AI Overview...
Branch of Undertaking - Summary of Main Points and Insights
-
Definition and Nature of Undertaking
An undertaking is a formal promise given by a party, either to the court or to another party, to perform or abstain from certain actions. It can be given in court proceedings or to a third party, with court-recorded undertakings holding particular enforceability BRANDS ACADEMY PVT LTD VS RISHU MONGA - Delhi, AYISSA BIBI UMMA VS ABOOBACKER - Kerala. -
Enforceability and Formal Recording
For an undertaking to be enforceable, it must be formally recorded and accepted by the court. Without such recording, breach may lack legal consequence, and the court may not have jurisdiction to act against violations Velpa International (P) Limited vs Priyadharshini - Madras. An undertaking not accepted or recorded by the court cannot be treated as binding or enforceable. -
Breach of Undertaking and Consequences
Breaching an undertaking, especially one given to the court, can lead to contempt proceedings, including penalties such as arrest or imprisonment. Wilful breach, even if unintentional, can be considered contempt, but the court distinguishes between breaches to a court and those to a third party SEVAKRAM PRABHUDAS VS H. S. PATEL - Gujarat, DEEPIKA CHAUHAN VS INDRA PASRICHA - Delhi. -
Breach of Undertaking to the Court vs. Third Parties
Breach of an undertaking given to a third party may not constitute contempt of court. The courts emphasize that only undertakings given to the court are directly enforceable as contempt, whereas those given to other parties are subject to contractual remedies AYISSA BIBI UMMA VS ABOOBACKER - Kerala. -
Specific Case Insights
- In cases involving structural removal or compliance with court orders, breach of undertaking can result in penalties or fresh notices, emphasizing the importance of strict compliance Mukesh Ramesh Bajaj vs Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation - Bombay.
- In property disputes, breach of undertaking regarding use or vacating premises can lead to contempt proceedings, with courts examining whether the undertaking was to the court or a party J. P. GOYAL VS AJEET KAUR - Delhi.
-
The courts have reiterated that an unconditional apology or acknowledgment of breach does not automatically negate contempt if the breach was wilful SEVAKRAM PRABHUDAS VS H. S. PATEL - Gujarat.
-
Court's Discretion and Principles
The courts maintain discretion in determining whether a breach amounts to contempt, considering factors like willfulness, formal acceptance, and the nature of the undertaking. They also emphasize that breach of an undertaking to the court is misconduct and can be punished accordingly BRANDS ACADEMY PVT LTD VS RISHU MONGA - Delhi, DEEPIKA CHAUHAN VS INDRA PASRICHA - Delhi.
Analysis and Conclusion
An undertaking is a significant legal instrument in judicial proceedings, with enforceability primarily dependent on formal recording and acceptance by the court. Breaching an undertaking, especially one given to the court, can constitute contempt and lead to serious legal consequences, including arrest. However, undertakings given solely to third parties may not invoke contempt proceedings but are enforceable through contractual remedies. Courts consistently stress the importance of compliance and the potential repercussions of wilful breaches, underscoring the need for parties to honor their commitments made in judicial settings.
References:
- Mukesh Ramesh Bajaj vs Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation - Bombay
- Velpa International (P) Limited vs Priyadharshini - Madras
- BRANDS ACADEMY PVT LTD VS RISHU MONGA - Delhi
- SEVAKRAM PRABHUDAS VS H. S. PATEL - Gujarat
- SHREE AMBICA NAGAR CO-OP HOUSING SOCIETY LTD. vs STATE OF GUJARAT - Gujarat
- Silver Glades Holdings Private Limited vs Shefali Varma - Delhi
- Praveen Kumar Sehrawat VS Rashmi Sehrawat - Delhi
- DEEPIKA CHAUHAN VS INDRA PASRICHA - Delhi
- AYISSA BIBI UMMA VS ABOOBACKER - Kerala
- J. P. GOYAL VS AJEET KAUR - Delhi
Search Results for "Brrach of Undertaking"
2025 Supreme(Online)(Bom) 4321 • India - Bombay High Court
GAURI GODSE, J
The appellant submitted an affidavit-cum-undertaking regarding the removal of an offending structure, which was accepted by the court ... The appellant was previously granted protection on a similar undertaking, which he breached, leading to issuance of a fresh notice ... The court emphasized compliance with undertakings to avoid contempt. ... It is clarified that this affidavit-cum-undertaking is in breach of the earlier order passed by this Court; hence, the same has not been accepted. However, the a....
2025 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 69781 • India - IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
P.B. BALAJI
failure to formally record undertaking affects its enforceability. ... of an undertaking to furnish security for a money claim - Trial Court dismisses application citing alternate remedy - Court emphasizes ... ... ... Ratio Decidendi: Without a recorded acceptance of an undertaking by the court, its infringement lacks enforceability and ... breach thereof and if the undertaking violated by him, the Court has jurisdiction to deal with such violation by even order his arrest and imprisonment. ... therea....
2015 0 Supreme(Del) 2838 • India - Delhi
MANMOHAN
undertaking given to a party and an undertaking given to a Court, and the consequences of breaching an undertaking. ... Contempt - Breach of Undertaking - Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 - Section 2(b) - CS(OS) 7/2015 - 11, 23, 24, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39 ... , 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48 - The court discussed the breach of undertaking given to a Court, the distinction between an ... In the absence of any express undertaking given by the appellant or ....
1999 0 Supreme(Guj) 423 • India - Gujarat
ANIL R.DAVE, R.BALIA
to maintain status quo - Breach of undertaking - Wilful breach of undertaking - Unconditional apology - Contempt of Court - Whether ... - Breach of under-taking - Such statement was made in Court - Whether it amount to statement on undertaking in Court - When nothing ... We, therefore, in the circumstances, even on assumption that case for wilful breach of undertaking given to Court is made out, would ... Another principle which governs the issue a....
• India - Gujarat High Court
S.R.BRAHMBHATT, R.P.DHOLARIA, JJ
The respondent committed contempt by violating an earlier undertaking regarding the residential use of the premises. ... - The court reiterated the obligations of society members under the Cooperative Societies Act and the consequences of breaching undertaking ... Respondent continued construction activities despite clear undertakings. ... breach is concerned, as there is no breach whatsoever of the undertaking or order. ... One may say that this interpretation would be a fin....
• India - Delhi High Court
SANJEEV SACHDEVA
(A) Contempt of Court - Breach of undertaking - Full and final settlement agreement executed on 26.12.2019 - Respondent agreed to ... (Paras 2-13) ... ... (B) Waiver of rights - Petitioner acknowledges undertaking from respondent ... ... ... Findings of Court: ... The court accepted the respondent's undertaking regarding future payments and allowed the petitioner ... Petitioner has filed the present petition seeking initiation of contempt proceedings against the respondent for breach of u....
2023 0 Supreme(Del) 3615 • India - Delhi
SANJEEV SACHDEVA, MANOJ JAIN
Undertaking - Maintenance and School Fees - Appellant held guilty of breach of court order and undertaking, undertakes to clear ... Case: Appellant held guilty of breach of court order and undertaking regarding payment of maintenance and school fees for ... accepted, appeal disposed of Issues: Breach of court order and undertaking, non-payment of maintenance and school fees ... Appellant impugns order dated 10.04.2023 whereby appellant has been held guilty of #HL_ST....
2023 0 Supreme(Del) 483 • India - Delhi
SURESH KUMAR KAIT, NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
and breach of an undertaking given to the court. ... Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the breach of an undertaking given to the court, even if recorded in a consent decree ... of the Undertaking given to the court. ... as an injunction made by the Court and a breach of the undertaking is misconduct amounting to contempt.” ... Analysed, the definition provides for two categories of cases, namely: (1) willful disobedience to a process of Court; or (2) willful #HL_S....
1971 0 Supreme(Ker) 245 • India - Kerala
T.C.RAGHAVAN, P.NARAYANA PILLAI
The breach of an undertaking given to the other party may not constitute contempt of court. ... Contempt of Court - Breach of Undertaking - Calcutta High Court, Bombay High Court, Patna High Court, Punjab High Court, Madhya ... Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that every undertaking given by a party to litigation is not necessarily an undertaking ... The breach of an undertaking given to the other party will not constitute contempt of court: on....
1984 0 Supreme(Del) 326 • India - Delhi
N.N.GOSWAMY
CONTEMPT OF COURT - UNDERTAKING TO THE COURT - BREACH - CONSEQUENCES - DELHI RENT CONTROL ACT, 1958 - SECTION 21 - COMPROMISE ... Issues: Whether the tenant's undertaking to vacate the premises by a particular date was an undertaking to the court. ... Ratio Decidendi: The court relied on the following principles: * An undertaking given to the court is an implied undertaking ... Having regard to the fact that the consequences of default were provided in the undertaking#HL_E....
Filter by Legal Phrase
