The has upheld the of , affirming the government's authority to restrict the availment of (ITC) for invoices or debit notes that remain unuploaded by suppliers in the electronic portal. A Division Bench comprising Justice Arun Monga and Justice Yogendra Kumar Purohit dismissed a batch of that sought the quashing of the rule and consequential issued by tax authorities, ruling that the challenged provision falls within the of the GST framework.
The court’s decision settles a persistent dispute regarding the extent of power delegated to the executive in framing rules under the GST regime. By validating Rule 36(4), the court has solidified the department's stance that ITC is a , not an , and can be subject to designed to ensure compliance and curb fraudulent credit claims. The bench explicitly aligned itself with the judicial positions previously adopted by the , Madras, and Kerala, which had similarly rejected challenges to the rule’s validity.
Judicial Reasoning on Rule-Making Authority
The petitioners, including M/s. Ravi Infrabuild Projects Pvt. Ltd., M/s Blue Phosphate Ltd., and the , had contended that the restriction imposed by Rule 36(4) was to the parent . They argued that once a taxpayer had satisfied the conditions laid out in , the entitlement to ITC became vested, and the government could not impose additional barriers—such as the supplier's failure to upload invoices—via . The petitioners further maintained that the rule was arbitrary, particularly because the statutory mechanisms for automatic matching of credits under Sections 37 and 42 were not fully operational at the relevant time due to systemic limitations.
However, the court found these contentions unpersuasive. In its order, the bench highlighted that Rule 36(4) derives its legitimacy from both Section 16 and the broader rule-making powers conferred under
. The court underscored that these provisions grant the government sufficient scope to prescribe conditions for tax credits to protect revenue. Addressing the arguments regarding the rule’s constitutional compliance, the court noted that the provision serves as a necessary policy measure intended to regulate the flow of tax credit within the economy. As the bench observed:
"We are in respectful agreement with the view taken therein and see no reason to take a contrary view."
The court further addressed the argument that Rule 36(4) was invalid because —which had been intended to govern such procedures—was never effectively notified before its omission. Relying on the reasoning established in prior rulings, the bench clarified that the absence of a notified Section 43A did not strip the government of its general authority to make rules under Section 164 for carrying out the provisions of the Act.
Limitations on
Beyond the constitutional challenge to the rule itself, the court examined the validity of the issued by the GST authorities, which had prompted the legal action. The department had initiated proceedings in Form GST DRC-01A, demanding the reversal of ITC worth approximately ₹1.22 crore, citing a mismatch between the taxpayer’s claims and the credit reflected in the GSTR-2A records.
The High Court held that the challenge to these notices was fundamentally dependent on the success of the challenge to the validity of Rule 36(4). Since the court upheld the rule, it found no basis to quash the proceedings initiated by the department. Relying on the principles set forth by the
in cases regarding the
of writs against preliminary departmental notices, the bench affirmed that courts are generally reluctant to intervene at the show-cause stage.
"It is trite law that no writ lies against an issuance of show cause notice and such writ petition would not be maintainable,"
the court stated, citing established precedent.
Procedural Path Forward for Taxpayers
While the decision represents a significant setback for the petitioners in their attempt to invalidate the rule, the court offered a path for continued litigation through statutory channels. During the proceedings, the bench noted that it was unclear whether final assessment orders had already been passed in the cases, as no interim stay had been granted during the pendency of the petitions.
The court clarified that its ruling would not impede the rights of the petitioners to seek appropriate relief if they were aggrieved by subsequent adverse orders. It held that the petitioners remain at liberty to appear before the competent tax authorities to present relevant evidence or, if an assessment order has already been finalized, to pursue the of an appeal under . This approach ensures that the factual disputes regarding specific ITC mismatches are addressed through the administrative hierarchy rather than in .
By refusing to interfere with the departmental process, the court has signaled that the technical and evidentiary issues arising from invoice mismatches are best resolved through the established mechanisms of the GST law. Taxpayers are now expected to comply with the existing regulatory requirements regarding invoice uploads while utilizing the available appellate forums to contest specific demands that they believe are legally or factually unsustainable. The batch of petitions stands disposed of, with the court stressing that the regulatory framework for ITC remains intact and enforceable across the state.
input tax credit - indirect tax litigation