Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
In the complex landscape of governance, legal opinions from high-ranking officials like the Attorney General (AG) play a pivotal role. But what exactly is the result of an Attorney General opinion over the government? This question often arises in discussions about constitutional law, policy-making, and judicial oversight in India. While not legally binding, these opinions carry significant weight, guiding governmental actions especially on constitutional matters. This post delves into the nuances, drawing from judicial precedents and expert analyses to provide clarity.
The opinions of the Attorney General serve as a cornerstone for governmental decision-making. Courts have consistently recognized them as highly influential and authoritative. As noted, The opinion of the Attorney General of India is a very important consideration in the decision of the Government. Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740
Key points highlight this dynamic:- The AG's opinion is considered highly influential and authoritative, often guiding the Government’s actions Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740.- Courts acknowledge that the AG’s advice is given with responsibility and entitled to respect, though not binding Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740.- The Government generally acts upon the AG’s legal advice, particularly on constitutional issues His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru VS State of Kerala - 1973 0 Supreme(SC) 163.
This influence stems from the AG's role as the chief legal adviser to the government, ensuring actions align with constitutional and legal standards.
The AG acts as a constitutional and legal adviser, with courts emphasizing the need for objective and fair exercise of power. In one ruling, it was observed: The exercise has to be performed objectively and fairly, mindful of the fact that the majesty of law has to be upheld and the rule of law preserved... Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740
Furthermore, The opinion of the Attorney-General is a very important consideration in the decision of the Government. His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru VS State of Kerala - 1973 0 Supreme(SC) 163 This underscores how such advice reflects legal standing and constitutional validity, often followed due to the AG's expertise.
Judicial bodies have held that AG opinions are rendered responsibly. For instance, courts tend to rely on them for constitutional questions Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740. Even though non-binding, they form a significant factor in governmental processes His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru VS State of Kerala - 1973 0 Supreme(SC) 163.
AG opinions have shaped outcomes in diverse areas, illustrating their practical impact.
In a corruption case under the Prevention of Corruption Act, the CBI decided not to prosecute based on the AG and Solicitor General's opinion that there was insufficient material. This decision was annexed and upheld, showing deference to such advice Dhruva Prasad Ojha VS State of Jharkhand through the C. B. I. - 2018 Supreme(Jhk) 869.
Similarly, in matters of reservation benefits for Scheduled Castes/Tribes, the Ministry of Home Affairs consulted the AG, whose opinion dated 18.02.2013 guided policy on migration and entitlements, approved by the Minister Bir Singh VS Delhi Jal Board - 2018 Supreme(SC) 857. The Supreme Court reinforced that SC/ST status is state-specific, aligning with AG-guided interpretations Bir Singh VS Delhi Jal Board - 2018 Supreme(SC) 857.
In procurement tenders, a government undertaking sought the AG's opinion before negotiations, ensuring multi-layered decision-making to avoid arbitrariness Oil India Limited VS Drillmec S. P. A. - 2014 Supreme(Gau) 610. This highlights how AG input mitigates legal risks in commercial dealings.
Other contexts include criminal prosecutions, where the AG's wide powers ensure fairness over public opinion Sandresh Ravindra Karunanayake Vs. Hon. Attorney General and others - 2023 Supreme(SRI)(CA) 64, and even contempt proceedings, where the Supreme Court obtained the AG's view on an editorial Subramanian Swamy VS Arun Shourie - 2014 5 Supreme 513.
Despite their weight, AG opinions are advisory. The government retains discretion to accept or reject them. However:- Ignoring advice, especially on constitutional issues, invites judicial scrutiny for reasonableness His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru VS State of Kerala - 1973 0 Supreme(SC) 163.- Courts may question deviations, demanding justification Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740.
For example, in telecom service taxation disputes, the Law Ministry and AG opined that Interconnection Usage Charges (IUC) were not taxable, influencing policy until legislative changes Bsnl Pgmtd VS Commissioner Of Central Excise, Jaipur - 2017 Supreme(Raj) 2586. This shows opinions can guide but not override statutes.
To maximize the value of AG opinions:- Governments should accord due weight, particularly on legal and constitutional fronts.- Courts ought to view them as key in reviews of governmental actions.- Documentation is crucial for any departure, promoting transparency His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru VS State of Kerala - 1973 0 Supreme(SC) 163.
These steps foster accountability and uphold the rule of law.
The AG's role extends beyond advice to interventions in high-stakes areas like multi-state AG collaborations Andrew Teter vs Anne E. Lopez - 2025 Supreme(US)(ca9) 25 or historical cases in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka) LE MESURIER C.J.R. v. Hon. Mr. LAYARD C.P. ATTORNEY GENERAL OF CEYLON. In modern India, this influence ensures policies withstand judicial challenges, as seen in summoning accused under CrPC Section 319, where AG opinions factored into prosecutorial restraint Dhruva Prasad Ojha VS State of Jharkhand through the C. B. I. - 2018 Supreme(Jhk) 869.
While this overview draws from established precedents, legal outcomes can vary by context. This is general information and not specific legal advice; consult a qualified attorney for personalized guidance.
References1. Union Of India VS Sushil Kumar Modi - 1996 7 Supreme 740: Role and influence of AG opinion.2. His Holiness Kesavananda Bharati Sripadgalvaru VS State of Kerala - 1973 0 Supreme(SC) 163: Non-binding but significant status.3. Dhruva Prasad Ojha VS State of Jharkhand through the C. B. I. - 2018 Supreme(Jhk) 869: AG opinion in prosecution decisions.4. Bir Singh VS Delhi Jal Board - 2018 Supreme(SC) 857: AG guidance on reservations.5. Oil India Limited VS Drillmec S. P. A. - 2014 Supreme(Gau) 610: AG in tender processes.
#AttorneyGeneral, #LegalAdviceIndia, #GovtLaw
I do not think this result flows. ... As a result of section 4 (b) of the amending Ordinance conferring upon the Attorney-General all or any of the powers conferred by, to take the same section, namely, section 253, even in regard to a summary trial held by a Police Magistrate in respect of a non-summary offence, the Attorney-General ... In this country, however, the Attorney-General enjoys no such power of veto. In my opinion#HL_END....
Schokman, C.C., for the Attorney-General. November 21, 1928. GARVIN J.- The prosecution in this case was initiated with the sanction of the Attorney-General. ... Appeal-Order of discharge by Police Magistrate-Instructions of the Attorney-General-Criminal Procedure Code, s. 158. ... Section 158 enacts that when the Attorney-General " directs that the accused be discharged he shall be forthwith discharged." ... But Counsel for the appel....
On April 27, the Attorney General issued Opinion No. 23-1, an official opinion regarding the Attorney General’s statutory authority to enforce § 18-622. ... Labrador, Idaho Attorney General; Office of the Idaho Attorney General, Boise, Idaho; for Defendant- Appellant. ... OPINION W. ... The Opinion Letter was signed by the Attorney General#HL....
, and no impasse would then result. ... Attorney-General. ... The effect of the order issued to the Magistrate by the Attorney- General is that in the Attorney-General's opinion the charges do not stand in need of amendment by the furnishing of more particulars than were to be already found in the charges read out to the accused. ... In the result this inquiry as against the 1st, 3rd and 4th accused will proceed on the charges other than the ch....
(emphasis added)). 2 SCPRT’s arguments urging a different result are unavailing. SCPRT stresses that under South Carolina state law, the attorney general “does not represent” SCPRT—a distinct state agency—or have custody or control of its records. ... Although it acknowledged that the State’s attorney general “may have waived a limited portion of South Carolina’s sovereign immunity” by joining the federal suit against Google, SCPRT maintained....
Weiser, Attorney General of Colorado, Denver, Colorado; William Tong, Attorney General of Connecticut, Hartford, Connecticut; Kathleen Jennings, Attorney General of Delaware, Wilmington, Delaware; Kwame Raoul, Attorney General of Illinois, Chicago, Illinois; Anthony G. ... Echeverria, Deputy Attorney General; Mica L. Moore and Helen H. Hong, Deputy Solicitors General; Michael J. Mongan, Solicitor ....
Weiser, Attorney General of Colorado, Denver, Colorado; William Tong, Attorney General of Connecticut, Hartford, Connecticut; Kathleen Jennings, Attorney General of Delaware, Wilmington, Delaware; Kwame Raoul, Attorney General of Illinois, Chicago, Illinois; Anthony G. ... Echeverria, Deputy Attorney General; Mica L. Moore and Helen H. Hong, Deputy Solicitors General; Michael J. Mongan, Solicitor ....
The Attorney General exercises wide powers in respect of criminal prosecutions and such power has been bestowed on the Attorney General by statutory provisions. ... However much the Prosecutor is honest & impartial, no person should be prosecuted based only on untenable public opinion or on stereotypical personal ideologies as the role of such Prosecutor or the Attorney General is to ensure the fairness at every stage in the criminal proceeding. ... L.R. 250, Samarak....
The caption, in my opinion, should be amended by deleting the words " C. P. Layard " and " Colombo " and by adding the words " the Honorable " before the Attorney-General. ... LAYARD, Attorney-General of Ceylon. C. J. R. LE MESURIER v. Hon. Mr. C. P. LAYARD, Attorney-General of Ceylon. D. C, Colombo, C 9,983. ... - In my opinion the appellant is entitled to succeed. ... He says that the Attorney-General#HL_E....
We are of the opinion for the reasons stated that the Attorney-General had the power under Section 385 of the Criminal Procedure Code to file the information and the application to quash it must accordingly fail. ... THEJAWATHIE GUNAWARDENE Information No. 1 of 1954 exhibited in the Supreme Court by the Attorney-General Informations-Power of Attorney-General to exhibit informations-Circumstances when informations may be presented-Criminal Procedure Code, s.....
On this basis, a decision was taken by the CBI not to prosecute the petitioner. The opinion of Attorney General of India and Solicitor General of India are enclosed as Annexure-1 to the petition. Upon a detailed consideration of the matter, it was opined that there was insufficient material to justify the prosecution of the petitioner. Such opinion was concurred by the Attorney General of India.
The opinion, inter alia, states that having regard to the order in the State of Uttaranchal’s case, till this issue is resolved by a larger bench, the decision in S. Pushpa case cannot be ignored. Now, Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt. of India, vide its letter No.14012/09/2012-Delhi-I dated 03.04.2013 has informed that the subject matter has been re-examined in consultation with Ministry of Law & Justice. In this matter Learned Attorney General for India has given his opinion dated 18.02.2013 (copy enclosed), which is self-explanatory and has been approved by the Hon’ble Minister of....
Therefore, IUC would not be taxable under the category of service. Law Ministry and Attorney General have opined that IUC is not taxable in any of the existing taxable services. Opinion of Law Ministry/Attorney General has also been obtained in the matter. 4. However, vide Finance Bill, 2007, a new definition of ''telecommunication service'' has been incorporated vide clause (104) of Section 65 of the Finance Act, 1994 and IUC has been specifically incorporated in the definition of ''telecommunication service'' to make it a taxable service.
We, therefore, direct that notice returnable on 8th October, 1990 be issued to the alleged contemners calling upon them to show cause why proceedings for contempt of this Court under Article 129 of the Constitution should not be initiated against them in respect of the offending editorial published by them. We have seen the editorial in the "Indian Express" of August 13, 1990. We have obtained the opinion of the Attorney General of India in the matter. We consider that paragraphs 2 and 3 of the editorial tend to fall within the definition of 'criminal contempt' in Section 2....
To eliminate any scope of arbitrariness or unreasonableness, appellant ensured that the decision making process was multi-layered. 2. Decision was taken in the said meeting to obtain the opinion of Solicitor General of India. Thereafter, the CBC in its 430th meeting held on 27.12.2012 decided to hold negotiation with respondent No. 2 on the price bid. Opinion of the Attorney General was sought for and obtained. Ultimately, an opinion was obtained from the Attorney General of India on 14.12.2012. Only thereafter the appellant decided to exclude respondent N....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
