2011 MarsdenLR 2653
COURT OF APPEAL PUTRAJAYA
SRI SOFIAH MOO & ORS – Appellant
Versus
SYED GAMAL SYED KECHIK AL-BUKHARY – Respondent
[Civil Appeal No: W-02-2338-2010]
Important Points
Subject
Probate Law - Administration of Estates
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Discretionary powers - The court has the discretion to appoint administrators and must consider the rights of all persons interested in the estate - Allegations of animosity and business failure do not justify exclusion from administration. (Paras 20-24)
Facts of the case:
The deceased died in 2009; petitioners, including his widow and daughters, filed for administration, excluding the deceased's son, the caveator, who has a significant share. The caveator filed a caveat and sought appointment as joint administrator.
Findings of Court:
The court confirmed that the caveator is entitled to be appointed joint administrator along with the petitioners, emphasizing the need for considering all interested parties.
Issues: Whether the court correctly appointed the caveator despite his withdrawal of a prior application and the claims of interpersonal issues.
Ratio Decidendi: The court determined that the caveator's withdrawal of application does not negate his right to be appointed administrator, and animosity cannot justify the exclusion.
Result: Appeal dismissed with costs.
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. background of the estate administration dispute. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5) |
| 2. identification of key issues in the appeal. (Para 6 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13) |
| 3. procedure for caveators in probate actions. (Para 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18) |
| 4. discretion of courts in estate administration. (Para 19 , 20 , 21) |
| 5. analysis of the petitioners' arguments. (Para 22 , 23 , 24) |
| 6. court's dismissal of the appeal with costs. (Para 25) |
Appeal
[1] The three appellants ("the petitioners") brought this appeal against the decision of the Kuala Lumpur High Court in allowing the appointment of the respondent ("the caveator") as joint administrator (in addition to the petitioners as the other administrators) of the estate of the late Tan Sri Syed Kechik Al-Bukhary ("the deceased").
Factual Background
[2] The deceased died on 10 April 2009.
[3] On 23 September 2009, the deceased's widow Puan Sri Sofiah Moo @ Moo Nyok Yin (the 1st petitioner) and their two daughters, Sharifah Munira and Puan Sri Sharifah Zarah (the 2nd and 3rd petitioners respectively) filed a petition for letters of administration ("the petition") seeking to be appointed as the administrators of the deceased's estate.
[4] The deceased had a son, Syed Gamal ("the caveator") from a previously-dissolved marriage. In relation to the estate, he is the single biggest beneficiary in terms of proportion and percentage i.e 14/32 share (43.75%) according to the Sijil Faraid, while the petitioners jointly have the balance thereof ie, 18/32 share. However, in the petition, the petitioners did not include the caveator as joint administrator.
[5] On 14 April 2010, the caveator filed a caveat pursuant to O. 71 r. 37(1) of the Rules of the High 1980 ("the caveat") to challenge the petition and sought an order, inter alia , that he be appointed as joint administrator of the estate as well. (For brevity and convenience, a reference hereinafter to an order and a rule is a reference to that order and rule in the Rules of the High 1980).
[6] The notes of proceedings of the learned judicial commissioner ("the JC") recorded the following words:
... That parties agree that the Court would decide on just that sole question on who are to be administrators of the estate of the Deceased here, the Deceased being Tan Sri Syed Kechik @ Syed Bakar bin Syed Mohammad.
[7] The JC took the position that the sole question for determination by him was whether (in addition to the petitioners as the other administrators) the caveator should be appointed as joint administrator of the estate. The JC gave the answer in the affirmative and made an order to that effect.
[8] This is the dissatisfied petitioners' appeal against the JC's decision.
[9] We now give our grounds for dismissing the petitioners' appeal.
Appointment Of Caveator As Joint Administrator
[10] Petitioners' learned counsel Dato' Vijay Kumar Natarajan (assisted by Ms Siti Salwa) complained that the JC had erred in appointing the caveator as joint administrator in that the appointment has been forced upon the petitioners after the caveator had withdrawn his application to intervene in the High Court ("application to intervene") with no liberty to file afresh. The petitioners added that there was animosity between the petitioners and the caveator. The petitioners also alleged that the caveator was a failed businessman.
[11] For the caveator, Mr Pawancheek Merican and Ms Suzilawati Ismail submitted that having regard to the entry of the caveat by the caveator, the JC had correctly exercised his discretion in appointing the caveator as joint administrator under s. 30 of the Probate and Administration Act 1959 read with s. 33 of the same Act. (A reference hereinafter to a section is a reference to that section in the ).
[12] In view of the submissions presented for the respective parties herein and the JC's decision, the question which we have to answer in the instant appeal is:
Upon a true construction of s. 30 read with s. 33, and given the above factual