same parties before the court. With the agreement of the parties, this court heard the four appeals together. The appeals are:

(i) W-02-207-04

An appeal by the defendant against the decision of Azmel Maamor J (as he then was) on 10 February 2004 in ordering interim injunctive orders (prohibitory and mandatory) against the defendant (1st appeal).

(ii) W-02-1021-04

An appeal by the plaintiff against the decision of Azmel Maamor J on 30 August 2004 in reviewing the mandatory injunction ordered against the defendant that he had granted on 10 February 2004 (2nd appeal).

(iii) W-02-34-07

An appeal by Tan See Siong and Soe Bank Tee (the defendant's directors) against the decision of Abdul Malik Ishak J (as he then was) on 20 December 2006 in finding the defendants' directors guilty for contempt and sentenced each of them to three weeks imprisonment and a fine of RM15,000 and in default thereof to one month imprisonment (3rd appeal).

(iv) W-02-1098-08

An appeal by the plaintiff against the decision of Mohd Yazid Mustafa JC on 15 September 2008, in dismissing the plaintiff's application