```html
NCLT Hyderabad Bench Orders Fresh Public Announcement in
Vibha
Agro Tech CIRP, Citing Flawed Notice
Hyderabad, February 21, 2025
– The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) Hyderabad Bench - I has halted the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) of M/s.
Background of the Case
The CIRP against
Aggrieved by the alleged lack of proper notice, several applicants, primarily seed organizers and farmers represented by All India Kisan Sabha, approached the NCLT. They argued that
Arguments Presented
Applicants' Counsel
contended that the IRP failed to comply with Regulation 6 of the CIRP Regulations by not publishing the public announcement in locations where
Respondent's Counsel (Resolution Professional & SBI)
countered that Regulation 6(2)(b)(i) mandates publication in other locations only if, in the IRP's opinion, the Corporate Debtor conducts
material
business operations there. They argued that the regulation is directory, not mandatory, and that the initial publication in Hyderabad was sufficient. They further claimed that some applicants were commercial entities and should have been aware of the CIRP, and that claims from aggregators in other states were already considered. They also referenced a prior NCLAT judgment,
NCLT's Analysis and Findings
The Tribunal acknowledged the locus standi of Applicant Nos. 2 to 8, the seed organizers, based on their contractual agreements and delivery challans with
On the crucial issue of public announcement, the NCLT observed:
> "On perusal of Regulation 6 (supra), we find that IRP is also required to publish the notice at other location where in the opinion of the interim resolution professional, the corporate debtor conducts material business operations. The registered office of the Corporate Debtor is located at Somajiguda, Hyderabad – 500082. Accordingly, on 14.06.2023, the IRP of Corporate Debtor issued the public announcement in compliance of Regulation 6 of IBBI (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016. The said Public Announcement was issued in Economic Times – English Language (Hyderabad Edition) and Nava Telangana – Telugu Language (Hyderabad Edition) calling for submission of claims."
However, the bench disagreed with the IRP's opinion that publication only in Hyderabad was sufficient. It emphasized the importance of the Corporate Debtor's factories and processing plants as key business locations:
> "…factories/processing plants of the Corporate Debtor which form the core/central business units for any corporation/company cannot be compared with the suppliers. Therefore, we are not persuaded to accept that the opinion/decision of IRP to publish notice only at Hyderabad where registered office of the Corporate Debtor is situated as 'just and equitable'."
Furthermore, the NCLT examined the circulation of the Hyderabad newspapers used for publication and found them to be categorized as "Small" circulation. Citing the Supreme Court’s judgment in Special Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition CMDA vs J. Sivaprakasam and Ors. , the Tribunal underscored the importance of "reasonably wide circulation" to ensure adequate notice to affected parties.
Decision and Implications
Based on these findings, the NCLT concluded that the initial public announcement was deficient and vitiated the subsequent CIRP process. The Tribunal ordered:
-
Fresh Public Announcement:
The Resolution Professional is directed to issue a fresh public announcement in Form-A in newspapers with wide circulation at the registered office, principal office, and factories/processing plants of
Vibha Agro Tech, within three days. - Re-initiated CIRP: The CIRP process is to be re-conducted expeditiously, within a maximum period of 180 days from the fresh announcement.
- Resolution Plan Infructuous: The Resolution Plan approved by the Committee of Creditors (CoC) is deemed infructuous.
- Refund to Resolution Applicant: The Resolution Professional is directed to return deposits made by M/s. Vasavi Realty Private Limited, the previously proposed resolution applicant.
-
Consideration of Ex-Management Concerns:
The Resolution Professional and CoC are directed to consider concerns raised by the former management of
Vibha Agro Tech in other pending applications. - Cost Imposed: A cost of Rs. 25,000/- was imposed on Applicant No. 4 for misleading the tribunal regarding notice, despite having filed a claim earlier.
The order highlights the critical importance of proper and widespread public announcements in CIRP proceedings to ensure fair opportunity for all stakeholders, particularly operational creditors, to participate and file their claims, thereby upholding the principles of natural justice and maximizing value in the insolvency resolution process. ```