The Goods and Services Tax Appellate Tribunal (GSTAT) in Hyderabad has delivered a significant ruling concerning the eligibility of businesses to claim accumulated input tax credit (ITC) under an inverted duty structure. In a decision dated 27 October, the tribunal set aside the rejection of a refund claim filed by Kedia Agro, holding that an executive circular issued by the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) cannot be applied retrospectively to deny rights that had already accrued to an assessee. This decision brings much-needed relief to manufacturers facing similar administrative barriers when seeking refunds for tax periods predating specific regulatory changes.

The dispute centered on an ITC refund claim worth ₹61.47 lakh, which the tax department had refused to process due to the timing of the application. The tribunal, presided over by Judicial Member Sushil Kumar Sharma and Technical Member Duvvuri Krishna Srinivas, emphasized that the right to claim ITC is a substantive entitlement that vests with a taxpayer at the time of purchase, rather than at the moment of filing a formal claim.

Kedia Agro, a company involved in the manufacture and supply of edible oils, had faced a systemic accumulation of unutilised ITC because the GST rates on its raw material inputs were higher than the rates applicable to its final outward supplies. The company’s refund claim pertained to the period between May 2020 and March 2021. According to the facts presented, Kedia Agro initially filed a refund application for ₹65.04 lakh on 18 June 2022. Subsequently, for administrative reasons, the company withdrew this application and submitted a revised, fresh claim for ₹61,47,671 on 25 March 2023.

The Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax, Mehdipatnam GST Division, rejected this fresh application on 23 May 2023. The tax authority relied heavily on Notification No. 09/2022-Central Tax (Rate), which took effect on 18 July 2022, and the subsequent CBIC Circular No. 181/13/2022-GST issued on 10 November 2022. The department contended that because the fresh application was filed after the notification came into force, the restriction on refunds for specific goods under Chapters 15 and 27 of the GST regime was applicable. The tax authorities argued that the withdrawal of the initial application resulted in a loss of the previous entitlement, forcing the company to adhere to the revised legal landscape.

Challenging Administrative Overreach

The tribunal’s ruling highlights the tension between substantive statutory rights and the restrictive nature of administrative circulars. During the proceedings, the counsel for the appellant argued that the ITC had accrued to the company long before the new restrictions were enacted. They maintained that the date of filing the refund application—provided it remains within the limitation period prescribed by Section 54 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017—should not act as a pivot for denying the eligibility of a claim related to an earlier period.

In its order, the GSTAT panel observed: “ITC is a right accrues to the assessee on the date when dutiable goods / services were bought in the course of furtherance of business. Such a right can't be curtailed by the interpreting an executive circular by giving it retrospective effect, without any statutory / legal backings.”

The tribunal’s reasoning aligns with the broader judicial trend in various High Courts, which have consistently struck down similar attempts by the revenue authorities to utilize circulars to limit the scope of tax benefits. By characterizing the right to ITC as something that vests upon the procurement of goods, the tribunal effectively signaled that executive departments cannot retroactively alter the legal status of an input tax credit through administrative interpretations. The bench underscored that the notification in question could not be used to invalidate a refund claim for a period where the company’s transactions were fully compliant with the law as it existed at the time of the business activities.

Remanded for Fresh Scrutiny

The decision by the Hyderabad bench of the GSTAT has direct consequences for the ongoing litigation surrounding Kedia Agro’s claim. By setting aside the orders of the original adjudicating authority and the subsequent first appellate authority, the tribunal has restored the status of the company’s refund application. The matter has now been remanded back to the original adjudicating authority, with clear instructions to reconsider the claim in accordance with the law.

Crucially, the tribunal also directed the authority to examine the company’s claim for interest on the delayed refund. This serves as a significant secondary win for the taxpayer, as it reinforces the principle that businesses should not be penalized for delays caused by the authorities' erroneous interpretation of eligibility rules. For the wider legal and corporate community, this ruling serves as a reminder that the substantive provisions of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act take precedence over the procedural constraints imposed by executive circulars.

As the matter returns to the assistant commissioner’s desk, the focus will now shift toward the administrative processing of the ₹61.47 lakh claim. The adjudicating authority is expected to conduct a comprehensive review, looking beyond the date of filing to ensure the underlying transaction-level compliance is verified. For tax practitioners, this ruling serves as a critical precedent in challenging the administrative denial of refunds where the state has attempted to use circulars to impose time-based restrictions that are not explicitly found in the primary legislation. The resolution of this case will likely influence how future refund applications are evaluated by GST authorities, particularly where taxpayers were forced to navigate overlapping regulatory transitions. The company now awaits a final determination on its interest entitlement, marking the next phase in this protracted tax dispute.