2010 MarsdenLR 2407
HIGH COURT MALAYA KUALA LUMPUR
IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF TAN SRI DATUK SYED KECHICK @ SYED BAKAR SYED MOHAMED (DECEASED)
[Petition For Letters Of Administration No: S31-668-2009]
Important Points
Subject
Probate Law - Letters of Administration
Act Referred
Headnote
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. overview of estate and parties involved. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6) |
| 2. considerations of administration rights and obligations. (Para 10 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 19 , 22 , 26 , 27 , 29 , 37 , 39 , 45 , 49) |
| 3. rights of beneficiaries and contesting interests. (Para 11 , 12 , 28) |
| 4. principles regarding majority interest and no forced administration. (Para 20 , 30 , 38 , 40 , 44) |
| 5. final order and call for reconciliation. (Para 61 , 62 , 63 , 64) |
Lee Swee Seng JC:
Prologue
[1] Some died poor. Some died rich. The fact remains that we all have to leave everything behind when we should die one day. Some would leave behind a legacy of faith, hope and love; others a legacy of wealth.
[2] Sometimes a sad thing happens: children, bickering and battling over who should administer the estate of the deceased father or spouse, what constitutes the asset of the deceased. Such is the scenario that has come before the court for decision.
The Parties
[3] This is an application for grant of letters of administration in respect of the estate of the late Tan Sri Datuk Syed Kechik @ Syed Bakar bin Syed Mohamed who passed away on 10 April 2009.
[4] The petitioners are the deceased lawful widow, Puan Sri Sofia Moo ('the first petitioner') and his two daughters, Puan Sharifah Munirah ('the second petitioner') and Puan Sri Sharifah Zarah ('the third petitioner').
[5] The beneficiaries of the estate of the deceased are the petitioners as well as a son through a previous marriage, which had been dissolved, by the name of Syed Gamal bin Syed Kechik ('the caveator').
[6] Now the parties to the dispute are as follows: the first petitioner as the lawful widow of the late Tan Sri Datuk Syed Kechik @ Syed Bakar bin Syed Mohamed and the second and third petitioners, as the daughters of the deceased on the one hand and on the other hand the caveator, as the son of the deceased, ie 'the son', as in the surviving son from a previous marriage of the deceased to the first wife. The petitioners had filed a petition for the grant of letters of administration, annexing a list of assets to be administered. the caveator had filled a caveat under the Rules of the High court 1980 ('RHC'), such that no grant of administration can be made without notice to him.
Problem
[7] The caveator had filed a summons in chambers in court encl 7, and upon realising (as advised by his solicitors) that he should actually go under O 72 of the RHC, he filed a fresh writ under Writ No S-22-443 of 2010.
[8] There was no warning filed by the petitioners for reasons given that the petitioners are not disputing that the caveator has an interest as a beneficiary of the estate of the deceased father.
[9] In the last hearing before the court, the court has recorded the following words:
... that parties agree that the court would decide on just that sole question on who are to be administrators of the estate of the deceased here, the deceased being Tan Sri Syed Kechik @ Syed Bakar bin Syed Mohammad.
Principles
[10] The court has considered the arguments of both parties, and the court must commend both counsel for the in depth research that they have done into this subject.
Rights Of The Petitioners And Caveator To Be Administrators Of The Deceased Estate
[11] Both parties are in agreement that both the petitioners and the caveator have a right to administration of the estate quest are all beneficiaries of the deceased estate. The petitioners' counsel submitted that in the circumstances of the case the court should exercise its discretion not to allow the caveator to be a co-administrator of the estate.
[12] The third petitioner gave evidence via affidavit as agreed by both the parties with respect to how evidence is to be adduced with respect to assisting the court to determine the single issue as to who the grant of administration to the estate should be given. Her evidence on why the caveator should be excluded from administration can be summarised as follows:
(a) The caveator was not able to disti