SEDRIS v. RAMANATHAN
NLR23V315
Present : Bertram
C. J. and Garvin A. J. 1921.
SEDRIS v. RAMANATHAN.
103-D.C.Galle,466.
Insolvency - Power of Court to annul adjudication - Application by opposing
creditor for an adjournment with a view to making an application for the
annulment of adjudication.
The power of the Court to annul an adjudication in bankruptcy is not limited to
cases for which special provision is made in the Insolvency Ordinance. The Court
has a general power to annul an adjudication in appropriate circumstances.
APPELLANT was, on an application made by him under section 20 of Ordinance No. 7
of 1853 on December 21, 1920, to have his estate adjudged insolvent and placed
under sequestration, adjudged insolvent under the provisions of section 26 of
the said Ordinance.
Two sittings were appointed under section 30 and estate adjudged insolvent, and
all other incidental steps having been gone through, and his last examination
having been proceeded with, the second sitting was declared closed, and a public
sitting was appointed for the allowance of his certificate, under the provisions
of section 124 of the Ordinance, for July 12,1921.
On July 8, 1921, the assignee gave notice of his intention to oppose the
granting of the certificate on four grounds.
On July 12, 1921, on an oral application made by counsel for opposing creditor
asking for an adjournment of the certificate meeting to enable him to prove that
the assets are not enough to pay five shillings in the pound, and to take the
necessary steps to have the adjudication of insolvency annulled, the District
Judge, over-ruling the objections raised by counsel for appellant to an
adjournment, adjourned the meeting.
The insolvent appealed.
Soertsz, for the appellant-An order of adjudication once published in the
Gazette is a judgment in rem, and cannot be annulled thereafter (see sections
30,41, and 143).
The whole of our insolvency laws is to be found within the four corners of the
Ordinance, and in the Ordinance there is no provision for annulment of the
adjudication in the circumstances of this case.
The Ordinance provides for the Court satisfying itself of the sufficiency of the
estate before the adjudication, and once the Court has satisfied itself and
adjudged the estate insolvent, the Court cannot reconsider its decision. In this
case the mere fact that the estate later realized less than five shillings in
the pound cannot
prejudice the appellant. That may be due to various causes, and "77~ the estate
may well have been worth five shillings in the pound at the date of the
petition.
Keuneman for respondent.-The Court has a general power to annul an adjudication. Ex parte
Spicer;[1] Ex parte Charles Louis.[2] The material before the Court was not
sufficient for the Court to adjudicate upon the sufficiency of the estate, and
it is now open to the Court to annul the adjudication. 5 Bal. Notes of Cases 1.
December 2, 1921. BERTRAM C.J.-
This is an appeal by an insolvent against the order of the District Judge of
Galle granting an adjournment with a view to enabling an opposing creditor to
make an application for the annulment of the adjudication. The learned Judge has
seen fit to grant an adjournment. There is no substantial justice in the
application which the opposing creditor desires to make. The petition was
presented by the insolvent himself at a time when he was undergoing imprisonment
as a civil debtor. He presented the petition a day after the commencement of his
imprisonment, and the ground of his petition was that he would not be able to
satisfy the Court that his assets would realize five shillings in the pound. Had
he waited for three weeks, he would, under the final sentence of section 20 of
the Insolvents Estate Ordinance, No. 7 of 1853, have been able to apply for an
adjudication without satisfying the Court as to the amount of his assets. The
sole object of this application is to subject the
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.