The National Company Law Tribunal Mumbai Bench has rejected the resolution plan for Atharva Auto Logistics Private Limited, citing significant procedural flaws, lack of financial feasibility, and questionable conduct regarding the investigation of potentially avoidable transactions. In a decisive order, the tribunal directed the immediate initiation of the liquidation process for the company, effectively terminating the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process that had been underway since February 2022.

The resolution plan, submitted by the company’s own suspended director, Suyog Satish Pachange, was found to be in violation of multiple statutory requirements and the terms established in the Request for Resolution Plan. Beyond the administrative deficiencies, the tribunal raised grave concerns regarding the Resolution Professional’s handling of financial records and the failure to initiate proceedings against Preferential, Undervalued, Extortionate, or Fraudulent (PUFE) transactions. The tribunal has instructed the Registry to forward the order to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India for potential disciplinary action against the Resolution Professional, Uday Kumar Bhaskar Bhatt.

The tribunal’s skepticism centered largely on significant advances totaling approximately ₹4.16 crore, which were attributed to two company employees, Dhiraj Kolhe and Dilip Theurkar. Despite the substantial nature of these outlays, the resolution process failed to provide a robust audit or justification for these payments. The court highlighted that ledger adjustments involving these amounts were performed during the insolvency period, often without adequate documentation or proof of services rendered.

Addressing these concerns, the bench remarked, “To our mind it appears that no PUFE application is filed merely to avoid disqualification of the present Resolution Applicant under Section 29A(g) of the Code.” By failing to thoroughly investigate these transactions, the tribunal noted that the process appeared to have been orchestrated to facilitate the return of a suspended director to the helm of the company, a move that would have been prohibited had the transactions been successfully challenged under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code.

The tribunal identified a series of critical failures in the submitted plan that rendered it non-responsive. Firstly, the payment timeline for upfront cash recovery was found to be open-ended and inconsistent with the Request for Resolution Plan, which mandated payment within 30 days of approval. The resolution plan’s stipulation that payments would be made “on or after 90 days” left the implementation schedule indeterminate, violating the requirements set forth in Regulation 38(2)(a) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2016.

Additionally, the plan failed to satisfy the requirement for Performance Security. While the Request for Resolution Plan demanded a Performance Bank Guarantee equivalent to 20% of the bid value—amounting to ₹20 lakh—the Resolution Professional failed to provide evidence that this security had been fully furnished. The record showed a deposit of only ₹5 lakh, leaving a substantial shortfall of ₹15 lakh, which, according to the tribunal, was grounds for rendering the entire resolution plan non-responsive under the specific terms of the tender documents.

Financial viability, a cornerstone of any acceptable resolution plan, was also deemed missing. The tribunal observed that the plan relied heavily on anticipated business receipts and unspecified subordinated debt to fund the proposed ₹100 lakh infusion. No binding commitments, term sheets, or formal agreements were placed on record to prove that these funds were actually available or that the resolution applicant possessed the necessary financial standing to back the plan. As the bench observed, “The feasibility and viability of the Plan within the meaning of Regulation 38(3)(b) is not satisfactorily established.”

Furthermore, the tribunal scrutinized the plan’s compliance with Section 30(2)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, which protects the interests of dissenting financial creditors. In this instance, Intec Capital Limited, which held a 33.88% voting share, did not vote in favor of the plan. The statutory minimum payout required for such a dissenting creditor was ₹22.28 lakh, yet the resolution plan only allocated ₹22.15 lakh, resulting in a clear statutory shortfall. The tribunal also noted that the plan failed to explicitly outline the priority of payments required under Regulation 38(1)(a) and 38(1)(b), which mandate that payments to operational creditors and dissenting financial creditors must take precedence over other claims.

Following the formal rejection of the plan, the tribunal invoked the provisions of Section 33(1)(b) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code to initiate the liquidation of Atharva Auto Logistics. To oversee this process, the bench appointed Vinit Gangwal as the liquidator. Under the tribunal's order, the new liquidator is tasked with taking control of all corporate assets and has been granted the authority to continue or institute fresh proceedings concerning any avoidance transactions that were previously ignored.

The transition to liquidation marks the end of a protracted insolvency process that was plagued by lack of cooperation from suspended directors and a failure by the professional lead to maintain proper corporate oversight. The tribunal’s order is intended to ensure that the remaining assets of the corporate debtor are managed in a transparent, accountable manner, with the liquidator expected to submit a preliminary report within 30 days.

This ruling underscores the tribunal’s commitment to enforcing strict compliance with insolvency regulations, signaling that resolution plans cannot simply be approved based on the commercial wisdom of a committee if they are fundamentally flawed or lack statutory integrity. The registry will now provide all relevant stakeholders, including the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and the Registrar of Companies in Pune, with the final order to commence the necessary liquidation filings. All personnel associated with the company are now effectively discharged, and the powers of the previous board are formally vested in the appointed liquidator.