AI Overview...
Case Law Database: Essential Guide to Indian Judicial Resources
In the digital age, a case law database has become indispensable for legal professionals, researchers, and students. These repositories compile judgments from courts like the Supreme Court of India and High Courts, enabling quick access to precedents. But what does Indian law say about case law databases? Are they protected under copyright? How are they used in disputes? This post draws from key judgments to explore these questions.
Note: This is general information based on case law, not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
Understanding Case Law Databases in India
A case law database is a structured collection of court judgments, often digitized for searchability. Courts increasingly reference such databases in rulings on copyright, contracts, and taxation. For instance, compilations of legal information qualify as literary works under copyright law.
Copyright Protection for Databases
Indian courts have consistently held that databases created through skill and labor are protectable. In one case, a compilation of client addresses developed over time was deemed a literary work under the Copyright Act, 1957. The court granted an interim injunction against misuse, noting:
Compilation of list of clients/customers developed by a person by devoting time, money, labour and skill amounts to a literary work wherein the author has a copyright. BURLINGTON HOME SHOPPING PRIVATE LIMITED VS RAJNISH CHIBBER - 1995 Supreme(Del) 811
Similarly, a herbal database was protected, with the court awarding damages for infringement and passing off. The ruling emphasized trade dress rights and punitive damages to deter violations:
The judgment established the importance of copyright ownership and protection, as well as the application of compensatory and punitive damages to discourage violations of intellectual property rights. HIMALAYA DRUG COMPANY VS SUMIT - 2005 Supreme(Del) 1071
Key Takeaways on Database Copyright:
- Databases like case law compilations gain protection if they involve original effort M/S VOGUESERV INTERNATIONAL PVT LTD vs RAJESH GOSAIN & ORS.
- Unauthorized copying or harvesting leads to injunctions and damages T. S. J. Media Private Limited, Represented by its Director, Arun Natarajan VS Boston Analytics Private Limited, Mumbai - 2021 Supreme(Mad) 1739.
- Even subscription-based access to legal databases (e.g., venture intelligence data) is safeguarded, as subscribers agree to terms protecting content by copyrights and trademarks.
These precedents apply directly to case law databases, where judgments are curated with indexing, summaries, and hyperlinks.
Databases in Criminal and Contract Law Contexts
Case law databases often intersect with broader legal issues. In quashing proceedings after compromise, courts reference statutory provisions like CrPC Sections 320 and 482. One ruling clarified:
Quashing a proceeding becoming futile after compromise and compounding of offence are two different things. GIAN SINGH VS STATE OF PUNJAB - 2012 7 Supreme 1
While not directly about databases, such cases are staples in legal databases. Breach of contract suits frequently cite database-related disputes, like supply contracts where timely defect notification is key:
In supply contracts, timely notification of defects is essential; failure to do so can forfeit claims for damages. COCHIN REFINERIES LTD. Vs M/S.VISHAL ENGINEERING WORKS - 2009 Supreme(Online)(KER) 47698
Arbitration awards involving databases can be set aside if patently illegal, per Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. Courts stress adherence to contract terms for liquidated damages Oil & Natural Gas Corporation LTD. VS SAW Pipes LTD. - 2003 3 Supreme 449.
Rule of Law and Public Databases
Public databases like PAN records play roles in tax and criminal law. Notices under Income Tax Act Section 143(2) use PAN database addresses:
Mere mentioning of the new address in the return of income without specifically intimating the Assessing Officer... is not enough. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai VS IVen Interactive Limited, Mumbai - 2019 Supreme(SC) 1159
This underscores accuracy in official databases, mirroring standards for case law databases.
Taxation of Database Access: Royalty or Not?
A hot topic is whether subscription fees to foreign databases (e.g., online journals) qualify as royalty under Income Tax Act Section 9(1)(vi) or India-US DTAA.
ITAT rulings clarify:
Payments for subscription access do not equate to royalty; they don't confer rights over copyrights or equipment. PLURALSIGHT LLC UTAH vs DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE - 2(1) BANGALORE - 2024 Supreme(Online)(ITAT) 236
Another held:
Income from online journal sales does not qualify as royalty or fees for technical services under the Income Tax Act or the India-US tax treaty. JOHN WILEY AND SONS INC. UNITED STATES vs ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (INT. TAXATION) 2(1)(2) NEW DELHI NEW DELHI - 2025 Supreme(Online)(ITAT) 2296
Implications for Case Law Databases:
- Access fees to international legal databases (e.g., Westlaw equivalents) are typically business income, not taxable as royalty.
- No transfer of copyright usage rights occurs; it's mere viewing access Factset Research Systems Inc. , In re VS.
Judicial Access and Supreme Court Precedents
Supreme Court cases form the backbone of any case law database. Rulings on corruption, transfers, and rule of law emphasize supremacy:
Whoever he may be, however high he is, he is under the law. State Of Haryana VS Bhajan Lal - 1990 Supreme(SC) 740
In Antulay's case, the Court corrected a transfer error per incuriam, stressing procedure under CrPC and Criminal Law Amendment Act A. R. Antulay VS R. S. Nayak - 1988 Supreme(SC) 337. Such landmark judgments are digitized in databases like SCC Online or Manupatra.
Databases also aid in evidentiary appreciation, as in rape cases where chemical reports were ignored perversely State Of Punjab VS Gurmitsingh - 1996 1 Supreme 485.
Challenges and Best Practices for Using Case Law Databases
- Accuracy: Verify against original judgments; databases may have errors.
- Updates: Courts mandate timely uploads (e.g., e-Courts project).
- Access: Free portals like Indian Kanoon vs. paid ones like LexisNexis.
- Protection: Former employees misusing client databases face injunctions VOGUESERV INTERNATIONAL VS RAJESH GOSAIN - 2013 Supreme(Del) 979.
Pro Tips:
1. Cross-reference multiple databases.
2. Use advanced search for sections like IPC 420 or CrPC 482.
3. Note citation formats for authenticity.
Key Takeaways
- Case law databases are vital for research, protected as literary works under copyright law BURLINGTON HOME SHOPPING PRIVATE LIMITED VS RAJNISH CHIBBER - 1995 Supreme(Del) 811.
- Tax on access is generally not royalty if no copyright transfer occurs PLURALSIGHT LLC UTAH vs DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE - 2(1) BANGALORE - 2024 Supreme(Online)(ITAT) 236.
- Courts rely on them for precedents in contracts, arbitration, and criminal matters GIAN SINGH VS STATE OF PUNJAB - 2012 7 Supreme 1, Oil & Natural Gas Corporation LTD. VS SAW Pipes LTD. - 2003 3 Supreme 449.
- Always update personal/public records like PAN databases to avoid procedural lapses Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Mumbai VS IVen Interactive Limited, Mumbai - 2019 Supreme(SC) 1159.
In summary, Indian jurisprudence views case law databases as essential tools, safeguarded by IP laws while facilitating justice. Stay informed with reliable sources to navigate legal complexities effectively.
This post synthesizes public case law for educational purposes. Legal outcomes vary by facts; seek professional advice.
Search Results for "Case Law Database: Key Indian Judgments Guide"
2012 7 Supreme 1 • India - Supreme Court
R.M.LODHA, SUDHANSU JYOTI MUKHOPADHAYA, ANIL R.DAVE
2008 (2) Mh.L.J. 856 - Referred ... Facts of the case ... Any order in violation and breach of statutory provisions, learned Additional Solicitor General would submit, would be a case against ... where the complainant and the accused had settled their differences and had arrived at an amicable arrangement, we see no reason ... Notwithstanding a touch of criminal liability, the settlement would bring lasting peace and harmony to larger number of people.
1990 0 Supreme(SC) 740 • India - Supreme Court
S.R.PANDIAN, K.JAYACHANDRA REDDY
Whoever he may be, however high he is, he is under the law. ... Conviction - First Information Report - Everyone whether individually or collectively is unquestionably under the supremacy of law ... However, in Rishbud's case and Muni Lal's case, it has been ruled that if any breach of the said mandatory provision relating to ... Ltd. had entered into an agreement of sale dated 22-9-1988 with Mrs. ... We are in agreement with the views, expressed by Mitter, J. and Mud....
1979 0 Supreme(SC) 300 • India - Supreme Court
P.N.BHAGWATI, R.S.PATHAK, V.D.TULZAPURKAR
" in Democracy, Equality and Freedom "substantial agreement in juristic thought that the great purpose of the rule of law notion ... with any one it likes and choosing one person in preference to another for entering into a contract does not involve violation of ... respondents in breach of the condition of eligibility laid down in paragraph (1) of the notice.
1990 0 Supreme(SC) 567 • India - Supreme Court
J.S.VERMA, R.M.SAHAI
of being an abuse of the power - It is unnecessary for us to go into that question also since order, we are making, governs the case ... Counsel - Appointment and renewal - Power of termination of any appointment - This has been done by Circular G.0, No.D-284-Seven-Law-Ministry ... questions arise for decision by us in this bunch of matters - Held, Non-arbitrariness, being a necessary concomitant of the rule of law ... of a contract. ... There can be no doubt that this function of the Public Prosecutor relates to a publi....
2003 3 Supreme 449 • India - Supreme Court
M.B.SHAH, ARUN KUMAR
in consequences of the breach of a contract. ... of breach of contract, the person aggrieved by the breach is not required to prove actual loss or damage suffered by him before ... The Court is competent to award reasonable compensation in case of breach even if no actual damage is proved to have been suffered ... of breach but with a case where the contract contained stipulation by way of penalty. ... —When a #HL_....
2009 Supreme(Online)(KER) 47698 • India - High Court of Kerala
M.L.JOSEPH FRANCIS, J
Damages - Supply Contract - Act Section List - The case revolves around a breach of contract, focusing on defective materials ... Ratio Decidendi: A buyer's obligation to notify a seller of defective goods promptly is pivotal to any breach of contract ... Fact of the Case: A plaintiff sued for damages due to defective materials supplied by the defendants. .......
1996 0 Supreme(Gau) 55 • India - Gauhati
J.N.SARMA
The measure of damages for breach of contract is laid down in the case of Hadley vs. Baxendable, 5 AC 25. 3. ... Section 73 of the Contract Act provides for compensation for loss or damage caused by breach of contract. 2. ... CONTRACT - BREACH OF CONTRACT - SECTION 73 OF TH....
• India - Madhya Pradesh
SHINDE, CHATURVEDI
CONTRACT - BREACH - DAMAGES - MEASURE OF DAMAGES - SALE OF GOODS - NON-DELIVERY - PROFITS LOST - DEDUCTION OF EXPENSES. ... Whether the plaintiff was entitled to damages for breach of contract? 3. ... material time and that the plaintiff was entitled to damages for breach of contract. ... The fundamental principle of....
2023 0 Supreme(Ker) 426 • India - Kerala
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
, 1968 - Contract - Breach of contract - Forfeiture of bill amount on termination of contract - To issue a writ of certiorari or ... is made clear that Court have not gone into merits of case - Ext.P9 to extent it fixes liability of Rs.6,00,000/- and Ext.P14 revenue ... of Rs.6,00,000/- and decision taken not to make bill payment for diaries already supplied, ar....
1994 0 Supreme(Gau) 62 • India - Gauhati
J.N.SARMA
CONTRACT - Breach of Contract - Damages - Measure of Damages - Burden of Proof - Section 73 of the Contract Act - Plaintiff's ... claim for damages for breach of contract dismissed due to failure to prove breach of contract by the defendant. ... The plaintiff's claim for damages#HL....
1995 0 Supreme(Del) 811 • India - Delhi
R.C.LAHOTI
" ... THE learned Judge has during the course of his judgment laid down a few principles based on a review of the case law which are reproduced hereunder so far as relevant for the decision of the case at hand : " Some of the rules of law that emerge from the principles enunciated in ... The range of things which may be included in a computer database is enormous. The information contained in the database may, itself, be confidential and protected by the law of breach....
2024 Supreme(Online)(ITAT) 236 • India - Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Bangalore Bench)
Smt. Beena Pillai, J, Shri Laxmi Prasad Sahu, ACJ
2023 to the extent prejudicial to the Appellant, is bad in law. contrary to the facts and circumstances of the case and is liable to be quashed. ... On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the final assessment order dated 7 July 2023 under section 143(3) read with section 144C(13) of the Act passed by the I,d. ... Ground No. 5 On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AU erred in levying interest under section 234B of the Act amoun....
2013 0 Supreme(Del) 979 • India - Delhi
MUKTA GUPTA
David Bainbridge has in SOFTWARE COPYRIGHT LAW (at p.48) dealt with computer database in the following terms: ... A computer database is a collection of information stored on computer media. ... The information contained in the database may, itself, be confidential and protected by the law of breach of confidence but what of the copyright position The simplest way of looking at a computer database is to consider the work it represents, for example a printed listing of names and addres....
2019 0 Supreme(SC) 1159 • India - Supreme Court
UDAY UMESH LALIT, INDIRA BANERJEE, M.R.SHAH
It is required to be noted that notices under Section 143(2) of the 1961 Act are issued on selection of case generated under automated system of the Department which picks up the address of the assessee from the database of the PAN. ... It is submitted therefore that in the facts and circumstances of the case the Assessing Officer was justified in sending the notices under Section 143(2) of the 1961 Act at the available address as per the PAN database. It is submitted therefore that the learned C.I.T. ... the said requir....
• India - Delhi High Court
David Bainbridge has in SOFTWARE COPYRIGHT LAW (at p.48) dealt with computer database in the following terms: A computer database is a collection of information stored on computer media. ... The information contained in the database may, itself, be confidential and protected by the law of breach of confidence but what of the copyright position The simplest way of looking at a computer database is to 10 In the facts and circumstances of the case I am....
Filter by Legal Phrase
