PREMAWANSA v. SOMALATHA
NLR63V551
1961 Present: Tambiah,
J.
U. S. PREMAWANSA, Appellant, and K. SOMALATHA,
Respondent
S. C. 223-M. C. Matale, 5531
Maintenance-Order made in
favour of wife-Effect on it of subsequent divorce- Kandyan Marriages and Divorce
Act No. 44 of 1952 (as amended by Act No. 34 of 1954), s. 35.
An order for maintenance in favour of a wife ceases to have effect after the
date of her subsequent divorce.
The appellant was married to the respondent under the Kandyan Marriages and
Divorce Act on the 18th February 1957. On the 21st July 1959, in a maintenance
action filed by the respondent, the appellant was ordered to pay maintenance.
Subsequently, divorce proceedings were filed under the above-mentioned Act and
an order granting dissolution was made on the 16th December 1959 by the District
Registrar. In the divorce proceedings the District Registrar ordered the
appellant to pay the respondent the same sum as ordered by the Magistrate in the
maintenance proceedings.
Held, that no distress warrant could be issued to recover any
arrears of maintenance due after the date of the divorce.
APPEAL
from an order of the Magistrate's Court,
Matale.
L. G. Weeramantry, for the Respondent-Appellant.
No appearance for the Applicant-Respondent.
Cur. adv. vult.
June 22, 1961. TAMBIAH, J.-
The appellant was married to the respondent under the Kandyan Marriages and
Divorce Act (No. 44 of 1952, as amended by Act No. 34 of 1954), on the 18th of
February 1957. On the 21st of July 1959, in the maintenance action filed by the
respondent against the appellant, the latter -was ordered to pay maintenance at
the rate of Rs. 10 per month to the respondent. Subsequently, divorce
proceedings were filed under the abovementioned Act and an order granting
dissolution was made on the 16th of December 1959 by the District Registrar.
On an application made by the respondent, by motion dated 26th November 1959,
claiming arrears of maintenance and a distress warrant to recover the same, an
inquiry was held by the learned Magistrate on the 3rd of December 1960. At the
inquiry, the appellant produced the certificate of divorce granted by the
District Registrar and claimed that the Court cannot enforce the order for
maintenance as the marriage between, the parties had been dissolved. The learned
Magistrate rejected the submission of the appellant and made order that the
respondent was
entitled to recover from the
appellant arrears of maintenance at Rs. 10 per month. The appellant has appealed
from the order of the learned Magistrate.
An order for the dissolution of marriage has the effect of rendering the order
for maintenance ineffective as from the date of the dissolution (vide Abdur
Rahaman v. Sakhina 1[5 Calcutta 558.]; In the matter of Din Muhammed
2[5 Allahabad 226.]; Mt. Aziman v. Pir Baksh 3[1876 Pun.
Rep. No. 1 Cr, p. 1 (2).]; Meniki v. Siyathuwa 4[(1940) 42 N. L. R.
53 at 54.]. This Court has even gone to the extent of holding that an order for
separation has the same effect, vide Simon Appu v. Somawathie 5[(1933)
56 N. L. R. 275.]). It would be artificial to contend that because the order was
not cancelled, a right, which has been extinguished, could be revived and a
liability that had been terminated could be enforced (Simon Appu v. Somawathie
(supra) ). Hence, the order for maintenance ceases to have any effect after the
date of the divorce.
However, in the instant case, the respondent is not without a remedy. The
District Registrar, acting under the Kandyan Marriages and Divorce Act (supra),
has ordered the appellant to pay the respondent the same sum as ordered by the
Magistrate in the maintenance proceedings. The respondent could enforce this
order in the same manner as an order made by the District Court in a matrimonial
action under Chapter 48 of the Civil Procedure Code (vide Sec. 35 of the Act,
No. 44 of 1952). Under the repealed Ordinance (Kandyan Marriages Ordinance (Cap.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.