SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 MarsdenLR 634

HIGH COURT MALAYA, KUALA LUMPUR
KAM SOH KEH KAN KOK PANG – Appellant
Versus
CHAN KOK LEONG & 2 ORS – Respondent
[Petition No. S5-31-359-93]



JUDGMENT

James Foong J:

Chong Swee Lin @ Chong Swee Leng (the deceased) died on 21 February 1993 as a result of a motor accident in Genting Highlands. On 12 November 1993, the petitioner claiming himself to be the lawful husband of the deceased filed a petition for letters of administration to the deceased estate. A caveat was posted by one Chan Kok Leong (the respondent) against this petition, and after a warning was issued the respondent entered appearance. By this act, this petition is considered as contested under O. 71 r. 37 (14) of the Rules of High (RHC) . This case was duly referred to the Judge of the High Court who then ordered it to be disposed of summarily under the powers granted to him under O. 71 r. 38(1) RHC .

In accordance with O. 71 r. 38(2) RHC this matter was heard in open Court. Besides affidavits being referred to, makers of these affidavits were also crossexamined. Included during this hearing with the consent of all parties, were several other witnesses who tendered oral evidence.

From the evidence adduced, the respondent together with his sisters, Chan Suit Foong and Elizabeth Chang Loong Yoke (who were later added in as the 2nd and 3rd respondents respectively) are children of the deceased. They claim that the petitioner was never the lawful husband of the deceased and as such should not be entitled to be the administrator of the estate of the deceased; they being the lawful children should be made administrators.

In determining who will be a suitable administrator of a deceased estate, s. 30 of the Probate and Administration Act 1950 provides as follows;

In granting administration the Court shall have regard to the rights of all persons interested in the estate of the deceased person or in the proceeds of sale thereof, and, in particular, administration with the will annexed may be granted to a devisee or legatee; and in regard to land settled previously to the death of the deceased, and not by his will, administration may be granted to the trustees of the settlement; and any such administration may be limited in any way the Court thinks fit:

Provided that, where the deceased died wholly intestate as to his estate, administration shall, if application is made for the purpose, be granted to some one or more of the persons interested in the residuary estate of the deceased, unless by reason of the insolvency of the estate, or other special circumstances the Court thinks it expedient to grant administration to some other person.

By the above provision, inevitably for the purpose of this case, the person most suitable to be the administrator would be the benefactor of the deceased estate. If the petitioner is the lawful husband, it is obvious that under the Distribution Act of 1958 he will be the sole beneficiary of the deceased estate, since the deceased died intestate. Being the sole beneficiary he should be the appropriate person to be appointed administrator. On the other hand, if the petitioner is not the lawful husband then the respondents should be the administrators as they are persons interested in the residuary estate of the deceased, being once again beneficiaries. There is no contest on the relationship of the respondents with the deceased, for as from the evidence so far adduced the petitioner has admitted that they are the deceased children. Therefore, the true issue of this whole case centers upon whether the petitioner was the lawful husband of the deceased.

The petitioner testified that he first met the deceased on Christmas Eve of 1976 at a night club where she was a singer. They got married on 2 January 1981 by way of a Chinese customary marriage ceremony. This involved the petitioner and the deceased hosting a dinner for 3 male friends of the petitioner and two female friends of the deceased at a Chinese restaurant in Jalan Peel, Kuala Lumpur. At this dinner, the petitioner alleged that he announced to the gathering that he and the deceased were getting married. A Chinese marriage certifica

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top