IN RE NOOR JEHAN
NLR56V29
1954 Present: Pulle J.
IN RE NOOR JEHAN
S. C. 519-In Revision M. C. Colombo 1,211 /B
Habeas corpus-Power of Court
to remand a girl to the Salvation Army Home-Courts Ordinance (Cap. 6), s. 45.
A Court has no jurisdiction to remand a girl to the Salvation Army Home during
the pendency of a case of kidnapping her.
Vaithalingam v. Gnanapathipillai (1944) 46 N. L. R. 235, followed.
APPLICATION
to revise an order of the Magistrate's Court, Colombo.
M. Markhani, for the petitioner.
April 23, 1954. PULLE J.-
In this case two persons were charged with the offence of having on the 11th
March, 1954, kidnapped a girl named Noor Jehan alias Nagoor Umma who was born on
26th August, 1938. The learned Magistrate assumed jurisdiction under section 152
(3) of the Criminal Procedure Code and fixed the trial for the 3rd May, 1954.
The girl who was produced in Court refused to go with her mother and she was
remanded to the Salvation Army Home. The mother moved in revision to have the
order of remand set aside on the ground that the Magistrate had no
jurisdiction to make it. At the
time this application first came before me I felt that if the Magistrate had no
jurisdiction I should make a further order granting the custody of the girl to
the mother. Treating the application as one that should be inquired into under
section 46 of the Courts Ordinance I called for a report from the Magistrate who
stated that the girl was unwilling to go with the mother and that, therefore,
she should not be handed over to her.
Mr. Markhani for the petitioner has drawn my attention to the case of
Vaithalingam v. Gnanapathipillai [1 (1944) 46 N. L. R. 235.] in which Soertsz J. held in similar
circumstances that a remand to the Salvation Army Home was illegal. I would,
therefore, set aside the order of remand and direct that the girl be handed over
to the mother who is entitled to have the custody.
Application allowed.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.