AI Overview...
- Co Shares Can Claim Preemption - Main points and insights:
- Rights of preemption are recognized under various laws such as the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, Partition Act, and Indian Succession Act, 1925, but their applicability depends on specific legal contexts and relationships KAILASHCHANDRA s/o RAMCHANDRA MISHRA VS DAMODAR s/o BALABAX (deceased) through Legal Heirs SMT. REVA DEVI w/o DAMODAR MISHRA - Madhya Pradesh, Tilok Chand VS Laxmi Narayan - Rajasthan.
- In Hindu law, preemption rights are linked to degrees of relationship with the vendor; claimants must establish their relationship within specific degrees to succeed Tilok Chand VS Laxmi Narayan - Rajasthan.
- The right of preemption can be exercised over entire property or shares, but not selectively against individual shares unless law permits; in some cases, the right must be exercised jointly Abdul Gafoor VS Musst. Nur Banu - Calcutta, Ram Shenkar Prasad Singh VS Additional Member, Board of Revenue - Patna.
- Court fees for preemption suits are to be based on the value of the shares sought, and the claimant's admission or denial of rights can affect their claim NAMBOORIKKANDY AMMAD Vs KOLARAKUTTIYIL BASHEER - Kerala.
- Under Islamic law, preemption rights are created among co-sharers, and sales with strangers are subject to specific restrictions; the right is generally limited to co-owners H.Abdul Gani (died) vs Venmathi Aachi - Madras.
- When a stranger purchaser sues for partition, the preemption rights of co-sharers may be extinguished if all parties seek partition, emphasizing the importance of joint claims and the nature of the transaction Sundari Bewa VS Ranka Behara - Orissa.
- Analysis and Conclusion:
- Co-sharers, including Co Shares, can claim preemption rights provided they meet legal criteria related to relationship, ownership, and the nature of the transaction.
- Preemption claims require careful consideration of the applicable law, relationship degrees, and whether the property is partitioned or shares are defined.
- In cases involving joint ownership or co-sharers, exercising preemption typically involves the entire property or shares collectively, not selectively.
- Legal precedents affirm that preemption rights are protected but are subject to specific procedural and substantive conditions, including law-specific restrictions and the context of sale or partition.
- Therefore, Co Shares can claim preemption rights, but success depends on fulfilling statutory requirements and the nature of their ownership and relationship with the vendor or other co-sharers.
Search Results for "Co Shares can Claim Preemption"
2019 0 Supreme(MP) 804 • India - Madhya Pradesh
VANDANA KASREKAR
for filing a civil suit claiming right of preemption. ... Preemption - Property Dispute - Hindu Succession Act, 1956, Section 22 - Indian Succession Act, 1925, Section 127 - The judgment ... discusses the applicability of the right of preemption under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and the voidability of a clause in a ... , the appellant has no right to claim right of preemption. ... has no right to preemption. ... In the present case, the appellant in para 6 of the plaint had admitted....
2008 Supreme(Online)(KER) 14155 • India - High Court of Kerala
M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR, J
Fact of the Case: The petitioner sought 5/6 shares via preemption, while the respondent counterclaimed for 1/6 shares ... Ratio Decidendi: The court clarified that court fees for preemption should be based on the value of the share sought to be ... court fees paid under the Act concerning the right to preemption. ... Petitioner instituted the suit for a decree for assignment of 5/6 shares due to respondent in favour of petitioner in exercise of the right of #HL_STA....
2024 0 Supreme(Telangana) 240 • India - Telangana
P. SAM KOSHY
They claimed a right of preemption under the Partition Act, arguing they should be allowed to purchase their shares before the properties ... for preemption under the Partition Act. ... in rejecting their application for preemption. ... Thus, prima facie, it appears that the law makers were certain when they have enacted the said provisions that in the event of a claim of right to preemption, the interest of the said person who seeks right for preemption is protected ....
2005 3 Supreme 46 • India - Supreme Court
RUMA PAL, P.VENKATARAMA REDDI
to exercise their undisputed right of preemption in respect of shares—Issue of 17,666 shares and their allotment to Pawar Group ... by respondents 3 and 4 in the company—Basis of claim of appellant with regard to 3417 and 93 shares was the failure to allow appellants ... of pre-emptive right in transfer of shares—Transfer of shares in the Company belonging to estate of husband of appellant by three ... The basis of the claim of the appellant and Shan....
1985 0 Supreme(Pat) 4 • India - Patna
BIRENDRA PRASAD SINHA
it is not possible for them to claim preemption jointly. ... claiming to be adjoining raiyats of all the vended land–First authority allowing the claim of preemption of some out of the preemption ... must establish that all of them are either cosharer or adjoining raiyats–If any one of them can not claim preemption separately ... The State of Bihar 1984 BBCJ 45 and has submitted that a joint claim for preemption is maintainable and ....
1868 0 Supreme(Cal) 120 • India - Calcutta
pre-emption right can be exercised against the entire sale or not at all, and cannot be selectively enforced against individual shares ... required to take the bargain with all its advantages and risks, and could not selectively enforce her right against individual shares ... pre-emption right can be exercised against the entire sale or not at all, and cannot be selectively enforced against individual shares ... If she elects to enforce her right of preemption, she must take the bargain with all its advantages and risks:....
1983 0 Supreme(Cal) 281 • India - Calcutta
S.N.SANYAL, A.K.SEN
The trial court dismissed the plaintiff's claim for pre-emption, but the appellate court reversed the decision and decreed the claim ... Whether a stranger purchaser must sue for partition or claim partition on separate allotment in order to attract Section 4 of the ... Section 4 of the Partition Act against the defendant, a stranger purchaser of a share in the dwelling house. ... That decision of the learned District Judge being challenged in this court the learned Judge upheld the claimant co-sharer's claim#H....
1953 0 Supreme(Raj) 194 • India - Rajasthan
DAVE
(a) Indian Succession Act, Secs. 28 and 23—Applicability—Preemption case where parties are Hindus — Counting of degrees —Section ... Sale by joint vendors—One vendor related in third degree but other vendor related in fourth degree—Property not partitioned and shares ... not defined—Pre-emptors claim should fail as a whole. ... It was held that he could claim preference on the score of relationship with the vendors to whom he was related in respect of the specific share of those particular vendors. ... ....
2024 Supreme(Online)(MAD) 37642 • India - High Court of Madras
P.VELMURUGAN, K.K.RAMAKRISHNAN, JJ
... Issues: The main issues included the validity of the oral Hiba and the binding nature of the sale deed on the plaintiff's share ... They inherit their shares in definite fraction and they are all entitled to claim for partition as co-owners and separate possession of their respective shares. ... (iv)According to the Islamic Law, a right of preemption is created and any sale transaction could be effected only between the co-sharers of the suit property and not with any strangers. ....
1968 0 Supreme(Ori) 6 • India - Orissa
S.K.RAY
PARTITION ACT - SECTION 4 - APPLICABILITY - STRANGER PURCHASER SUING FOR PARTITION - CO-SHARERS CLAIMING PARTITION OF THEIR SHARES ... In cases, of partition instituted at the instance of the stranger-purchaser where all the other co-sharers also claim to partition ... off their shares as well, the right of pre-emption will stand extinguished, because in that case the object, viz.. maintenance of ... claim allotment of their shares and where the purchaser is also a pa....
Filter by Legal Phrase
