JUDGMENT

Hamid Sultan Abu Backer JC:

[1] This is my judgment in respect of the plaintiffs' claim for patent infringement and the defendants' counterclaim for the plaintiffs' patent number MY-106710-A to be invalidated and expunged.

[2] The plaintiffs' prayers can be summarised inter alia as follows: (a) a declaration that the plaintiffs' patent MY-106710-A is valid and subsisting in Malaysia and that it has been infringed on by the defendants, (b) an injunction to restrain the defendants from further infringing the plaintiffs' patent by producing any offending electronic cradles with features and functions attributes in the manner claimed in the plaintiffs' patent, (c) an order for the delivery or destruction of all offending cradles manufactured and distributed by the defendants with features and functions attributes in the manner claimed in the plaintiffs' patent, (d) an order for full discovery of all relevant documents, invoices etc in relation to the manufacture, use, distribution, sale and storage of the infringed electronic cradles with features and functions attributes in the manner claimed in the plaintiffs' patent, (e) an inquiry as to damages on the infringement or al