2025 Supreme(SRI)(SC) 9707
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE DEMOCRATIC SOCIALIST REPUBLIC OF SRI LANKA In the matter of an Application for leave to Appeal in terms of Section 5(c)(1) of the High Court of the Provinces (Special Provisions) Act. No 19 of 1990 as amended by the High Court of the Provinces (Special Provisions) (Amendment) Act No. 54 of 2006.
Nisha Kanthi Peiris No. 49, Wattaranthanna Lane, Kandy.
PLAINTIFF Vs.
Case No - SC/Appeal: 123/2019 Siril Jayawardena Karunaratne No. 49 A, SC/HCCA/LA - 416/2018 Wattaranthanna Lane, CP/HCCA/140/2015 (FA)
Kandy.
DEFENDANT AND THEN Nisha Kanthi Peiris No. 49, Wattaranthanna Lane, Kandy.
PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT Vs.
Siril Jayawardena Karunaratne No. 49 A, Wattaranthanna Lane, Kandy.
DEFENDANT-RESPONDENT AND NOW BETWEEN Siril Jayawardena Karunaratne No. 49 A, Wattaranthanna Lane, Kandy.
DEFENDANT-RESPONDENT-
APPELLANT Vs.
Nisha Kanthi Peiris No. 49, Wattaranthanna Lane, Kandy.
PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT-
RESPONDENT Before: Justice A. L. Shiran Gooneratne Justice K. Priyantha Fernando Justice Sampath B. Abayakoon Counsel: Bhagya Herath with Sajeevi Jayasinghe and Abirami Balasubramaniam instructed by P. G. Ruwini Sakunthala for the Defendant-Respondent-Appellant.
Olivia Thomas instructed by Piyumi Kumari for the Plaintiff-
Appellant-Respondent.
Argued on: 03/10/2025 Decided on: 31/10/2025 A.L. Shiran Gooneratne J.
This matter arises from an Appeal filed by the Defendant-Respondent- Appellant (hereinafter referred to as the “Appellant”) challenging the Judgment of the Civil Appellate High Court of Kandy dated 26/10/2018, which allowed the Appeal of the Plaintiff-Appellant-Respondent (hereinafter referred to as the “Respondent”), and awarded damages in the sum of Rs. 100,000/- for Malicious Prosecution.
The Respondent instituted action in the District Court of Kandy in Case No. 35999/06, seeking damages for losses sustained due to the Appellant’s malicious institution of criminal proceedings against her. The criminal proceedings in question stemmed from Case No. 96483 filed by the Appellant in the Magistrate’s Court of Kandy by way of a Private Plaint, alleging that the Respondent had violated a ‘settlement agreement’ in Case No. 32000 filed in the Magistrate’s Court of Kandy, for obstructing a roadway granted to the Appellant.
The Appellant alleged that the Respondent had dumped garbage on the said roadway, shouting at persons using the roadway, and throwing stones at a moving vehicle. Based on the said allegations, the Respondent was charged under Section 73 of the Primary Courts Procedure Act No. 44 of 1979. The learned Magistrate, by Judgment dated 11/07/2003, found the Respondent guilty as charged.
However, upon appeal, the High Court of Kandy, by Judgment dated
22/09/2004, acquitted the Respondent, held inter alia that:
● the alleged conduct, if at all, should have been prosecuted under the Penal Code, ● there was insufficient evidence to conclude that the Respondent had obstructed the roadway or violated the said settlement, and therefore could not be found guilty under Section 73 of the Primary Courts Procedure Act.
Following the acquittal, the Respondent instituted the present action in the District Court of Kandy for malicious prosecution. The Appellant sought a dismissal of the action and brought a counter claim seeking Rs. 2,000,000/- in damages, alleging that the Respondent’s civil action before the District Court constituted malicious conduct.
The Learned Additional District Judge of Kandy, by Judgment dated 12/06/2015, dismissed both the Respondent’s action and the Appellant’s claim in reconvention. The Court held, inter alia, that since the Respondent’s cause of action accrued on the date of conviction, the action was time-barred. The court held that the Appellant failed to establish malice or quantify losses sustained. The court was also of the view that the Appellant failed to lead evidence in support of his claim in reconvention.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment, the Respondent appealed to the Civil Appeals High Court of Kandy (“the