AI Overview...
- Copyrightable Content - Main points and insights:
- Content must meet the criteria of originality and creativity to qualify as copyrightable. Works like question papers, photographs, and merchandise bearing trademarks are recognized as copyrightable RUPENDRA KASHYAP VS JIWAN PUBLISHING HOUSE PRIVATE LIMITED - Delhi, Giant Rocket Media And Entertainment Pvt Ltd VS Priyanka Ghatak - Delhi.
- Simple slogans or common phrases (e.g., Shauq Badi Cheez Hai) are not copyrightable due to lack of originality Godfrey Phillips India Ltd. VS Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. - Delhi.
- The sweat of the brow doctrine, which awarded copyright based on effort, has shifted towards requiring a modicum of creativity, meaning not all efforts qualify Giant Rocket Media And Entertainment Pvt Ltd VS Priyanka Ghatak - Delhi.
- Trademarked content, such as logos and brand-specific merchandise, are protected under copyright law, especially when used without authorization, including counterfeit goods and online advertisements World Wrestling Entertainment, Inc. VS Savio Fernandes - Delhi, WORLD WRESTLING ENTERTAINMENT, INC. vs SAVIO FERNANDES & ORS - Delhi, WORLD WRESTLING ENTERTAINMENT, INC. vs SAVIO FERNANDES & ORS - Delhi.
- The ownership and rights in broadcast content depend on licensing agreements and territorial restrictions, with the content provider holding the rights and controlling its use, including advertisements inserted during broadcasts Dish TV India Ltd. VS Gulf DTH FZ LLC - Delhi, GULF DTH FZ LLC VS DISHTV INDIA LIMITED - Delhi, GULF DTH FZ LLC VS DISHTV INDIA LIMITED - Delhi.
- Question papers, as compilations of questions, are copyrightable, provided they involve some originality in form and content RUPENDRA KASHYAP VS JIWAN PUBLISHING HOUSE PRIVATE LIMITED - Delhi.
-
Rights related to broadcasting are governed by specific provisions under the Copyright Act, and media companies often operate under consent or licensing agreements that may limit liability SANJAY KUAMR GUPTA VS SONY PICTURES NETWORKS INDIA P. LTD. - Delhi.
-
Analysis and Conclusion:
- Copyright protection is granted to original works that demonstrate a minimal level of creativity, including literary works, photographs, and certain compilations.
- Mere effort or compilation without originality does not suffice for copyright.
- Trademarked and copyrighted content, especially in commercial contexts like merchandise and online advertisements, require proper authorization for use.
- Legal disputes often involve assessing originality, ownership, and licensing rights, with courts emphasizing the importance of these factors in determining copyrightability and infringement.
- Overall, copyright law aims to protect the rights of creators and owners of original content while balancing issues of originality, effort, and fair use.
References: - RUPENDRA KASHYAP VS JIWAN PUBLISHING HOUSE PRIVATE LIMITED - Delhi, Godfrey Phillips India Ltd. VS Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. - Delhi, Dish TV India Ltd. VS Gulf DTH FZ LLC - Delhi, GULF DTH FZ LLC VS DISHTV INDIA LIMITED - Delhi, GULF DTH FZ LLC VS DISHTV INDIA LIMITED - Delhi, Giant Rocket Media And Entertainment Pvt Ltd VS Priyanka Ghatak - Delhi, World Wrestling Entertainment, Inc. VS Savio Fernandes - Delhi, SANJAY KUAMR GUPTA VS SONY PICTURES NETWORKS INDIA P. LTD. - Delhi, WORLD WRESTLING ENTERTAINMENT, INC. vs SAVIO FERNANDES & ORS - Delhi, WORLD WRESTLING ENTERTAINMENT, INC. vs SAVIO FERNANDES & ORS - Delhi
Search Results for "Copyrightable Content"
2015 0 Supreme(Del) 4645 • India - Delhi
MANMOHAN SINGH
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the defendants' unauthorized use of the plaintiff's trademarks and copyrightable content ... The defendants were found to be selling counterfeit goods bearing the plaintiff's trademarks and copyrightable content without authorization ... Defendants were advertising the said products bearing the trademarks, logos and other copyrightable content of the plaintiff on the said websites. The website had also displayed a collage of various photographs bea....
2016 0 Supreme(Del) 3884 • India - Delhi
PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, PRATIBHA RANI
Whether mere insertion of different advertisement in the content results in two copyrightable contents would then become a matter of debate. In the absence of a written statement as of now, the appellant cannot even open up the debate. ... The ownership in the content of what is ultimately broadcasted is with the content provider and the content provider has the right to restrict the territory in which the broadcaster can broadcast the content under the license. ... M....
2017 0 Supreme(Del) 4722 • India - Delhi
S.P.GARG
Whether mere insertion of different advertisement in the content results in two copyrightable contents would then become a matter of debate. In the absence of a written statement as of now, the appellant cannot even open up the debate. ... 26. ... The cue to the possible defence was that the content holder provides signals of the broadcast to the respondent No.1 with advertisements, breaks etc. for the OSN Territories and the same content holder provides signal of the broadcast to the appellant with adv....
2017 0 Supreme(Del) 4736 • India - Delhi
S.P.GARG
Whether mere insertion of different advertisement in the content results in two copyrightable contents would then become a matter of debate. In the absence of a written statement as of now, the appellant cannot even open up the debate. ... 26. ... The cue to the possible defence was that the content holder provides signals of the broadcast to the respondent No.1 with advertisements, breaks etc. for the OSN Territories and the same content holder provides signal of the broadcast to the appellant with adv....
1993 0 Supreme(Del) 725 • India - Delhi
MAHINDER NARAIN
Whether the question papers are copyrightable subject matter. 2. ... Question papers are copyrightable subject matter as they are a compilation of questions requiring answers from examinees, akin to ... The court held that question papers are copyrightable subject matter as they are a compilation of questions requiring answers from ... ; photographs are copyrightable too. ... ... ( 26 ) THE form and content of the question paper which is on record of this Court, is something which is registerable unde....
• India - Delhi High Court
There were approximately 1300 merchandise articles bearing the WWE logo, trademarks and other copyrightable content available at the said store. ... Defendants were advertising the said products bearing the trademarks, logos and other copyrightable content of the plaintiff on the said websites. ... The defendant No.1 is the proprietor of the defendant No. 2 and 3, who are engaged in selling apparel and merchandise bearing the registered trademark WWEand other copyrightable cont....
• India - Delhi High Court
There were approximately 1300 merchandise articles bearing the WWE logo, trademarks and other copyrightable content available at the said store. ... Defendants were advertising the said products bearing the trademarks, logos and other copyrightable content of the plaintiff on the said websites. ... The defendant No.1 is the proprietor of the defendant No. 2 and 3, who are engaged in selling apparel and merchandise bearing the registered trademark WWEand other copyrightable cont....
2020 0 Supreme(Del) 1230 • India - Delhi
RAJIV SAHAI ENDLAW
It noted that the book's content may not qualify as an original literary work and that the plaintiff did not plead any similarity ... It was held that while under the "sweat of the brow" doctrine copyright was conferred on works merely because time energy skill and labour was expended, now under the "modicum of creativity" standard not every effort or industry or expending of skill results in copyrightable work but only those which ... Techno Plast, (2016) 233 DLT 1 held that the content of what is "original" has undergone considerable ch....
2012 0 Supreme(Del) 1635 • India - Delhi
A.K.PATHAK
Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that the slogans were not copyrightable as they were common phrases, and the advertisements ... Finding of the Court: The court found that the slogans 'Shauq Badi Cheez Hai' and 'Swad Badi Cheez Hai' were not copyrightable ... There is nothing original in this slogan which is not copyrightable. ... That apart, the slogans, in my view, are not copyrightable. Plaintiff can at best press for a passing off action by making out a case in its favor. ... 3. 16. ... The next question whi....
2018 0 Supreme(Del) 2754 • India - Delhi
VALMIKI J.MEHTA
rights or broadcasting rights (Chapter VIII Sections 37 to 39A) and only which are then copyrightable issues as per the Copyright Act, 1957. ... The Plaintiffs were asked to sign a consent letter. A consent letter in the television industry allegedly releases the media houses from any liability in case they broadcast content that is similar to the concept note that is being presented before them. ... The Plaintiffs in their own pleadings under Para 13 of the Plaint have stated the effects of signing a consent#H....
Filter by Legal Phrase
