SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2018 MarsdenLR 1327

HIGH COURT MALAYA KUALA LUMPUR
AHMAD IBRAHIM & ORS – Appellant
Versus
ABU BAKAR IBRAHIM & ANOR – Respondent
[Civil Suit No: 22NCVC-142-03/2014]



Important Points

The court emphasizes the discretion under the Probate and Administration Act 1959 in appointing estate administrators, highlighting the importance of evidence in determining trust and ownership issues.

Subject

Probate - Administration of Estates

Act Referred

Headnote

This case deals with the Plaintiffs' claims for the grant of Letters of Administration for the Deceased's estate. The Court dismisses the application for the removal of the First Defendant as trustee of certain shares and validates a transfer of shares under the Probate and Administration Act 1959. The issues revolve around the fitness of the parties for administration and the validity of property claims. The Court finds a lack of evidence supporting the objections to the First Defendant's role and affirms his ownership of the contested shares.

Result: The Court orders the appointment of the Plaintiffs and the First Defendant as co-administrators.

Petitioner Advocates:Suzilawati Ismail,Wan Zafran Pawancheek ,Respondent Advocate: Baljit Singh,Abd Shukor Ahmad,Nor Shahdah Saari

Table of Content
1. issues to be tried as formulated by the court. (Para 19 , 20)
2. court findings regarding asset ownership and claims. (Para 21 , 22 , 23)
3. final ruling by the court on administration. (Para 24 , 25 , 26)
4. court's directives for the co-administration. (Para 27 , 28 , 29)
Decision Of The Court

[19] Having heard the evidence given by all the witnesses from the Plaintiffs and the Defendants, and after considering the submissions of the parties, with regard to the Plaintiffs' claims against the 1st Defendant for the 899 shares in the 2nd Defendant, the Court finds that on the balance of probabilities, the Plaintiffs have failed to prove that the 899,999 shares of the 2nd Defendant formed part of the Deceased's Estate.

[20] Therefore, the Plaintiffs' claims against the 1st Defendant with regard to the 899 shares in the 2nd Defendant in para 42 sub-paragraphs (2), (3), (4) and (5) of the Plaintiffs' SOC are dismissed. Consequently, the Court make no order with regard to the 1st Defendant's counter claim in para 56(f) of his Amended SOD and Counter Claim as the Court finds that the said shares has not been listed as part of the Deceased's Estate in the Sijil Faraid issued by the Syariah High Court of the Federal Territories, Kuala Lumpur.

[21] The the 899,999 shares in the 2nd Defendant therefore, is to remain in the 1st Defendant's name as the true owner of the said shares as the Court finds that the said shares do not form part of the Deceased's Estate pursuant to the Sijil Faraid issued by the Syariah High Court (refer Exh D9 at pp 51-53 of Bundle K -amended Order/Sijil Faraid dated 15 December 2014 issued by the Syariah High Court of the Federal Territories, Kuala Lumpur).

[22] The Court dismisses the Plaintiffs' claim in para 42 sub-paragraph 5 of the Plaintiffs' SOC as the Court finds that both the Deceased's Transfer and Control letter dated 23 March 2010 (refer Exh D60) and the Deceased's Statutory Declaration dated 23 March 2010 (refer Exh D68) do not create any Trust Deed. The sale and transfer of the 899,999 shares in the 2nd Defendant to the 1st Defendant is valid as the sale and transfer of the said shares was done and completed when the Deceased is still alive and, the 899,999 shares is also not listed in the Sijil Faraid as part of the Deceased's Estate.

[23] The Plaintiffs' claims in para 42 sub-paragraphs (6), (7), (8) and (9) of the Plaintiffs' SOC are also dismissed. From the Sijil Faraid applied by the 3rd Plaintiff in Syariah High Court, the Order granted by the Syariah High Court has already listed all the Assets and Liabilities in the Deceased's Estate and also the names of all the beneficiaries of the Deceased.

[24] With regard to the 1st Defendant's counter claim in para 56(e) of his SOD and Counter Claim, the Court finds that on the balance of probabilities, the 1st Defendant has failed to prove his case against the Plaintiffs for a declaration that the land held under title 18437 lot 1674, Mukim Hulu Kelang, Daerah Kuala Lumpur, Negeri Selangor Darul Ehsan is part of the Deceased Estate. Therefore, the 1st Defendant's claim in para 56 (f) is dismissed based on the following reasons:-

(a) the land title (refer Exh P9 at pp 1138-1140 of Bundle I) shows the ownership of the said land is under the names of "Ahmad Bin Ibrahim ½ bhgn" ie the 1st Plaintiff and "Sinta Widjaja, ½ bhgn."

(b) Sale and Purchase Agreement dated 29 April 2008 (refer Exh P8 at pp 1107-1121 of Bundle I) between "Tibra Sdn Bhd" as Vendor and, "Ahmad Bin Ibrahim" ie the 1st Plaintiff and "Sinta Widjaja (F)" as the Purchasers was done and completed before the demise of the Deceased.

(c) The Amended Order/Sijil Faraid dated 15 December 2014 (refer Exh D9) also has not included the said land as part of the Deceased's Estate.

(d) The 1st Defendant did not apply to include the said land as part of the Deceased's Estate when he applied to amend the Syariah High Court Order dated 8 May 2014 (refer Exh P14 - Syariah High Court Federal Territ

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top