The High Court of Judicature at Madras has dismissed a plea filed by Ms Rajkumar Theatres Private Limited seeking to restrain the further exhibition and exploitation of the Hindi film Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion , including its release on over-the-top (OTT) platforms. Justice P.B. Balaji, presiding over the matter, held that the applicant’s second attempt to secure an injunction failed because an earlier order denying the same relief—following a petition under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996—had already attained finality. The Court observed that the applicant could not simply abandon arbitration proceedings and initiate a new civil suit to re-litigate the same issues using the same documentation.

The dispute stems from a series of agreements concerning the adaptation rights of the original 2013 Malayalam film Dhrishyam , produced by Aashirvad Cinema and directed by Jeethu Joseph. In December 2013, the creators granted Wide Angle Creations exclusive rights to remake, dub, and adapt the film, including its sequels and prequels, specifically for Hindi and other North Indian languages. Following this, Wide Angle Creations entered into a joint development agreement with the applicant, Rajkumar Theatres, in 2014. These rights were later sub-assigned to third parties, including Digital 18 Media (Star Studio 18).

The conflict intensified when Aashirvad Cinema and Jeethu Joseph entered into a separate agreement in November 2025 with Panorama Studios, granting them the rights to produce a new Hindi adaptation under the title Dhrishyam 3 . Rajkumar Theatres argued that the original creators had already exhausted their rights to assign sequel production after the initial 2013 grant, and that the new film infringed upon the exclusive rights they held as co-producers. However, the respondents maintained that the film Dhrishyam: The Conclusion was an entirely independent work, representing a new adaptation that did not overlap with the specific rights assigned to the applicant.

In its assessment, the Court focused on the principle of res judicata, noting that the applicant had previously filed an application under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act against the same respondents, seeking the same injunctive relief. That application was heard and dismissed on its merits on October 1, 2026, just before the film’s theatrical release. Justice P.B. Balaji emphasized that the legal foundation for the applicant's current claim was essentially a reiteration of earlier arguments that had already been adjudicated upon.

“I have already discussed as to how in both the Section 9 application as well as in the present original application, the parties are the same, the relief sought for is the same, and the documents relied on are also the same,” the Court noted in its order. By choosing to abandon the arbitration route and failing to appeal the initial adverse order, the applicant was deemed unable to renew the injunction request. The Court highlighted that the applicant's conduct in impleading the same parties and relying on the identical four core agreements established a clear pattern that precluded a fresh grant of equitable relief.

The Court further addressed the contention regarding the "subsisting rights" of the applicant. Upon a conjoint reading of the four relevant agreements, Justice Balaji concluded that the applicant failed to prove a prima facie case. The agreements revealed that the applicant’s interest was limited to specific commercial exploitation rather than total copyright ownership. The Court observed, “The applicant/plaintiff has not prima facie been able to satisfy me as to how they had a subsisting right to prevent the original copyright owners from assigning the adaptation rights in favour of the respondents 4 and 5.”

Moreover, the Court scrutinized the promotional materials and the film's title. While the applicant raised concerns regarding the film’s marketing as a sequel to the Dhrishyam series, the Court observed that the official Censor Certificate identified the film as Dhrishyam: The Conclusion . This, the Court reasoned, indicated a deliberate departure from the earlier film series. Furthermore, the Court noted that the agreement between the original producers and Panorama Studios explicitly recognized that the assignee had developed a modified storyline, over which the original creators retained specific boundaries, thereby further distinguishing the new film from the earlier works over which the applicant claimed rights.

Justice Balaji also dismissed the notion that the court should interfere with a high-budget production without compelling evidence of harm. Citing the balance of convenience, the Court stated that granting an injunction would result in massive financial losses not only to the producers but to multiple stakeholders involved in the film’s distribution and streaming. “A movie is a big budget film, and even if it is prima facie found that there is a Copyright infringement and would result in huge financial losses as production of the movie involves multiple stakeholders, all of whom would be adversely affected by an interim injunction,” the order noted.

While the Court acknowledged the applicant's argument that they were initially unaware of the specific nature of the respondents' agreements, it held that this did not justify ignoring the binding nature of the previous interlocutory order. The court emphasized that consistent judicial approach requires that similar matters receive similar treatment to ensure predictability. Because the applicant failed to demonstrate exceptional new circumstances or a shift in the factual matrix that would necessitate a different outcome, the request for a temporary injunction was denied.

The ruling leaves the matter open for trial regarding the substantive claims, but for the present, the Court has refused to impede the film's exploitation on OTT and digital platforms. The application stands dismissed without costs, and the litigation will continue to proceed in its normal course for a final determination on the ownership of copyright and potential infringement claims in the main suit.