PERERA v. PERERA
NLR49V254
1948 Present : Canekeratne and Dias JJ.
PERERA, Appellant, and PERERA,
Respondent.
S. C. 259-D. C. Avissawella, 4,773.
Married woman-Disposal of immovable property-Consent of husband in Writing- Void
or voidable-Matrimonial Rights Ordinance-Married Women's Property Ordinance.
A woman married before July 1, 1924, cannot dispose of immovable property
acquired before that date without the written consent of the husband.
APPEAL from a judgment of the District Judge, Avissawella.
H. V. Perera, K.C., with E. A. P. Wijeyeratne, for the plaintiff, appellant.
N. K. Choksy, K.C., with S. R. Wijayatilake and E. C. F. de Silva,
for the
defendants, respondents.
Cur. adv. vult.
March 22, 1948. CANEKERATNE J.-
This is an appeal by the plaintiff, a grand-daughter of one Ango Perera, from a
judgment dismissing her action for declaration of title to a land.
Ango Perera became the owner of the land by two deeds dated April 1, 1907, and
July 13, 1907, respectively; she made a gift in favour of the plaintiff by deed
P 1 dated October 25, 1941, reserving a life-interest to herself and her husband
and by deed 1 D 1 dated August 10, 1944, she transferred the same land with the
consent of her husband to the first defendant, another grand-daughter-it
purports to be a deed if sale.
As Ango Perera was married after the proclamation of the 1 Patrimonial Rights
and Inheritance Ordinance of 1876, this land formed part of her separate estate.
The right of a married woman to enter into contracts, and to make dispositions
of her property under certain circumstances was recognised by this Ordinance (as
regards the former, see sections 10 and 9, and 17 N. L. E. 357, as regards the
latter see sections 9, 12 and 13). The second part of the Ordinance which
contained sections 5 to 19 and sections 22 and 23 was repealed and the scope of
her capacity to contract and of her rights was widely extended by the Married
Women's Property Ordinance, No. 18 of 1923. The Ordinance applies to all married
women, whether they were married before the date of the Ordinance, July 1, 1924,
or after : certain persons are taken out of the purview of the Ordinance
(section 3). The new law ought to be construed so as to interfere as little as
possible with vested rights. A retrospective operation is not to be given to a
statute so as to impair an existing right or obligation. The repeal of sections
5 to 19, 22 and 23 is, according to the proviso to section 4, not to affect any
right acquired while those sections were in force.
The Ordinance provided in effect that if a woman married on or after July 1,
1924, all her property no matter when acquired should be her separate property
and she can dispose of any property belonging to her as if she were a feme sole
(section 7 and section 5(1)). It contains certain provisions which are
applicable to a woman married before this date. The position of such a woman is
as follows :-(1) She is entitled to dispose of in manner previously mentioned in
the Ordinance as a fame sole by deed or will as her separate property whatever
accrued to her after the commencement of the Ordinance (section 10 (1)). The
section applies to and affects all marriages contracted before the commencement
of the Ordinance and alters with respect to such marriages in the manner
indicated in the section the consequences of the marital relation. (2) She can
make a gift of immovable property acquired before the Ordinance
to her husband. It was an existing right at the time of the passing of the
Ordinance of 1923, and the new Ordinance does not alter this right. The Privy
Council in Hulme King v. de Silva 1 stated that under section 5 of the Ordinance
a wife is under no disability as regards covertures in disposing of her
immovable property in favour of her husband. A married woman while the Ordinance
of 1876 was in force could not dispose of any immovable property by a deed inter rivos. except w
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.