The has directed the to submit an confirming whether the agency attempted to serve the on leader Azam Khan during his apprehension on . This development follows intense arguments between the and the ’s legal team regarding the procedural adherence to constitutional safeguards during the arrest, which took place shortly after the leader was granted in a separate case.
A comprising Justice Rajiv Gupta and Justice Devendra Singh issued the order after the maintained that its officers made multiple attempts to provide the required documents, which the former Uttar Pradesh Minister allegedly refused to accept. The Court has now instructed the agency to formally place its version of events on record through a sworn , effectively postponing any until .
The legal challenge centers on the arrest of Azam Khan just 40 minutes after he was released from the Rampur district jail, where he had been held in connection with a dual PAN card case. The took him into custody following a money laundering probe initiated by the central agency regarding financial irregularities linked to the .
Procedural Disputes and Constitutional Safeguards
During the hearing, senior advocate , representing the , argued that the failure to communicate the to his client rendered the entire detention illegal. Sibal contended that the authorities were orchestrating a campaign of " " rather than , citing a pattern of successive criminal cases initiated against his client whenever he neared the prospect of being released from custody.
Sibal specifically raised concerns about the timing of the ’s action, noting that the Enforcement Case Information Report was registered in , yet the arrest did not occur until several years later. He further suggested that the allegations of land occupation were moot, as the disputed agricultural land had been returned to the original farmers.
In response, the , represented by Additional Solicitor General and senior advocate , vehemently denied accusations of political motivation. The agency informed the Court that its assistant director had repeatedly tried to serve the , and that this refusal by the amounted to " " with the law. To substantiate this, the agency claimed to have video recordings, a , and other contemporaneous records demonstrating that the was informed of the reasons for his arrest.
The agency further asserted that the and the “ ” were provided to the within 12 to 14 hours during his appearance before the . Relying on established judicial precedents, the argued that the law allows for communication of arrest grounds within 24 hours of detention, provided that the agency has made a good-faith effort to do so.
The Conflict Over Evidence
The courtroom discussion turned on the interpretation of available visual evidence. While the presented video footage as proof that the arrest grounds were indeed offered to the , his legal team challenged the validity of this evidence. Sibal argued that the recordings did not clearly show the officer informing the of his right to the documents, nor did they conclusively demonstrate a deliberate refusal on the part of the leader.
The Court, seeking to resolve this factual deadlock, pressed for a definitive statement. Justice Rajiv Gupta remarked during the proceedings that the agency’s claims must be formally documented to be considered as evidence, stating,
"Let it be on record on an
that yes, it was offered, and you deny it. We will pass appropriate orders tomorrow."
Context of the Ongoing Investigation
The investigation by the into the involves allegations that funds and materials meant for public projects were diverted to the university campus. The agency alleges that government works were executed on private property and that financial contributions from contractors were routed back to the trust as donations.
Throughout the proceedings, the ’s counsel argued that the attachment of university properties valued at approximately ₹500 crore, based on allegations concerning only 1.552 hectares of land, was disproportionate and intended to cause professional and personal harm. Conversely, the maintained that the restoration of land to farmers does not absolve the accused of potential violations under the , asserting that the probe involves substantial financial irregularities exceeding the specific land dispute.
The case has been listed for a follow-up hearing on . The outcome of this session is expected to clarify whether the Court considers the 's efforts sufficient to satisfy the constitutional requirements mandated under . For the time being, the remains in , and the Court has refrained from passing any until the agency's is submitted for scrutiny. The legal community is closely watching this matter, as it will likely further refine the standards for procedural compliance during arrests made under the .
money laundering probe - constitutional safeguards - arrest procedure - judicial custody - Article 22