The , has affirmed the entitlement of Special Economic Zone (SEZ) units to claim refunds of distributed by . The decision settles a long-standing dispute between the , and , confirming that raised by the revenue authorities did not negate the of an SEZ unit to recover tax-paid credit that remains unutilized in its .
The tribunal’s bench, comprising Judicial Member Pramod Kumar Rai and Technical Member Kishori Lal, dismissed eight distinct appeals filed by the Revenue department. These appeals contested the relief granted to Reliance Industries by the regarding refund claims for various tax periods. The core of the dispute revolved around whether an SEZ unit, as the recipient of services rather than the original supplier, could maintain a for ITC distributed to it through an ISD mechanism.
Strengthening the Rights of SEZ Units
The Revenue had challenged the refund orders, arguing that under , a in respect of supplies to an SEZ unit must be filed by the supplier. The department maintained that the SEZ unit, as a receiver, was not eligible to initiate such proceedings. Furthermore, the Revenue contended that credit distributed by an ISD should not be equated with tax paid on supplies made directly by a registered person to an SEZ unit, thus attempting to restrict the applicability of refund provisions.
In dismissing the department's position, the tribunal conducted an extensive review of judicial precedents, including findings from the and the . The tribunal emphasized that the law requires a that favors the claimant when the statutory mechanisms provided are otherwise unworkable for the specific entity. The bench noted that since it was practically impossible for an ISD-distributing supplier to file a refund claim for credit already passed on, the burden must logically fall upon the SEZ unit to seek the refund.
Addressing the legislative intent, the tribunal highlighted that the "
" is a vital tool for ensuring that provisions remain workable. As the tribunal noted in its order:
"The law relating to the refund to SEZ unit provided under
read with rule 89 of the CGST Rules, as interpreted by the Gujarat and Madras High Courts clearly provide that since it is not possible for a supplier of goods and services to file a
to claim the refund of the input tax credit distributed by ISD, the instance of the department that the petitioner is not entitled to seek the refund of the ITC paid in connection with goods or services supplied to SEZ unit is not tenable."
Rejection of Revenue’s Procedural Objections
The tribunal also scrutinized the Revenue’s reliance on several
circulars, which the department had cited to argue that the refund claims were procedurally flawed. The tribunal concluded that these circulars were primarily issued to address the initial non-availability of a digital refund module on the common portal and did not fundamentally restrict the substantive rights of taxpayers. The bench remarked:
"Both circulars prescribed the procedure for processing the refund claims manually due to the non-availability of the refund module on the common portal and did not bring any substantial change in the law relating to right of refund to SEZ units."
Furthermore, the tribunal addressed the Revenue's attempt to distinguish the current case from previous rulings by citing ongoing challenges before the . The Revenue had argued that the ’s judgment in the Britannia Industries case was currently . However, the tribunal rejected this argument, noting that the Revenue failed to produce any stay order. It reiterated that until a higher court grants a stay, the existing judicial interpretations remain binding upon subordinate authorities. The tribunal also reinforced this by referencing supplementary decisions from the , which echoed the principle that SEZ units cannot be denied refunds simply based on their status as recipients.
The tribunal's ruling underscored the principle that tax law should facilitate the ease of doing business rather than create insurmountable procedural barriers. By allowing the refund, the bench ensured that the "" status of supplies to SEZ units—a cornerstone of the GST regime intended to bolster export competitiveness—was fully realized in practice.
The final order pronounced by the tribunal on , confirmed that all eight appeals filed by the Revenue were meritless. The tribunal upheld the earlier orders passed by the , thereby directing the department to honor the refund claims for the unutilized ITC. This decision provides significant relief to large-scale industrial players operating within SEZ frameworks, solidifying the legal framework for recovering tax credits that might otherwise remain indefinitely trapped in electronic ledgers due to technical administrative bottlenecks. The department is now expected to process the refund claims, bringing the long-drawn-out litigation to a close.
ITC refund - SEZ units