JUDGMENT
Mairin Idang JC:
Introduction
[1] The 1st plaintiff is the duly appointed attorney of the 2nd plaintiff. The 2nd plaintiff is the registered proprietor of a parcel of land situate at Sungai Sibuti, Miri containing an area of 304 hectares more or less and described as Lot 16 Bukit Kisi Land District (Lot 16). Lot 16 is still under provisional lease (PL). The 1st and 2nd plaintiffs shall also be referred collectively as the plaintiffs.
[2] The defendant has entered and planted oil palm trees on approximately 720 hectares of land which included Lot 16 (the subject land).
The Caveat
[3] On the 3 September 2012 the defendant lodged a caveat against Lot 16 at the Miri Land Registry Office as Instrument No L 11755/2012 (the said caveat). The grounds in support of the said caveat are stated in the Statutory Declaration (SD) of Lee Chi Hong dated 7 August 2012. I now reproduce the relevant paragraphs:
"7. Sometimes in the year 1999, the contractor appointed by the company has accidentally planted outside the boundary of Lot 70 Sawai Land District over an area of land measuring approximately 720 Ha, which is shaded in yellow in annexure "A" (hereinafter referred to as "the subject land"). The shaded area was believed to be part of the state land then.
8. In year 2001, the company wrote to the Land and Survey Department, Miri to apply for provisional lease to be issued over the said subject land, in replacement of Lot 14 Bukit Kisi Land District and Lot 200 Bakong Land District.
A copy of the letter dated 12 July 2001 is annexed herein and marked "B".
9. By a letter dated 26 September 2002, the Land and survey Department, Miri had informed the company that the said application made by the company is being considered, and that the company will be informed of the outcome of the application in due course. The company had not heard from the Land & Survey Department thereafter.
A copy of the letter dated 26 September 2002 is annexed herein and marked "C".
10. A few weeks before the date of this declaration, the company discovered that there were surveyors entering into the subject land for the purpose of conducting a survey. The company later found out from the surveyors that part of the subject land is now held by Metro Presence Sdn Bhd under a provisional lease described as Lot 16, Bukit Kisi Land District.
A copy of the land title issued to Metro Presence Sdn Bhd is annexed herein and marked as "D".
11. As the company has fully planted oil palm on the subject land and invested considerable amount of money in building the infrastructure on the subject land, I am advised by M/s Jimmy HT Wee & Co Advocates that the company has a caveatable interest over the subject land."
Application To Remove The Caveat
[4] On the 1 October 2014 the plaintiffs filed an application (encl 1) to remove the said caveat. The grounds in support of the plaintiffs' application are stated in the affidavit in support (the AIS) of Mr Chia Chok Hian as follows:
a) The 2nd plaintiff is still the registered proprietor of Lot 16;
b) The 1st plaintiff is the attorney for the 2nd plaintiff in respect of Lot 16;
c) On the 3 September 2012 the defendant had lodged the said caveat registered as Instrument No L 11755/2012 at Miri Land Registry Office against Lot 16 claiming to be entitled to or beneficially interested in the said Lot 16.
d) The ground stated in the defendant's Statutory Declaration that the defendant's contractor had accidently planted outside of the boundary of Lot 70 Sawai Land District over an area of land measuring approximately 720 hectares believed to be State land does not disclose that the defendant has any legal or beneficial interest in the said affected area or any caveatable interest in Lot 16.
The Parties' Affidavits
[5] The parties have filed the following affidavits:
a) Affidavit in support (encl 2) affirmed by Chia Chok Hian on the 1 Ocotber 2014 (AIS);
b) Affidavit in reply 1 (encl 6) affirmed by Mr. Chia Chok Hian on 24 November 2014 (AIR);
c) Affidavit in opp