JANE NONA v. GUNAWARDENE
NLR49V522
1948 Present : Dias and
Basnayake JJ.
JANE NONA, Appellant, and GUNAWARDENE,
Respondent.
S. C. 193-D. C. Negombo, 13,959
Prescription-Execution sale-Debtor in
possession after sale-Interruption- Delivery of possession by Fiscal-Undivided
share-How far delivery valid-Civil Procedure Code-Section 288.
Appellant mortgaged an undivided half share of a field which was sold in
execution and purchased by M. Order for delivery of possession was issued and
the Fiscal reported that he was unable to trace the co-owners and that the
purchaser failed to attend to receive possession. The Fiscal then purported to
act under section 288 of the Civil Procedure Code and deliver possession to the
purchaser. Appellant continued in possession of the field.
Held, (i) that a judgment debtor who continues in adverse possession
after a sale in execution can acquire title by prescription ;
(ii) that symbolical possession by a purchaser at a court sale is not
interruption of such possession. There must be an interruption of actual
physical possession.
(iii) Where property is not in the occupation of anyone section 288 of the Civil
Procedure Code has no application and the action of the Fiscal was a nullity.
APPEAL
from a judgment of the District Judge, Negombo.
N. E. Weerasooria, K.C., with B. Senaratne, for the defendant
appellant.
No appearance for the plaintiff, respondent.
Cur. adv. vult.
April 20, 1948.
Basnayake J.-
As security for a loan of Rs. 1,500 by deed No. 1,443 dated June 22, 1926,
attested by A. D. C. Ainirthaweera, Notary Public, the defendant-appellant
(hereinafter referred to as the appellant) created a mortgage in favour of two
persons named Kaluaratchige Herath Appuhamy and Weerasinghe Aratchige Charlis
Perera over her undivided half share of a field called Pitakotuwe Kumbura in
extent four acres, two roods, and thirty-three perches, and some other lands.
The mortgages above-mentioned instituted D. C. Negombo, Case No. 3,502 for the
recovery of the debt due to them and in execution of the decree therein the
appellant's share in the field Pitakotuwe Kumbura was sold and purchased by one
Weeragoda Achchilage Mudiyanse to whom it was transferred by deed No. 140 of
April 4, 1936, attested by H. C. Sansoni, Notary Public.
On February 17, 1937, an order for delivery of
possession was issued. The order was in the following terms :
" You are hereby ordered to put the said purchaser or his agent into possession
of the said lands and fields and the buildings and if need be to remove any
person bound by the decree who may refuse to vacate the same."
On March 23, 1937, the Fiscal reported :
" My Officer reports that he was unable to trace the co-owners of the undivided
lands and that the purchaser failed to attend and receive possession of the
divided lands.",
and asked for an extension of time to enable him to proceed under section 288 of
the Civil Procedure Code. The extension was granted. On February 3, 1938, he
reported :
" By virtue of the hereto annexed Order for Delivery of Possession marked A
issued in case No. 3, 502 of the District Court of Negombo, I have caused my
Officer D. S. A. Amerasekera to deliver possession of 1, 2, 4 and 6th named
undivided shares to the purchaser on January 24, 1938, in terms of section 288
of the C. P. C. and the complete possession of 3rd and 5th named lands which are
more fully described in the Order for Delivery of Possession to the purchaser on
the same day, as will appear from the affidavit of the said Officer, Marked B
dated February 3, 1938."
Affidavit B referred to :
" I, D. S. A. Amarasekera, Fiscal's Officer, do hereby declare and affirm that I
did on January 24, 1938, deliver possession of the 1st, 2nd, 4th and 6th named
undivided shares in terms of Section 288 of the C. P. C. and the complete
possession of 3rd and 5th named lands which are more fully described in the
Order for Delivery
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.