2024 Supreme(US)(ca7) 143
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
Hamilton
Word Seed Church – Appellant
Versus
Village of Hazel Crest – Respondent
United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit ____________________ No. 23-1754 WORD SEED CHURCH, now known as Grace Fellowship Covenant Church, Plaintiff-Appellant,
v. VILLAGE OF HAZEL CREST, Defendant-Appellee. ____________________
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division. No. 1:20-cv-07725 — Harry D. Leinenweber, Judge. ____________________
ARGUED JANUARY 9, 2024 — DECIDED AUGUST 6, 2024 ____________________
Before ROVNER, HAMILTON, and JACKSON-AKIWUMI, Circuit Judges. HAMILTON, Circuit Judge. Plaintiff-appellant Word Seed Church believes that the Village of Hazel Crest zoning ordi- nance discriminates against churches and other religious as- semblies. The district court disagreed, granted summary judgment to the village, and later denied the church’s motion for relief from judgment. The church has appealed. 2 No. 23-1754
Before we reach the merits of the church’s arguments,
though, we must address some preliminary jurisdictional is-
sues posed by the case’s unusual procedural posture. The
church did not appeal the district court’s grant of summary
judgment. Instead, the church filed a motion under Federal
Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b) for relief from that final judg-
ment and then appealed only the district court’s denial of its
Rule 60(b) motion. When an appeal arrives to us in this pos-
ture, we may not second-guess the district court’s exercise of
its subject matter jurisdiction unless the court made an egre-
gious mistake on that score or intervening events have ren-
dered the case moot. Neither happened in this case. We there-
fore have appellate jurisdiction and subject matter jurisdiction
over this appeal, and we affirm on the merits the district
court’s denial of the church’s Rule 60(b) motion because the
district court did not abuse its discretion in making that deci-
sion.
I. Factual Background
The Word Seed Church, now known as Grace Fellowship
Covenant Church, is a congregation in the south suburbs of
Chicago. Like many new congregations, the church did not
have a permanent home but began looking for one in 2018 or
2019. The church identified the Village of Hazel Crest as one
possible location, but the church had trouble finding a suita-
ble property there. The church claims that this difficulty was
caused by the village’s zoning ordinance, which it contends
discriminates against religious assemblies.
The village’s zoning ordinance establishes nine zoning
districts: four for residential use (R-0, R-1, R-2, and R-3), two
for business (B-1 and B-2), one for limited manufacturing (M-
1), one for Special Planned Development (SPD), and one for
No. 23-1754 3 office, research and compatible use (M-OR). The ordinance
imposes certain restrictions on properties in each district,
such as limits on building heights and lot sizes. It also sets out
permitted and special uses for each zoning district. A permit-
ted use is one that “may be lawfully established in a particular
district or districts, provided it conforms with all require-
ments, regulations and performance standards (if any) of such
district.” Churches are not an enumerated permitted use in
any of the nine zoning districts.
Only three zoning districts, all of them residential, permit
churches as a special use: R-1, R-2, and R-3. But a group or
person may not open a church in these districts without a spe-
cial use permit. The zoning ordinance establishes a multi-step
process for acquiring one. First, a land user must submit a
special use application to the village’s Zoning Administrator.
Then a nine-person Zoning Commission reviews the applica-