The in Bengaluru has issued a significant dual order in the ongoing of Sri Balaji Cement & Power Limited, mandating both the reconstitution of the and the immediate enhancement of police presence around the company’s non-operational factory site in Kalaburagi, Karnataka. These rulings address critical aspects of the , namely the legal classification of creditor claims and the physical protection of corporate assets.
In the first major development, the tribunal ruled that a debt originating from the supply of coal and transportation services does not transform into a “” simply because parties entered into a subsequent or registered a . The bench, comprising Member (Judicial) Sunil Kumar Aggarwal and Member (Technical) Radhakrishna Sreepada, clarified that the character of a debt is rooted in the nature of the underlying transaction. Consequently, the tribunal set aside the classification of as a , a move that had previously granted the entity a 69.73% voting share in the CoC.
The tribunal emphasized that under , a must involve the disbursement of money against consideration for the time value of money. The court observed, “The existence of Memorandums of Understanding, registered charge by way of Deed of Mortgage do not establish that the original transaction was a financial transaction because the essential requirements of Section 5(8) of the Code are that there must be a disbursement against consideration for the time value of money.” By affirming that commercial supply transactions cannot be converted into through settlement arrangements, the NCLT ordered the to reconstitute the CoC and submit a report within two weeks.
Security and Asset Protection
Concurrent with the governance overhaul, the tribunal addressed the deteriorating security situation at the company’s factory premises in Malkhed village. Since the factory ceased operations in , the site has been a frequent target for theft, resulting in the loss of transformers, copper wiring, and heavy machinery components. The RP reported that despite hiring private security firms, unauthorized intruders—often intoxicated—had repeatedly breached the premises and threatened security personnel with physical violence.
In one instance, intruders utilized a gas-cutter to dismantle iron staircase railings and components of the clinker cooling bucket conveyor. Although the local police had registered an regarding this specific incident, the ongoing threats to staff prompted the RP to file an application under seeking enhanced state-led protection. While the tribunal declined to order the permanent stationing of police forces, noting that the primary duty of safeguarding assets remains with the Resolution Professional, it did mandate increased oversight.
“The concerned Police Authorities arrayed in the application are directed to take adequate measures as to maintain law and order in and around the Factory premises including by taking a round of the area during their regular day/night patrolling,” the order stated. Furthermore, the tribunal directed the police to act decisively on complaints and FIRs lodged by the RP or security personnel, ensuring that perpetrators are apprehended in accordance with the law.
Strengthening Corporate Security Infrastructure
Beyond the intervention of law enforcement, the NCLT provided specific directives to the Resolution Professional to bolster the physical security of the asset. Acknowledging that the isolated location of the factory and the lack of lighting contributed to the vulnerability of the site, the tribunal instructed the RP to reinforce the perimeter. The bench ordered that the factory be bounded on all sides with appropriate fencing—suggesting embedded barbed wire if a full wall is not feasible—and restricted access to one or two monitored gates.
To facilitate better monitoring, the tribunal recommended the installation of recording cameras and improved lighting arrangements. Furthermore, it directed the deployment of security guards equipped with licensed arms to deter local groups from accessing the property. These measures are designed to preserve the remaining assets of the , ensuring that the of the unit is not eroded further during the CIRP.
The tribunal’s decisions collectively aim to stabilize the insolvency process for Sri Balaji Cement & Power Limited. By reclassifying P.D. Enterprises as an , the NCLT has sought to rectify the balance of power within the Committee of Creditors, effectively stripping a supply-chain participant of its dominant voting influence. Simultaneously, by involving local police authorities in a regular patrolling capacity, the tribunal has sought to mitigate the risk of further asset stripping.
The Resolution Professional is now tasked with the formal reconstitution of the CoC. Once the committee is reformed, it is expected to conduct a comprehensive review of previous decisions to determine if any remedial actions are required, including an assessment of the remuneration of the RP for the duration of the erroneous classification. The tribunal has listed the matter for further consideration on , by which time the compliance reports regarding the CoC reconstitution and the strengthening of site security are expected to be reviewed. The court’s approach reflects a firm stance on both the strict interpretation of statutory definitions of debt and the practical, on-the-ground requirements for managing corporate assets under financial distress.
insolvency resolution - creditor classification