SILVA v. FERNANDO
NLR21V383
Present : Loos A. J.
SILVA v. FERNANDO.
327- C. R. Negombo, 25,337.
Husband and wife-Implied authority to pledge husband's credit-Waiver of debt.
A presumption of authority from the mere fact of cohabitation would not extend
beyond the pledging by the wife of her husband's credit for necessaries ; there
is no presumption of authority to borrow money in his name ; and, similarly,
there would be no presumption of authority to waive a claim for money due to her
husband.
THE
facts appear from the judgment.
A. St. V. Jayawardene, for defendant, respondent.
Canakeratne, for plaintiff,
appellant.
March 26, 1919. Loos A.J.-
The plaintiff became entitled to a share of certain premises of which defendant
was the tenant in January, 1916, and in June, 1917, he sued the defendant for
the rent due in respect thereof. Defendant filed answer alleging the payment of
a sum of Rs. 505 to plaintiff's predecessor in title between March, 1912, and
October, 1915, on the understanding that that sum was to be set off against the
rent due by him, and that, after setting it off against the rent due to
September, 1917, there was still a balance due to him. The defendant was not
present at the trial and judgment was obtained by plaintiff as prayed for by
him.
On the plaintiff applying for writ of execution, the defendant filed an
affidavit alleging that after decree had been entered an adjustment thereof had
been made. His contention was that the plaintiff had agreed to make the set-off
referred to in the answer after decree had been ordered, and in support thereof
he relied on a letter (D 1) written by the plaintiff's wife on September 28,
1918, in which she admits that the payments referred to by the defendant had
been received by her and her mother, and states that the balance due by the
defendant as rent to September, 1917, might be taken by him as interest. She
further states that rent will be recovered at Rs. 15 per mensem by the "
gentleman," referring to her husband apparently.
The learned Commissioner holds that it is incredible that such a letter would
have been written by the plaintiff's wife without his knowledge; that there is
nothing to show that she would have taken upon herself the responsibility of
waiving what had been decreed in favour of her husband without his acquiescence;
and he argues that the reference to the recovery of rent at Rs. 15 implies that
the letter was written with the authority of her husband, the plaintiff; and he
holds that there was an adjustment of the decree.
The plaintiff's wife was called as a witness by the defendant at the inquiry,
and she stated that the letter D 1 had been written at the request of her
mother. It was contended by the respondent's counsel that the plaintiff's wife
must be regarded as having been expressly or impliedly authorized by her husband
to write the letter, and he relied on section 18 of the Ceylon Evidence
Ordinance, 1895. The applicability of that section would depend on the question
of the extent to which a man's wife is his agent. A presumption of authority
from the mere fact of cohabitation would not extend beyond the pledging by the
wife of her husband's credit for necessaries; there is no presumption of
authority to borrow money in his name; and, similarly, I think there would be no
presumption of authority to waive a claim for money due to her husband.
There can be little doubt that the plaintiff's wife was not expressly authorized
to make any adjustment of the decree. The plaintiff states that he was not aware
of the existence of the letter D 1, and that he did not enter into any such
arrangement as defendant relies on.
It appears to me that the evidence does not establish an express or implied
authority to plaintiff's wife to write the letter D I, and that no adjustment of
the decree was in fact made. The order appealed from must be set aside, with
costs.
Set aside.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.