The has issued notice on a challenging the ’s August ruling that invalidated critical sections of the , while simultaneously providing immediate relief to litigants by ordering that pending proceedings under the law shall not be dismissed or . The bench, comprising Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar, clarified that the regarding ongoing rent disputes will remain preserved until the matter is heard again in the new year.
The order, passed on , serves as a crucial interim measure for landlords and tenants whose or were left in legal limbo following the High Court’s decision. By directing that these proceedings should not be treated as due to the , the has effectively stalled the immediate consequences of the High Court’s judgment, which had previously held that several key provisions of the 2021 Act were .
The had declared Sections 8, 9, 10, 38, and 42 of the state Act , effective from the date of its , judgment. The division bench of the High Court had reasoned that these provisions, which govern rent revision and bar , stood in direct conflict with the central , and the . Because the 2021 Act lacked specific required under to override such central legislation, the High Court concluded that the state law could not prevail in its current form.
The petitioners, representing landlords seeking to enforce tenancy terms under the 2021 framework, contend that the High Court failed to establish a direct, irreconcilable conflict between the state and central statutes. They have argued that the 2021 Act functions as a supplement to existing laws by providing a streamlined forum for disputes, rather than a contradiction. According to the challenge brought before the , the petitioners further argue that the High Court’s decision to allow the to "spring back to life" is legally unsustainable, as a act cannot be revived by .
A primary contention raised in the petition is that the High Court exercised a power akin to " "—a prerogative the petitioners argue is reserved exclusively for the . The appellants suggest that the High Court’s subsequent clarifications in October essentially functioned as a review, further complicating the procedural landscape for landlords who had acted in under the new . In the case directly affected, shop tenants had been ordered to vacate in based on a , a directive that was subsequently challenged and then quashed by the High Court in line with its broader ruling against the 2021 Act.
The legal uncertainty created by the High Court’s invalidation of Section 38, which bars civil courts from hearing matters covered by the Act, had left many litigants unsure of whether their cases should be transferred or abandoned. The 's intervention ensures that these matters remain active while the apex court considers whether the state legislature acted within its competence. The Court noted in its proceedings: “Issue notice to the respondent(s), however, proceedings pending under the relevant provision of UP Regulation of Urban Premises Tenancy Act, 2021, shall not be dismissed as not maintainable or , on account of the , during pendency of this .”
The dispute involves significant complexities regarding the intersection of state-level tenancy reforms and central property laws. By protecting pending petitions, the has signaled that the practical administrative consequences of the High Court's ruling are to be held in abeyance while the constitutional questions are fully explored. This provides a temporary shield for various stakeholders who had initiated eviction or rent revision applications under the 2021 Act, preventing a wholesale collapse of cases filed over the last few years.
The matter has been formally scheduled for further hearing on . Until that date, the has granted the petitioners permission to serve notice to the respondents through , ensuring that all parties are properly joined for the next round of arguments. The outcome of this appeal will likely settle the long-standing debate over the extent to which states can legislate on urban rent and eviction matters when such laws interface with established central statutes. For now, the legal proceedings that were initiated under the 2021 Act remain protected from dismissal, maintaining the existing framework for property disputes across the state.
urban rental regulation - landlord tenant litigation