The Supreme Court of India on Friday declined a request to urgently list an application seeking the recall of a prior judicial decision that referred petitions challenging the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023 , to a five-judge Constitution Bench . A three-judge bench, presided over by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and including Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, held that the application for recall, along with any challenges directed at the validity of the reference order, must be presented before the five-judge bench already tasked with hearing the underlying constitutional challenge.

The matter centers on a split verdict delivered on September 23, 2026 , by a two-judge bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma. That bench had been deliberating whether the constitutional validity of the 2023 legislation, which dictates the selection criteria for the Election Commission of India , necessitated a review by a larger Constitution Bench . While Justice Datta found no constitutional barrier preventing the two-judge bench from adjudicating the matter, Justice Sharma dissented, arguing that the law involved substantial questions of constitutional interpretation that required a broader judicial panel . Ultimately, both judges agreed to refer the matter to the Chief Justice for the constitution of a larger bench.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan , representing the petitioners, urged the Court to list the recall application before the original two-judge bench. He argued that the application was fundamentally predicated on the argument that Justice Sharma should have recused himself due to a conflict of interest , specifically citing that the Justice’s son serves as the standing counsel for the Election Commission of India before the Madhya Pradesh High Court . Bhushan contended that because the reference order was born out of a process involving a judge who should have been excluded, the recall plea ought to be heard by the same panel to rectify the initial procedural error.

Navigating Procedural Deadlocks and Recusal Claims

The application for recall asserts that the participation of Justice Sharma created a “ reasonable apprehension of bias and propriety ” concerning the statutory framework governing the appointment of top electoral officials. The petitioners have argued that given the direct nature of the challenge against the 2023 Act, any judicial involvement from a person with close professional ties to the defendant body—the Election Commission—is legally untenable under established principles of judicial conduct .

During the proceedings on Friday , the Chief Justice of India noted that the administrative duty of forming the Constitution Bench had already been completed and that the five-judge panel now possesses the necessary authority to deliberate on all ancillary issues, including the validity of the reference itself. When Bhushan emphasized that the reference order was a result of Justice Sharma's dissent and urged for a listing before the original bench ahead of Justice Sharma's retirement at the end of next week, the Chief Justice remained firm. The bench observed that the five-judge assembly is well-positioned to address whether the reference order should be set aside, even in the event of a judge's retirement.

“My role was only to constitute the bench,” the Chief Justice stated, clarifying that the procedural path forward lay with the assigned Constitution Bench rather than the original two-judge formation. Justice Bagchi further observed that the five-judge bench is fully empowered to evaluate the legitimacy of the reference order alongside the primary challenge to the 2023 Act.

The Evolution of the 2023 Election Act Challenge

The underlying legal conflict stems from the 2023 Act, which mandates that the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners be appointed by the President upon the recommendation of a selection committee. This committee includes the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, and a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. Petitioners have challenged Sections 7 and 8 of this Act, arguing that the exclusion of a neutral member from the selection committee undermines the spirit of free and fair elections, a concept previously discussed in judicial precedents regarding the institutional independence of the Election Commission.

The hearings held earlier this year saw extensive arguments from both the Attorney General and the Solicitor General, who had questioned the maintainability of the case before a two-judge bench, citing Article 145(3) of the Constitution . This article provides that cases involving substantial questions of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution must be heard by a bench of at least five judges. Justice Datta, in his opinion on September 23, had maintained that the 2023 Act, while introducing new elements to the legal landscape, could be analyzed using existing constitutional principles without requiring a Constitution Bench . Conversely, Justice Sharma had argued that the question of whether Parliament is justified in changing the composition of the selection committee was a novel and substantial question of constitutional law.

Future Path for the Constitution Bench

By directing the petitioners to approach the five-judge bench, the Supreme Court has effectively signaled that the question of the reference order’s validity is now inextricably linked to the main constitutional challenge. The legal team for the petitioners must now prepare to argue the issue of judicial propriety and the specific conflict-of-interest allegations as a preliminary point before the Constitution Bench when the matter is next heard.

The refusal to grant an urgent, separate listing before the original two-judge bench underscores the Court’s emphasis on institutional efficiency and its reliance on the hierarchical structure of bench assignments. As the legal community watches, the focus now shifts toward how the five-judge bench will address the allegations of bias and whether it will proceed with the constitutional examination of the 2023 Act or first dedicate time to resolve the controversy surrounding the initial referral process. The resolution of this matter remains a pivotal moment for the judiciary's role in interpreting the legal frameworks that govern the administration of democratic elections in India.