22-2908 (L); 22-2933; 22-2987; 22-3237
Antonyuk; Hardaway; Christian; Spencer v. Chiumento

                       UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
                            FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
                              ____________________

                                    August Term, 2022

             Argued: March 20, 2023                Decided: December 8, 2023

         Docket Nos. 22-2908 (L), 22-2972 (Con); 22-2933; 22-2987; 22-3237
                             ____________________

    IVAN ANTONYUK, COREY JOHNSON, ALFRED TERRILLE, JOSEPH MANN, LESLIE
                       LEMAN, LAWRENCE SLOANE,

                                                Plaintiffs-Appellees,

                                              v.

DOMINICK L. CHIUMENTO, in his official capacity as the Acting Superintendent of
   the New York State Police, MATTHEW J. DORAN, in his official capacity as the
Licensing Official of Onondaga County, JOSEPH CECILE, in his Official Capacity as
                         the Chief of Police of Syracuse,

                                                Defendants-Appellants,

 KATHLEEN HOCHUL, in her official capacity as the Governor of the State of New
  York, WILLIAM FITZPATRICK, in his official capacity as the Onondaga County
   District Attorney, EUGENE CONWAY, in his official capacity as the Sheriff of
    Onondaga County, P. DAVID SOARES, in his official capacity as the District
   Attorney of Albany County, GREGORY OAKES, in his official capacity as the
 District Attorney of Oswego County, DON HILTON, in his official capacity as the
   Sheriff of Oswego County, JOSEPH STANZIONE, in his official capacity as the
                       District Attorney of Greene County,

                                                Defendants.
                            ____________________

   JIMMIE HARDAWAY, JR., LARRY A. BOYD, FIREARMS POLICY COALITION, INC.,
                SECOND AMENDMENT FOUNDATION, INC.,

                                        Plaintiffs-Appellees,

                                       v.

DOMINICK L. CHIUMENTO, in his official capacity as the Acting Superintendent of
                        the New York State Police,

                                        Defendant-Appellant,

BRIAN D. SEAMAN, in his official capacity as the District Attorney for the County
  of Niagara, New York, JOHN J. FLYNN, in his official capacity as the District
                Attorney for the County of Erie, New York,

                                      Defendants-Appellees.
                            ____________________

   BRETT CHRISTIAN, FIREARMS POLICY COALITION, INC., SECOND AMENDMENT
                            FOUNDATION, INC.,

                                        Plaintiffs-Appellees,

                                 JOHN BROWN,

                                        Plaintiff,

                                       v.

DOMINICK L. CHIUMENTO, in his official capacity as the Acting Superintendent of
                        the New York State Police,

                                        Defendants-Appellants,


                                       2
JOHN J. FLYNN, in his official capacity as District Attorney for the County of Erie,
                                     New York,

                                            Defendant-Appellee.
                                  ____________________

             MICHEAL SPENCER, HIS TABERNACLE FAMILY CHURCH, INC.,

                                               Plaintiffs-Appellees,

                                              v.

DOMINICK L. CHIUMENTO, Acting Superintendent of the New York State Police, in
    his official capacity, and STEVEN A. NIGRELLI in his individual capacity,

                                               Defendants-Appellants,

WEEDEN A. WETMORE, District Attorney for the County of Chemung, New York,
   in his official and individual capacities, MATTHEW VAN HOUTEN, District
Attorney for the Count