SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(SC) 1314

1996(7) Supreme 6
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
K. Ramaswamy and G.B. Pattanaik, JJ.
Smt. Sawarni -Appellant
versus
Smt. Inder Kaur & Ors. -Respondents
Civil Appeal No. 10987 of 1996
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 6956 of 1995)
Decided on 23-8-1996
Counsel for the Parties :
For the Appellant : A.S. Sohal and Sanjeev Malhotra, Advocates.
For the Respondents : Seeraj Bagga, Ms. S. Bagga and Ms. Tanuj Bagga, C.S. Ashri, Advocates.

Important Points

IMPORTANT POINT
Mutation of a property in the revenue record does not create or extinguish title nor has it any presumptive value on title.

Subject

Property Law - Title and Possession

Act Referred

Headnote

DECLARATION SUIT OF TITLE AND POSSESSION-Plaintiff-appellant succeeded to property owned by her deceased father-Defendant No. 5 claiming herself to be daughter of plaintiff s father sold the land to defendant No. 1 to 4-Trial Judge recorded findings that defendant No. 5 was not the daughter of plaintiff s father and sale deed executed by her did not convey any title-Lower appellate Court without focusing attention to weightly reasons given by trial Court reversed the decree-Lower appellate Court was not justified in not considering material evidence as well as reasons recorded by trial Court-It did not come to positive finding that defendant No. 5 was daughter of plaintiff s father-Mutation of property in revenue record in name of defendant No. 5 could not be said conveying title-It failed to consider that plaintiff had obtained succession certificate also-Judgment and decree of lower appellate Court and confirmed by High Court are liable to be set aside and that of trial Court liable to be confirmed. (Para 6)

       

Judgement Key Points
  • Mutation of property in the revenue record does not create or extinguish title nor does it have any presumptive value of title; it only authorises the payment of land revenue. [1000011720005]
  • A lower appellate court must properly consider the material evidence and weighty reasons given by the trial court; failure to focus on or discuss such evidence renders the judgment unsustainable. [1000011720005]
  • A lower appellate court cannot reverse a trial court's decree without setting aside key findings or arriving at positive contrary findings on disputed issues of fact. [1000011720005]
  • A plaintiff succeeding to property as a co-heir is entitled to file a suit for declaration of title and possession claiming her share as well as the share of other co-heirs who support her claim or are untraceable. [1000011720005]
  • A succession certificate issued under the Indian Succession Act establishing legal heirs cannot be ignored and rights flowing from it are relevant; it cannot be annulled without following procedure under the Act. [1000011720005]
  • A will executed by a widow devising her estate to specific

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • civil law
    • property law
      • title and possession (Para 3, 6, 7)
      • revenue records (Para 4, 6)
    • succession law
      • heirship (Para 3, 4, 6)
      • wills and succession certificates (Para 3, 4, 6)
  • practice and procedure
    • appellate jurisdiction (Para 2, 5, 6, 7)

Table of Contents

1. Suit for declaration of title and possession — Dispute over legal heirship and validity of sale deed based on contested paternity and maternity. (Para 3 )

2. Whether mutation in revenue records conveys title to sell property — Validity of a Will and succession certificate in establishing heirship. (Para 4 , 5 )

3. Mutation in revenue records does not create or extinguish title — Failure to consider oral evidence and valid succession certificates vitiates findings on heirship. (Para 6 )

4. Mutation of property in revenue records does not convey title nor has it any presumptive value on title; it only enables payment of land revenue. (Para 6 )

5. Appeal allowed — Judgments of High Court and lower appellate court set aside — Trial court's decree for possession and title confirmed. (Para 7 )

6. Does mutation in revenue records establish ownership or title to a property?

No. Mutation of a property in the revenue record does not create or extinguish title, nor does it have any presumptive value on title. Its purpose is solely to enable the person in whose favor the mutation is ordered to pay the land revenue. (Para 6 )

7. What is the legal effect of a succession certificate issued by a civil court?

A succession certificate issued by a civil court under the Indian Succession Act establishes rights that cannot be ignored by the court unless the certificate has been annulled on available legal grounds. (Para 6 )

8. Can a lower appellate court reverse a trial court's finding of fact without examining the material evidence?

No. A lower appellate court is not justified in reversing a trial court's positive conclusion on a factual issue without focusing on the reasons advanced by the trial court or examining the material evidence on record. (Para 6 )

JUDGMENT

Pattanaik, J.-Leave granted.

2. This appeal by special leave is by the plaintiff against the judgment and decree of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in Regular Second Appeal No. 1253 of 1994 dismissing the second appeal in limine, thereby confirming the judgment and decree of the Additional District Judge in Case No. 66 of 1986.

3. The plaintiff filed the suit for declaration of title and possession over the disputed land. It was alleged in the plaint that one Gurbax Singh was the admitted owner of the land in question and he died leaving behind his widow Gurdip Kaur and daughters Swarni, the plaintiff, and Roori @ Kirpal Kaur. Said Gurbax Singh purchased the land in question form one Dhara Singh under a registered sale deed dated 5th September, 1958. Widow Gurdip Kaur died on 14th April, 1968 and on her death plaintiff and Roori succeeded to the disputed land in question. Gurdip Kaur also had executed a Will on 29th February, 1968 in favour of her two daughters the plaintiff and Roori. Plaintiff and Roori had obtained a succession certificate claiming to be the legal heirs of Gurdip Kaur from the Civil Court on 4th April, 1975. Said Roori was not heard of and did not claim any interest in the disputed property, but defendant Nos. 8 and 9 are the sons of said Roori and defendant No. 7 is her husband and, therefore, in the property of Gurbax Singh, plaintiff as well defendant Nos. 7 to 9 are the successors in interest and are entitled to share half and half. It was also alleged that defendant Nos. 5 and 6 without having any interest in the property forcibly occupied a portion of the disputed property taking advantage of the absence of plaintiff from the suit village and, therefore, the plaintiff filed the suit for the relief as already stated. It was also averred in the plaint that defendant No. 1 claimed to have purchased the property from defendant No. 5 - Inder Kaur and said defendant No. 5 claiming herself to be one of the daughters of Gurbax Singh had executed the sale deed in question. Plaintiff contended that defendant No. 5 is the daughter of Harnam Singh brother of Gurbax Singh and not daughter of Gurbax Singh as alleged and, therefore, she had no title to the property to pass on in favour of defendant No. 1 under the registered sale deed in question.

4. Defendant Nos. 5 and 6 in their written statement though admitted plaintiff to be one of the daughters of Gurbax Singh, but pleaded that the other daughter of Gurbax Singh is Inder Kaur, the defendant No. 5 and Roori @ Kirpal Kaur was not the daughter of Gurbax Singh. The execution of Will by Gurdip Kaur, widow of Gurbax Singh was also denied and it was averred that the said Will is a forged and fictitious document. The defendants also denied the factum of obtaining a succession certificate by the plaintiff and said Roori. It was thus contended that since Inder Kaur had half share in the disputed property being daughter of Gurbax Singh, she executed the sale deed in favour of defendant Nos. 1 to 4 and defendant No. 6 on receipt of valuable consideration. Thus, the possession of defendant Nos. 5 and 6 or defendant Nos. 1 to 4 is that of a true owner and they cannot be held to be trespassers. Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 filed a separate written statement and took the same stand as that of defendant Nos. 5 and 6. It was also averred in the written statement that the land in question had been mutated in favour of plaintiff and Inder Kaur which establishes the rightful ownership of defendant No. 5. Defendant Nos. 7 to 9 filed a written statement admitting the plaintiff s claim. On these pleadings the learned trial Judge framed as many as 8 issues and recorded the following findings :

(i) Gurbax Singh was the owner of the disputed property.

(ii) Roori @ Kirpal Kaur was the other daughter of Gurbax Singh apart from plaintiff and Inder Kaur, defendant No. 5 was not his daughter.














1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top