2017 Supreme(US)(ca7) 61
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
Ripple, Rovner, Sykes
Lana Canen – Appellant
Versus
Dennis Chapman – Respondent
United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit ____________________ No. 16-1621 LANA CANEN, Plaintiff-Appellant,
v. DENNIS CHAPMAN, in his individual capacity as Deputy for the Elkhart County Sheriff Department, Defendant-Appellee. ____________________
Appeal from the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, South Bend Division. No. 3:14-cv-00315-RL — Rudy Lozano, Judge. ____________________
ARGUED SEPTEMBER 23, 2016 — DECIDED JANUARY 27, 2017 ____________________
Before RIPPLE, ROVNER, and SYKES, Circuit Judges.
RIPPLE, Circuit Judge. Lana Canen was convicted of felony
murder on August 10, 2005 in Indiana state court. Over seven
years later, the state postconviction court vacated her convic-
tion after Detective Dennis Chapman, the state’s fingerprint
expert, recanted his trial testimony. He conceded that he mis-
takenly had identified a latent fingerprint found at the crime
2 No. 16-1621 scene as belonging to Ms. Canen. The misidentification oc-
curred because Detective Chapman only was trained to com-
pare “known prints” (i.e., digital, ink, or powder fingerprint
exemplars), not “latent prints” (i.e., invisible, unknown fin-
gerprints found at a crime scene), and thus lacked the neces-
sary qualifications to identify the latent print removed from
the crime scene. At no time had he disclosed his lack of train-
ing to any party in the underlying state criminal proceeding.
Following her release, Ms. Canen brought this action
1
against Detective Chapman under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. She
claimed that he had withheld his lack of qualification to per-
form latent fingerprint analysis and therefore had violated
Brady v. Maryland,
1 The district court’s jurisdiction was premised on 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1343(a)(3). 2 Our jurisdiction is premised on 28 U.S.C. § 1291. No. 16-1621 3
I BACKGROUND A. On November 28, 2002, Helen Sailor was strangled to death in her apartment. At the time, she was a resident of the Waterfall Highrise Apartments in Elkhart, Indiana, which provided housing for low-income elderly people and adults with disabilities. Lana Canen and Andrew Royer, both recip- ients of Social Security disability benefits, were also residents. During the murder investigation, the Elkhart City Police Department (“ECPD”) found fingerprints on a number of items in Sailor’s apartment, including a plastic container used to hold her medication. The ECPD sent these lifts, along with fingerprint samples from various suspects, to Detective Chap- man of the Elkhart County Sheriff’s Department for analysis because they knew that the Indiana State Police Laboratory would have required substantially more time to do the anal- ysis. Detective Chapman conc